Dominican Today Forum » Dominicans Abroad » Haiti » Why the U.S. and France Hate Haiti
#11 - Posted 16 October 2009, 10:28 PM
Location: Canada, Montreal
Join date: June 2009
Member #: 3003
Posts: 451
Send Message
RE: Why the U.S. and France Hate Haiti
Quote:
Belly previously said:

With all the presure that French put to their allies like USA, Canada they are still wondering why they still there. They probably hoped by now Haitians would had dissappear from the planet but to me it just proves that they have lost another fight against Haiti because 200 years after they still free. Now days they are starting to see a light with the help of DR and other countries calling for those who talk their talk to now walk the walk if they really want to help is either put up or shut-up. I was surprise to hear Leonel Fernandez the other days saying that a lot of those claiming that what to help Haiti have not done anything but talk trash. I'm not saying that Haiti is a paradise but i have been there almost 13 times and things are not as bad as the pictures you find on the web.

NGO my ass. They "gave" you money and take it again.


Haiti got to "walk alone" with out those " FRIEND" countries... The problem is that they are in all our institutions. They have acces to all Shantytowns of the country.. Who knows tomorrow if they will not take the Lagônave Island like they had tooken The Navassa Island. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Navassa_Island.
TN1804
Post IP/Country: 69.9.98.9* / CA
Advertisement
Sponsored Links
#12 - Posted 16 October 2009, 10:29 PM
Location: Canada, Montreal
Join date: June 2009
Member #: 3003
Posts: 451
Send Message
RE: Why the U.S. and France Hate Haiti
Quote:
Belly previously said:

Quote:
perlurdom previously said:

Quote:
Belly previously said:

Quote:
abc200 previously said:

Too true!
A country that the US destroyed by undercutting local rice farmers with subsidized rice so it could have a cheap labour force for which it has no further use - China is even cheaper.
S.


I wonder if now that they can get cheap labor or should i say new modern day cheap slaves then maybe Haiti has hope now. I wonder?



Belly,
I agree with the historical part of the report, however, for me it's hard to believe that : "For five centuries, the imperial powers have seen Haiti only as a dark, placid pool of super-cheap labor. Upon first becoming president, however, Aristide sought to raise Haiti's miserable minimum wage. A major no-no" What has been the benefit of the US or anyone in the neighborhood to keep 9M super-cheap labor locked in or trapped in Haiti? If US or France were looking for cheap labor there were and are better sources in Asia and Africa. Haiti's current condition is nothing different than 20+ former french colonies around the world, it cannot be just a coincidence; it sounds to me that the French made an excellent job denying their slaves access to basic education, a proven method of eroding leadership foundation. Balaguer tried to do something similar.


French did a good job at keeping people uneducated while they were ruling but history have shown us that once those underdog gain ground France is going to have a big problem because their biggest mistake was to pull out of those places completely and leave them with a real knowledge of the history. See Spaniards did a better job because even though they left they still have a big presence in their ex-colonies and have tried for a long time to sale their killers as heroes which some do believe but most are coming to find out the true about it now that they are growing. Yet most latin countries don't hate spaniards because of that same reason on the other hand every ex-colony of France don't want to hear nothing from them.


Samething for the ex british colonies. If you look.

All french colonies are all poor.
TN1804
Post IP/Country: 69.9.98.9* / CA
#13 - Posted 17 October 2009, 12:28 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, San Francisco and Houston,Texas
Join date: April 2009
Member #: 2555
Posts: 1243
Send Message
RE: Why the U.S. and France Hate Haiti
Quote:
Incognito previously said:

Quote:
Belly previously said:

With all the presure that French put to their allies like USA, Canada they are still wondering why they still there. They probably hoped by now Haitians would had dissappear from the planet but to me it just proves that they have lost another fight against Haiti because 200 years after they still free. Now days they are starting to see a light with the help of DR and other countries calling for those who talk their talk to now walk the walk if they really want to help is either put up or shut-up. I was surprise to hear Leonel Fernandez the other days saying that a lot of those claiming that what to help Haiti have not done anything but talk trash. I'm not saying that Haiti is a paradise but i have been there almost 13 times and things are not as bad as the pictures you find on the web.

NGO my ass. They "gave" you money and take it again.


