| #1 - Posted 6 August 2009, 12:01 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: August 2009 Member #: 3311 Posts: 37 | A Question for my Dominican Brothers (And Sisters to lol) LONG QUESTION BE PREPARED TO READ Disclaimer: The contents of this paragraph may have material which may offend. If you are one who is easily angered or will act brashly do to its offensiveness please refrain from reading it. Viewer discretion advised. But I'm not trying to make anyone mad. I am honestly trying to ask what I believe to be relevant and genuine questions. As I have surfed the net, spoken to people, and just watch actions of the Dominican government, I and I'm sure millions of others have recognized the absurd amount of resentment and racism Dominicans harbor against Haitians. I mean I look at this forum and I see threads which talk about Haitians in a very degrading manner. I see the same thing on other Dominican forums and EVEN HAITIAN Forums were Dominicans go on and insult Haitians for no reason at all. My question. Why? What has Haiti done to you that is so bad that you must bash us constantly? For what reason? Is it because of Jean-Pierre Boyer's union of Santo Domingo and Haiti in 1822 and the twenty two years of a united Hispanola which followed? Do you guys feel in angst against us because of this? If so, I will acknowledge that there were atrocities which took place during this time period however, this occupation was necessary for the definitive end of slavery in DR. If Haiti hadn't occupied it then Dominicans would have been enslaved for a much longer time and possibly be farther behind in their social and economic developments than they are today. Now as a Haitian American I do understand how (and this if Dominicans have problems against Haitians because of the 22yr occup.) you might hold resentment against Haiti because of this occupation. This is because I understand how African Americans feel about our 465yr (that’s not including the 89yrs which followed with segregation) enslavement to Europeans. Despite the fact the Santo Domingo was not under Haitian rule for even a fraction of the time, I will still give you that. Although free today, the actions of the past are hard to forget. HOWEVER, once released in 1844 Dominicans were free to form their own nation with very little tampering from the Haitian side. On the other hand once freed AA were subjected to another system of oppression. It has been only been 44 yrs since the end of Jim Crow. I have family who REMEBERS BEING OPRESSED. Therefore if there were to be any resentment against white Americans in an African Americans case, although we must forgive and it would be wrong, it would still be totally founded. 44yrs ago in DR, the people were only 5 yrs out of Trujillo's horrible regime. However the difference. TRUJILLO WAS A FELLOW DOMINCAN WHO OPRESSED OTHER DOMINICANS. It was not like a Haitian was oppressing you guys. Besides Haiti during this time period was to with its own problems to even worry about the DR. Besides any resentment you did have with Haiti should have been left behind in the 1937 Parsley Massacre were Trujillo INVADED Haitian land and killed an estimated 30,000 Haitians. As horrible as it is, I would think that would be a sort of a pay back for the 22yrs (even though it had been for the good of the Dominicans) Yet their is still resentment today. Despite the fact during Trujillo's era, even beyond the massacre there were still more revenge against the Haitians. e.g. (Antihaitinismo) So all and all haven't you gotten back for the "atrocities" we Haitians supposedly committed against you guys?? That being said if its not the 22yrs thing is it about race? Yes yes the Haitians did hold resentment towards the mulatto elite. Since there were more mulattos on the Dominican side thus there may have been more racism on the Haitian's part, against them. (This is within that 22yrs im talking about because after that Haiti really did keep to itself) Yet, you have to remember that the mulattos or the lighter guys were the ones running the show and alot of times it meant that us Haitians, black Haitians, were at the scum dirt bottom of any agenda they may have had. That still prevalent today. Why does that still exist. I mean for the most part all of you guys are of African decent. European Middle Eastern and Asian Dominicans included because of the ancestral ties to Africa and the beginning of human life. (hey that’s fact don't blame me) Yet for those of you with visible strains of African influence why discriminate against some one who has a darker skin tone than you? Were all one and the same. I mean as much as some Dominicans don't like it, its true. Why deny it? And if there is resentment today against Haitians because of the current immigration problem... WHAT ARE YOU WORRIED ABOUT? Yes they come in illegally, but if they didn't come I am positive that the Dominican economy would not be as well off as it is today. I mean its the same with Mexicans and other migrant workers from central America in the United States. Without their contribution, the US economy would lose some serious profit. Besides how are Haitians "Invading" other than the fact they are moving into Dominican cities. What your scared that their presence would lead to you or your family losing their jobs? What most barely know how to read or write. Heck most can't even speak Spanish. Obviously, that shouldn't be a worry for you guys. The simple fact that you have access to a computer and are partaking in discussions in this forum lets me know to some extent you are well off enough not to be cutting sugar cane in the fields. So what is this?? I laid it out the best that I know of. If there is some reason that I am unaware of for Dominican resentment please tell me SORRY FOR THE LONG POST LOL |