Haiti got to "walk alone" with out those " FRIEND" countries... The problem is that they are in all our institutions. They have acces to all Shantytowns of the country.. Who knows tomorrow if they will not take the Lagônave Island like they had tooken The Navassa Island. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Navassa_Island.


i doutb US will steal more land from Haiti like the have with the Navassa island that would be too obvious and won't look good around the world. In my opinion Navassa island belongs to Haiti but what is Haiti going to do with it i just don't see the point of figthing for something that will have no use to Haiti. To me U.S.A is keeping this land just in case Puerto Rico becomes a independent country and they just won't have a place to put a military base in the area. Lagonave island will not be taken away well you never know what USA is thinking but i hope not.
Edited on 10/17/2009 12:29 PM by Belly.
Success is a journey of your life not a stage of your life! by Belly
Post IP/Country: 75.53.147.17* / US
#14 - Posted 17 October 2009, 12:32 PM
Location: United States
Join date: June 2009
Member #: 2977
Posts: 1492
Send Message
RE: Why the U.S. and France Hate Haiti
Quote:
Incognito previously said:

Quote:
Belly previously said:

Quote:
perlurdom previously said:

Quote:
Belly previously said:

Quote:
abc200 previously said:

Too true!
A country that the US destroyed by undercutting local rice farmers with subsidized rice so it could have a cheap labour force for which it has no further use - China is even cheaper.
S.


I wonder if now that they can get cheap labor or should i say new modern day cheap slaves then maybe Haiti has hope now. I wonder?



Belly,
I agree with the historical part of the report, however, for me it's hard to believe that : "For five centuries, the imperial powers have seen Haiti only as a dark, placid pool of super-cheap labor. Upon first becoming president, however, Aristide sought to raise Haiti's miserable minimum wage. A major no-no" What has been the benefit of the US or anyone in the neighborhood to keep 9M super-cheap labor locked in or trapped in Haiti? If US or France were looking for cheap labor there were and are better sources in Asia and Africa. Haiti's current condition is nothing different than 20+ former french colonies around the world, it cannot be just a coincidence; it sounds to me that the French made an excellent job denying their slaves access to basic education, a proven method of eroding leadership foundation. Balaguer tried to do something similar.


French did a good job at keeping people uneducated while they were ruling but history have shown us that once those underdog gain ground France is going to have a big problem because their biggest mistake was to pull out of those places completely and leave them with a real knowledge of the history. See Spaniards did a better job because even though they left they still have a big presence in their ex-colonies and have tried for a long time to sale their killers as heroes which some do believe but most are coming to find out the true about it now that they are growing. Yet most latin countries don't hate spaniards because of that same reason on the other hand every ex-colony of France don't want to hear nothing from them.


Samething for the ex british colonies. If you look.


You mean the United States of America, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, and India?
http://englishquisqueya.ning.com
Post IP/Country: 204.210.155.3* / US
#15 - Posted 17 October 2009, 3:02 PM
Location: Canada, Montreal
Join date: June 2009
Member #: 3003
Posts: 451
Send Message
RE: Why the U.S. and France Hate Haiti
Quote:
ElTorodeCibao previously said:

Quote:
Incognito previously said:

Quote:
Belly previously said:

Quote:
perlurdom previously said:

Quote:
Belly previously said:

Quote:
abc200 previously said:

Too true!
A country that the US destroyed by undercutting local rice farmers with subsidized rice so it could have a cheap labour force for which it has no further use - China is even cheaper.
S.


I wonder if now that they can get cheap labor or should i say new modern day cheap slaves then maybe Haiti has hope now. I wonder?



Belly,
I agree with the historical part of the report, however, for me it's hard to believe that : "For five centuries, the imperial powers have seen Haiti only as a dark, placid pool of super-cheap labor. Upon first becoming president, however, Aristide sought to raise Haiti's miserable minimum wage. A major no-no" What has been the benefit of the US or anyone in the neighborhood to keep 9M super-cheap labor locked in or trapped in Haiti? If US or France were looking for cheap labor there were and are better sources in Asia and Africa. Haiti's current condition is nothing different than 20+ former french colonies around the world, it cannot be just a coincidence; it sounds to me that the French made an excellent job denying their slaves access to basic education, a proven method of eroding leadership foundation. Balaguer tried to do something similar.