Post IP: 74.190.63.3* | |
| Advertisement | |
Sponsored Links | |
| #2 - Posted 6 August 2009, 12:51 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: March 2009 Member #: 2380 Posts: 1196 | RE: A Question for my Dominican Brothers (And Sisters to lol) LONG QUESTION BE PREPARED TO READ Quote: AyMouno previously said: Disclaimer: The contents of this paragraph may have material which may offend. If you are one who is easily angered or will act brashly do to its offensiveness please refrain from reading it. Viewer discretion advised. But I'm not trying to make anyone mad. I am honestly trying to ask what I believe to be relevant and genuine questions. As I have surfed the net, spoken to people, and just watch actions of the Dominican government, I and I'm sure millions of others have recognized the absurd amount of resentment and racism Dominicans harbor against Haitians. I mean I look at this forum and I see threads which talk about Haitians in a very degrading manner. I see the same thing on other Dominican forums and EVEN HAITIAN Forums were Dominicans go on and insult Haitians for no reason at all. My question. Why? What has Haiti done to you that is so bad that you must bash us constantly? For what reason? Is it because of Jean-Pierre Boyer's union of Santo Domingo and Haiti in 1822 and the twenty two years of a united Hispanola which followed? Do you guys feel in angst against us because of this? If so, I will acknowledge that there were atrocities which took place during this time period however, this occupation was necessary for the definitive end of slavery in DR. If Haiti hadn't occupied it then Dominicans would have been enslaved for a much longer time and possibly be farther behind in their social and economic developments than they are today. Now as a Haitian American I do understand how (and this if Dominicans have problems against Haitians because of the 22yr occup.) you might hold resentment against Haiti because of this occupation. This is because I understand how African Americans feel about our 465yr (that’s not including the 89yrs which followed with segregation) enslavement to Europeans. Despite the fact the Santo Domingo was not under Haitian rule for even a fraction of the time, I will still give you that. Although free today, the actions of the past are hard to forget. HOWEVER, once released in 1844 Dominicans were free to form their own nation with very little tampering from the Haitian side. On the other hand once freed AA were subjected to another system of oppression. It has been only been 44 yrs since the end of Jim Crow. I have family who REMEBERS BEING OPRESSED. Therefore if there were to be any resentment against white Americans in an African Americans case, although we must forgive and it would be wrong, it would still be totally founded. 44yrs ago in DR, the people were only 5 yrs out of Trujillo's horrible regime. However the difference. TRUJILLO WAS A FELLOW DOMINCAN WHO OPRESSED OTHER DOMINICANS. It was not like a Haitian was oppressing you guys. Besides Haiti during this time period was to with its own problems to even worry about the DR. Besides any resentment you did have with Haiti should have been left behind in the 1937 Parsley Massacre were Trujillo INVADED Haitian land and killed an estimated 30,000 Haitians. As horrible as it is, I would think that would be a sort of a pay back for the 22yrs (even though it had been for the good of the Dominicans) Yet their is still resentment today. Despite the fact during Trujillo's era, even beyond the massacre there were still more revenge against the Haitians. e.g. (Antihaitinismo) So all and all haven't you gotten back for the "atrocities" we Haitians supposedly committed against you guys?? That being said if its not the 22yrs thing is it about race? Yes yes the Haitians did hold resentment towards the mulatto elite. Since there were more mulattos on the Dominican side thus there may have been more racism on the Haitian's part, against them. (This is within that 22yrs im talking about because after that Haiti really did keep to itself) Yet, you have to remember that the mulattos or the lighter guys were the ones running the show and alot of times it meant that us Haitians, black Haitians, were at the scum dirt bottom of any agenda they may have had. That still prevalent today. Why does that still exist. I mean for the most part all of you guys are of African decent. European Middle Eastern and Asian Dominicans included because of the ancestral ties to Africa and the beginning of human life. (hey that’s fact don't blame me) Yet for those of you with visible strains of African influence why discriminate against some one who has a darker skin tone than you? Were all one and the same. I mean as much as some Dominicans don't like it, its true. Why deny it? And if there is resentment today against Haitians because of the current immigration problem... WHAT ARE YOU WORRIED ABOUT? Yes they come in illegally, but if they didn't come I am positive that the Dominican economy would not be as well off as it is today. I mean its the same with Mexicans and other migrant workers from central America in the United States. Without