French did a good job at keeping people uneducated while they were ruling but history have shown us that once those underdog gain ground France is going to have a big problem because their biggest mistake was to pull out of those places completely and leave them with a real knowledge of the history. See Spaniards did a better job because even though they left they still have a big presence in their ex-colonies and have tried for a long time to sale their killers as heroes which some do believe but most are coming to find out the true about it now that they are growing. Yet most latin countries don't hate spaniards because of that same reason on the other hand every ex-colony of France don't want to hear nothing from them.


Samething for the ex british colonies. If you look.


You mean the United States of America, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, and India?

Look Jamaica,Trinadad,Dominica,India versus Senegal,Haiti,Congo...
TN1804
Post IP/Country: 69.9.98.9* / CA
#16 - Posted 17 October 2009, 3:03 PM
Location: Canada, Montreal
Join date: June 2009
Member #: 3003
Posts: 451
Send Message
RE: Why the U.S. and France Hate Haiti
Quote:
Belly previously said:

Quote:
Incognito previously said:

Quote:
Belly previously said:

With all the presure that French put to their allies like USA, Canada they are still wondering why they still there. They probably hoped by now Haitians would had dissappear from the planet but to me it just proves that they have lost another fight against Haiti because 200 years after they still free. Now days they are starting to see a light with the help of DR and other countries calling for those who talk their talk to now walk the walk if they really want to help is either put up or shut-up. I was surprise to hear Leonel Fernandez the other days saying that a lot of those claiming that what to help Haiti have not done anything but talk trash. I'm not saying that Haiti is a paradise but i have been there almost 13 times and things are not as bad as the pictures you find on the web.

NGO my ass. They "gave" you money and take it again.


Haiti got to "walk alone" with out those " FRIEND" countries... The problem is that they are in all our institutions. They have acces to all Shantytowns of the country.. Who knows tomorrow if they will not take the Lagônave Island like they had tooken The Navassa Island. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Navassa_Island.


i doutb US will steal more land from Haiti like the have with the Navassa island that would be too obvious and won't look good around the world. In my opinion Navassa island belongs to Haiti but what is Haiti going to do with it i just don't see the point of figthing for something that will have no use to Haiti. To me U.S.A is keeping this land just in case Puerto Rico becomes a independent country and they just won't have a place to put a military base in the area. Lagonave island will not be taken away well you never know what USA is thinking but i hope not.

Lagonave could be a good base for France. They are losing power in America.
TN1804
Post IP/Country: 69.9.98.9* / CA
#17 - Posted 17 October 2009, 3:30 PM
Location: United States, Brooklyn
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 40
Posts: 1396
Send Message
RE: Why the U.S. and France Hate Haiti
Quote:
Belly previously said:

Let's begin with 1492. Since that year, when it was "discovered," no country in the Caribbean has suffered more pain per capita than Haiti.

In the 15th century, according to Columbus, Haiti was an island paradise. Now it is an ecological disaster. In the 18th century, Haiti was the richest colony in the New World. Now it is the poorest nation in the Western Hemisphere.

In the early 1500s, Haiti's indigenous people, the Taino, were rendered extinct. Alien disease took its inevitable toll. But it was the Spanish obsession with gold and Columbus' brutal ways of extracting and extorting what little gold there was that sealed their fate.

Soon thousands of West Africans were imported every year to fill the labor vacuum. Africans, under the lash, were put to work raising indigo and then cane sugar. So savage was the slave regime, at first under the Spanish and then under the French, that a slave's life expectancy upon reaching Haiti was only several years. Slaves didn't live long enough to assimilate "Western civilization." To this day Haiti remains essentially an African country.

In the 1790's, the Afro-Haitians revolted. In 1804, led by the slave Toussaint L'Ouverture, the Africans succeeded in whupping Napolean's army and driving it off the island.

This was the world's first successful slave revolt. Ignored in our history books, it was an accomplishment as significant and as liberating as the French or U.S. revolutions.

Western civilization -- France and the other white colonial slave-holding powers -- has yet to forgive the Afro-Haitians. Like Sandinista Nicaragua and Castro's Cuba, liberating itself was Haiti's original sin. Two centuries later the forces of counter-liberation are still relentlessly applied against it.

For years, few nations would recognize Haiti's independence. The United States, despite the lofty sentiments of its founding documents, did not recognize Haiti until our own slave regime crumbled in the 1860s. France, despite the ideals of its 1789 revolution, would not recognize Haiti until it paid a crushing multi-million dollar indemnity.

In the Catholic theology of my youth, we are all born -- like Haiti -- with original sin. And many of us go on to commit grievous sins of our own. These are called mortal sins. In the last dozen or so years unrepentant Haiti and President Jean-Bertrand Aristide, whom it keeps electing, has committed a number of these. This is why the so-called "international community" -- especially the United States and France -- are determined to keep Haiti in hell.

In Haiti's 1992 presidential election the U.S.-financed candidate, Marc Bazin, was pre-ordained to win. At the last minute, however, a Catholic priest preaching liberation theology entered the race. Father Aristide won the election by a 67 percent landslide.

Within eight months, a U.S.-sponsored coup toppled Aristide. The next time Aristide stood for election -- in 2000 -- he won by an even greater share of the vote. And this was an election internationally certified as fair. Aristide was, and continues to be, the choice of the vast majority of Haiti's people.

But on February 29, 2004, Aristide was again overthrown. The U.S. military abducted Aristide at gunpoint, transporting him to the Central African Republic, one of the most isolated countries on the planet.

Why does the U.S. government hate Aristide so?

For five centuries, the imperial powers have seen Haiti only as a dark, placid pool of super-cheap labor. Upon first becoming president, however, Aristide sought to raise Haiti's miserable minimum wage. A major no-no.

Aristide kept up his offensive behavior. In 1994 when he returned from exile and resumed his presidency, he abolished Haiti's brutish military.

And, finally, consider this brazen deed. During his second term, Aristide sued France for reimbursement of the aforementioned indemnity. Aristide presented France with a bill -- corrected for inflation and with 5 percent interest compounded. The bill, still outstanding, totals $21 billion.

For the time being, President Aristide lives in South Africa. Aristide's party, Lavalas, has once again been forced underground. Even so, it insists there can be no elections in Haiti without the return of its president and the democratic constitutional order he embodies.

Source: http://www.commondreams.org/views05/0720-31.htm


A few things I have to say about this article....

When you say haiti, at the beginning you're also including DR, The Haiti we know today did not exist in the 1500 century. The colony then was called Santo Domingo, not haiti. Haiti as in Today's Haiti, can not claim any indegenous heritage, althought they often tried. It was Ovando that killed more Taino then Colon, remembers that columbus, was almost aways travelling. Though i still agree, he was an asshole.

The Haiti that we know today started off after the depopulation policy of the Spanish Empire towards santo Domingo... the 17th century the French found the easter side, with pleny of Cuero (animals) and no one around, depopulated of Spaniards and Indians, so you're right when you say that Haiti is an African Country.

Also, i was under the impression that Aristide abolished the Armed Forces because he feared them. Not because they were brutal... Which was a mistake nonthelest, the vacuum of power, has been filled in by corner-thugs and drug dealers.

Post IP/Country: 96.224.181.2* / US
#18 - Posted 17 October 2009, 4:25 PM
Location: United States
Join date: June 2009
Member #: 2977
Posts: 1492
Send Message
RE: Why the U.S. and France Hate Haiti
Quote:
Incognito previously said:

Quote:
ElTorodeCibao previously said:

Quote:
Incognito previously said:

Quote:
Belly previously said:

Quote:
perlurdom previously said:

Quote:
Belly previously said:

Quote:
abc200 previously said:

Too true!
A country that the US destroyed by undercutting local rice farmers with subsidized rice so it could have a cheap labour force for which it has no further use - China is even cheaper.
S.


I wonder if now that they can get cheap labor or should i say new modern day cheap slaves then maybe Haiti has hope now. I wonder?



Belly,
I agree with the historical part of the report, however, for me it's hard to believe that : "For five centuries, the imperial powers have seen Haiti only as a dark, placid pool of super-cheap labor. Upon first becoming president, however, Aristide sought to raise Haiti's miserable minimum wage. A major no-no" What has been the benefit of the US or anyone in the neighborhood to keep 9M super-cheap labor locked in or trapped in Haiti? If US or France were looking for cheap labor there were and are better sources in Asia and Africa. Haiti's current condition is nothing different than 20+ former french colonies around the world, it cannot be just a coincidence; it sounds to me that the French made an excellent job denying their slaves access to basic education, a proven method of eroding leadership foundation. Balaguer tried to do something similar.