their contribution, the US economy would lose some serious profit. Besides how are Haitians "Invading" other than the fact they are moving into Dominican cities. What your scared that their presence would lead to you or your family losing their jobs? What most barely know how to read or write. Heck most can't even speak Spanish. Obviously, that shouldn't be a worry for you guys. The simple fact that you have access to a computer and are partaking in discussions in this forum lets me know to some extent you are well off enough not to be cutting sugar cane in the fields. So what is this?? I laid it out the best that I know of. If there is some reason that I am unaware of for Dominican resentment please tell me SORRY FOR THE LONG POST LOL "Trujillo INVADED Haitian land and killed an estimated 30,000 Haitians"."Yes they come in illegally, but if they didn't come I am positive that the Dominican economy would not be as well off as it is today. I mean its the same with Mexicans and other migrant workers from central America in the United States". whatever intentions you have in putting what you have just put i will not question. i will not question your sincerity. just to clarify here trujillo did not invade haitian land!!!! also for you to compare the possible results of d.r without haitians in comparison with the united states without mexicans and central americans needs further investigation from you. two totally different countries with different origens and ways on how both economies thrive. i think you need to also look at haiti and i challenge you to read the post on racism in haiti which i put. it is written by a haitian which he mentions racism is alive an well in haiti. im not here to deny antihaitianismo which is alive an well. i think their are many factors. more than the one sided arguments that many haitians come up with and do you know what that is? COLOR COLOR COLOR RACE RACE RACE. |
Post IP: 170.232.192.1* | |
| #3 - Posted 6 August 2009, 1:19 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: August 2009 Member #: 3311 Posts: 37 | RE: A Question for my Dominican Brothers (And Sisters to lol) LONG QUESTION BE PREPARED TO READ In 1937 Rafael Trujillo, in an event known as the Parsley Massacre ordered the Army to kill all Haitians on the Dominican side of the border; an estimated 17,000 to 35,000 Haitians were killed for approximately five days, from October 2, 1937 through October 8, 1937 I did read that post you mentioned (funny it was before you mentioned it to lol) and I'am very aware of the internal racism between Haitians themselves. I always found it funny how some of the lighter skinned Haitians would call themselves blanc despite the fact they were obviously neg lol. Its ridiculous anyhow and it is something that does need to end. I also know it is one of the reason Haiti is failing now because the small quote on quote blanc population is purposely suppressing the majority of the population. (Link below if you don’t believe. Very interesting dialogue between a moderator and an American business man about this oppression) however, when I did talk about Dominican racism against Haitians that was a very small part of my question. And I know it is more than a race thing, that was my whole point of stressing other factors than race. What I'm trying to figure out is why the resentment? http://multinationalmonitor.org/hyper/issues/1995/01/mm0195_10.html Edited on 8/6/2009 1:22 PM by AyMouno. |
Post IP: 74.190.63.3* | |
| #4 - Posted 6 August 2009, 1:20 PM | |
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo Join date: December 2007 Member #: 38 Posts: 4359 | RE: A Question for my Dominican Brothers (And Sisters to lol) LONG QUESTION BE PREPARED TO READ First off, Trujillo DID NOT invade haitian land, cuz' the massacres came AFTER he signed with the haitian government the final border agreements of 1936 (by which your country moved its borders eastward from the original 1777 borderline) and in which the DR LOST the Plateau Central to your country's uncontrolled populational growth (some 3,165 km2). And most of all, he committed the massacres after giving your people inside our borders an ULTIMATUM of three days to move your arses out of our land OR ELSE. Judging by the speedy way in which news travel islandwide, your assassinated countrymen really tempted their fate, cuz' by that time Trujillo had SEVEN YEARS on power, so they must have been pretty well acquainted of the lengths that he was capable of going to achieve his ends. I'm not glossing over this horrible tragedy, but if something must be said with all truthfulness, is that your countrymen had it coming, cuz' the massacres were not the surprise attack that the international media and some of your own intellectuals want to portray. Trujillo gave them an ultimatum, and when a blood-thirsty tyrant, with the power of a first class army backing him up, threatens you with anihilation if you don't comply with his wishes, the safest policy of all is TO RUN AS FAST AS YOUR LEGS CAN CARRY YOU. If you're going to defy a tyrant, you have to make yourselves sure that you're pretty well armed, or at least, have some safe retreats were to run to if/or when defeats against the tyranny's military forces occur. To act otherwise is complete madness, cuz' there's no turning back when the gauntlet of defiance is once thrown, you either kill the tyrant and his forces and prevail or prepare yourselves to be slaughtered. There's no middle ground. About comparing