French did a good job at keeping people uneducated while they were ruling but history have shown us that once those underdog gain ground France is going to have a big problem because their biggest mistake was to pull out of those places completely and leave them with a real knowledge of the history. See Spaniards did a better job because even though they left they still have a big presence in their ex-colonies and have tried for a long time to sale their killers as heroes which some do believe but most are coming to find out the true about it now that they are growing. Yet most latin countries don't hate spaniards because of that same reason on the other hand every ex-colony of France don't want to hear nothing from them.


Samething for the ex british colonies. If you look.


You mean the United States of America, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, and India?

Look Jamaica,Trinadad,Dominica,India versus Senegal,Haiti,Congo...


Oh I thought you were stating ex-British colonies were impoverished like ex-French colonies.
http://englishquisqueya.ning.com
Post IP/Country: 204.210.155.3* / US
#19 - Posted 17 October 2009, 4:57 PM
Location: United States
Join date: January 2009
Member #: 1932
Posts: 883
Send Message
RE: Why the U.S. and France Hate Haiti
Quote:
Belly previously said:

With all the presure that French put to their allies like USA, Canada they are still wondering why they still there. They probably hoped by now Haitians would had dissappear from the planet but to me it just proves that they have lost another fight against Haiti because 200 years after they still free. Now days they are starting to see a light with the help of DR and other countries calling for those who talk their talk to now walk the walk if they really want to help is either put up or shut-up. I was surprise to hear Leonel Fernandez the other days saying that a lot of those claiming that what to help Haiti have not done anything but talk trash. I'm not saying that Haiti is a paradise but i have been there almost 13 times and things are not as bad as the pictures you find on the web.

Interesting post and i had forgotten about Titi's ballsy bill to France!

I also find it curious how you'vve been to Haiti 13 times and " things are not as bad as the pictures you find on the web.", but in your visits to Cuba the conditions are 'unbearable' (was that the term you used?). I have been in Haiti only once and what I saw it was saddening!

As with all the people who have visited DR , Bavaro, Punta Cana, etc, they all say how beautiful our country is, and that is not a lie. As we nod in agreement, I always find myself thinking about the problems our own country has.
Post IP/Country: 71.206.78.19* / US
#20 - Posted 17 October 2009, 5:06 PM
Location: United States
Join date: August 2009
Member #: 3278
Posts: 301
Send Message
RE: Why the U.S. and France Hate Haiti
Quote:
Glimmertwin previously said:

Quote:
Belly previously said:

With all the presure that French put to their allies like USA, Canada they are still wondering why they still there. They probably hoped by now Haitians would had dissappear from the planet but to me it just proves that they have lost another fight against Haiti because 200 years after they still free. Now days they are starting to see a light with the help of DR and other countries calling for those who talk their talk to now walk the walk if they really want to help is either put up or shut-up. I was surprise to hear Leonel Fernandez the other days saying that a lot of those claiming that what to help Haiti have not done anything but talk trash. I'm not saying that Haiti is a paradise but i have been there almost 13 times and things are not as bad as the pictures you find on the web.

Interesting post and i had forgotten about Titi's ballsy bill to France!

I also find it curious how you'vve been to Haiti 13 times and " things are not as bad as the pictures you find on the web.", but in your visits to Cuba the conditions are 'unbearable' (was that the term you used?). I have been in Haiti only once and what I saw it was saddening!

As with all the people who have visited DR , Bavaro, Punta Cana, etc, they all say how beautiful our country is, and that is not a lie. As we nod in agreement, I always find myself thinking about the problems our own country has.


What part of Haiti did you go to..because if it was the capital then there's really no point in mentioning ever going to Haiti.....You will not experience Haiti if you only go to the capital....go to Jeremie or Jacmel...or any other small town in the south of Haiti that's where our true culture is...............and maybe a little bit up north to Cap Haitien.
Tout nèg ki renmen libète pa janm vle wè polis.-kreyòl-
Post IP/Country: 76.18.211.4* / US