the DR with the US and Europe and our inmigration problem with your countrymen, this is the answer that I gave a fellow poster about the foolishness of that comparison: Quote: Alcides previously said: I'm LOVE mi tierra but I can't close my eyes, I just try o be objectif. About the "Muro", in this case why don't make the same in United States and Europe ? Like this, all the illegal people can't enter. Dominicanos inclued It's strong to have reaction like this. Only extremist people with a little-little brain can thinking these ideas. What are you doing out of your country (like me, I reconozise) ? Just try to have a better life... Lautaro answers: That might be so, but you have to recognize that we are NEITHER the US nor Europe (in fact, we're even light years away from some of our own latin american pals), we're a Third World country for God's sake, and as such, we can't give ourselves the luxury of being lax with our inmigrational issues with our neighbours to the west, specially if we consider the fact that we have the duty to attend FIRST to the needs of an estimated 4.5 million of poor people of our own. Until we fulfill (at least partially) the needs of our own poor, we can't accept the rejects of another society, unless we want to end up in a worse socioeconomic position than the one we already have, that is. You can play the racial card all you want, but that will not prevent me (and others) from seeing the reality as it is. En buen dominicano, no hay cama pa' tanta gente, tanto literal como figuradamente. This is all that I will be telling you about this "question", so carry on if you must. Edited on 8/6/2009 1:38 PM by Lautaro. “Since the two rarely come together, anyone compelled to choose will find greater security in being feared than in being loved.” Niccolo Machiavelli |
Post IP: 200.88.48.3* | |
| #5 - Posted 6 August 2009, 1:33 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: March 2009 Member #: 2380 Posts: 1196 | RE: A Question for my Dominican Brothers (And Sisters to lol) LONG QUESTION BE PREPARED TO READ Quote: AyMouno previously said: In 1937 Rafael Trujillo, in an event known as the Parsley Massacre ordered the Army to kill all Haitians on the Dominican side of the border; an estimated 17,000 to 35,000 Haitians were killed for approximately five days, from October 2, 1937 through October 8, 1937 I did read that post you mentioned (funny it was before you mentioned it to lol) and I'am very aware of the internal racism between Haitians themselves. I always found it funny how some of the lighter skinned Haitians would call themselves blanc despite the fact they were obviously neg lol. Its ridiculous anyhow and it is something that does need to end. I also know it is one of the reason Haiti is failing now because the small quote on quote blanc population is purposely suppressing the majority of the population. (Link below if you don’t believe. Very interesting dialogue between a moderator and an American business man about this oppression) however, when I did talk about Dominican racism against Haitians that was a very small part of my question. And I know it is more than a race thing, that was my whole point of stressing other factors than race. What I'm trying to figure out is why the resentment? http://multinationalmonitor.org/hyper/issues/1995/01/mm0195_10.html Do you ever notice the haitian resentment of dominican woman? refering to them as putas and prostitutes!!!! |
Post IP: 170.232.192.1* | |
| #6 - Posted 6 August 2009, 1:38 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: August 2009 Member #: 3311 Posts: 37 | RE: A Question for my Dominican Brothers (And Sisters to lol) LONG QUESTION BE PREPARED TO READ Ok for the immigration thing I will give you that. Because your right. Both Haiti and Dominican Republic are Third World countries. And before you can take care of others you got to take care of your own. Especially as a developing nation, you guys (or us for that matter lol) don't have the resources to take on another ailing population. It makes sense to me. The Trujilo part however.... it was 1937 and I believe that information did not travel as quickly as you would want me to belive, besides there are some areas where the Mountains dominate the border which I'am sure slowed the delivery of the mandate considerably and even if they had a 3 day warning they still had to move their ENTIRE LIVES to go to a land that they had left many years ago. So back home thier was no place and now their was no longer a place in DR. I'm sure many stayed because they just didn't know what to do. Now if Trujillo had given them 3 months-yr to evacuate every Haitian from the region then the Haitians would have it coming if they were their by the end of this time. But the man gave them 3 DAYS to move Hundreds of thousands of people who had already dug their roots in the country many years ago. Still though... Why the resentment? |
Post IP: 74.190.63.3* | |
| #7 - Posted 6 August 2009, 1:43 PM | |
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo Join date: December 2007 Member #: 38 Posts: 4359 | RE: A Question for my Dominican Brothers (And Sisters to lol) LONG QUESTION BE PREPARED TO READ Quote: AyMouno previously said: Ok for the immigration thing I will give you that. Because your right. Both Haiti and Dominican Republic are Third World countries. And before you can take care of others you got to take care of your own. Especially as a developing nation, you guys (or us for that matter lol) don't have the resources to take on another ailing population. It makes sense to me. The Trujilo part however.... it was 1937 and I believe that information did not travel as quickly as you would want me to belive, besides there are some areas where the Mountains dominate the border which I'am sure slowed the delivery of the mandate considerably and even if they had a 3 day warning they still had to move their ENTIRE LIVES to go to a land that they had left many years ago. So back home thier was no place and now their was no longer a place in DR. I'm sure many stayed because they just didn't know what to do. Now if Trujillo had given them 3 months-yr to evacuate every Haitian from the region then the Haitians would have it coming if they were their by the end of this time. But the man gave them 3 DAYS to move Hundreds of thousands of people who had already dug their roots in the country many years ago. Still though... Why the resentment? I think that the resentment comes from the fact that the big fish out there (US, UK, Canada and France) are using the plight of your countrymen on this country to further their agendas, mainly, to wash their hands out of the mess that their policies created on your country at the expense of our country. Their modus operandi on this is by the financing of the thousand-odd NGO's operating on both sides of the border. Surely you must be acquainted with Sonia Pierre by now, aren't you? The much noise they make about the matter, the worse off your countrymen will end up being in the long run, or at least that's how I see it, cuz' the people are getting mightily tired of seeing this country defamed without reason, specially when we consider the fact that your countrymen are a thousand times better off on this country than they will ever be on their own homeland right now. “Since the two rarely come together, anyone compelled to choose will find greater security in being feared than in being loved.” Niccolo Machiavelli |
Post IP: 200.88.48.3* | |
| #8 - Posted 6 August 2009, 1:45 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: August 2009 Member #: 3311 Posts: 37 | RE: A Question for my Dominican Brothers (And Sisters to lol) LONG QUESTION BE PREPARED TO READ What and are you aware of the Domincan people's resentment of Haitians as a whole? For just being Haitian and born on Hispanola? THey can be decent educated hard working people, but what are they to you all.? Barbaric voodu worshipers who use mud cakes as thier only source of sustenance. Your point? We can go tit-for tat for days but thats not my question. WHY THE RESENTMENT? |
Post IP: 74.190.63.3* | |
| #9 - Posted 6 August 2009, 1:46 PM | |
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo Join date: December 2007 Member #: 38 Posts: 4359 | RE: A Question for my Dominican Brothers (And Sisters to lol) LONG QUESTION BE PREPARED TO READ Quote: AyMouno previously said: What and are you aware of the Domincan people's resentment of Haitians as a whole? For just being Haitian and born on Hispanola? THey can be decent educated hard working people, but what are they to you all.? Barbaric voodu worshipers who use mud cakes as thier only source of sustenance. Your point? We can go tit-for tat for days but thats not my question. WHY THE RESENTMENT? See the answer above. “Since the two rarely come together, anyone compelled to choose will find greater security in being feared than in being loved.” Niccolo Machiavelli |
Post IP: 200.88.48.3* | |
| #10 - Posted 6 August 2009, 2:01 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: March 2009 Member #: 2380 Posts: 1196 | RE: A Question for my Dominican Brothers (And Sisters to lol) LONG QUESTION BE PREPARED TO READ Quote: AyMouno previously said: Ok for the immigration thing I will give you that. Because your right. Both Haiti and Dominican Republic are Third World countries. And before you can take care of others you got to take care of your own. Especially as a developing nation, you guys (or us for that matter lol) don't have the resources to take on another ailing population. It makes sense to me. The Trujilo part however.... it was 1937 and I believe that information did not travel as quickly as you would want me to belive, besides there are some areas where the Mountains dominate the border which I'am sure slowed the delivery of the mandate considerably and even if they had a 3 day warning they still had to move their ENTIRE LIVES to go to a land that they had left many years ago. So back home thier was no place and now their was no longer a place in DR. I'm sure many stayed because they just didn't know what to do. Now if Trujillo had given them 3 months-yr to evacuate every Haitian from the region then the Haitians would have it coming if they were their by the end of this time. But the man gave them 3 DAYS to move Hundreds of thousands of people who had already dug their roots in the country many years ago. Still though... Why the resentment? the problem is and i dont say this sacastically but haiti is not a third world nation but a fifth world nation. DR is third world. read the story on what was going on before the massacre when trujillo visited dajabon. he was informed by the peasents of the area that haitians were stealing cattle and they pressed him greatly. haitians have been stealing cattle, motoconchos, chooping trees on our side of the island. his methods were wrong of coarse but hopefully you understand the other side of the story. |
Post IP: 170.232.192.1* | |