Dominican Today Forum » Dominicans Abroad » Haiti » Haiti "restavek" tradition called child slavery
#1 - Posted 29 August 2010, 2:03 PM
Location: United States, Seattle, W.A.
Join date: April 2009
Member #: 2555
Posts: 3423
Send Message
Haiti "restavek" tradition called child slavery


By Jim Loney
PORT-AU-PRINCE | Thu Feb 18, 2010 9:17am EST

(Reuters) - Living in a tent after an earthquake left a million Haitians in the streets, Melila Thelusma says she cannot support her two daughters and is ready to give them away to foreigners if she can find a good home for them.

Despite her desperation, Thelusma said she would never turn 11-year-old Gaelle and 6-year-old Christelle over to a Haitian family, as tens of thousands of other poor parents have done.

"Not a Haitian family. Haitians will make them suffer," Thelusma, 39, said. "They ... force the child to work like a animal. They don't really take care of them."

Deeply ingrained in the culture of the impoverished former slave colony, the practice of poor families giving away children to wealthier acquaintances or relatives is known in the native Creole as "restavek," from the French words rester avec, or "to stay with."

Critics call it slavery.

The children, they said, are taken in as servants, forced to work without pay, isolated from other children in the household and seldom sent to school.

"A restavek is a child placed in domestic slavery," said Jean-Robert Cadet, a former restavek who now runs a foundation to improve the lives of restavek children (www.restavekfreedom.org).

After the January 12 earthquake, the Haitian government warned that child traffickers could take advantage of the ensuing chaos to prey on vulnerable children. The well-publicized drama surrounding 10 U.S. missionaries caught trying to spirit 33 children over the border seemed to reinforce the threat.

But critics say tens of thousands of Haitian children have been freely given by their own parents to a life of slavery within Haiti.

300,000 RESTAVEKS?

A 2002 study for UNICEF and other organizations by Norway's Fafo Institute for Applied Social Science said there were 173,000 restavek children, more than 8 percent of the population between 5 and 17. Cadet believes there are more than 300,000.

"When I was a child, the family basically owned me," said Cadet, whose mother died young. He was given away to a wealthy family when he was four.

"I grew up sleeping under the kitchen table. I got up early, swept the yard, washed the car, fetched water, emptied the chamber pot. I went to the market, bathed the children, walked the children to school and I couldn't come to school," he said. "I never ate with the family. I was abused physically. I was abused emotionally with bad words."

The restavek tradition may date to the time when Haiti was a French slave colony, when the children of slaves worked as domestics in the home of the master. Cadet said a relic of that era, a twisted cowhide whip known in Creole as a rigwaz, is still used to beat restaveks.

"It's the same whip that the French used during colonial times to beat slaves," he said. "You can buy them in the markets (in Port-au-Prince) today."

The restavek tradition lives on in part because it is accepted, or at least tolerated, in Haitian culture. Some families school and feed their restavek children, and some argue the children would die if they remained with their poor parents.

A family that has taken in a restavek child, Cadet said, will never admit to mistreating that child, and the government is reluctant to interfere in domestic affairs.

'LIKE A MOTHER'

Marie Regine Joseph Pierre calls her 16-year-old charge, Rosaline, her cousin, and says she took in the girl when she was eight.

Rosaline lives "like brothers and sisters" with Pierre's own children, she says, and goes to school.

"My behavior with them, it's like a mother," she said.

Expatriates have carried restavek traditions to the United States, Two years ago, a mother and her adult daughter were convicted in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, of keeping a Haitian teenager as their slave for six years.

The girl, Simone Celestin, described in court how she was beaten, forced to sleep on the floor and bathe from a bucket.

Although Haiti is a signatory to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, Caroline Bakker, a child protection adviser for UNICEF, said it has no laws to protect restavek children.

Haiti needs new laws to protect children in domestic servitude from illegal labor practices, as well as social service programs to help parents who might otherwise give their children away.

"It should go hand in hand, protection and criminalization," she said. "Set up programs ... so that those families are able to keep those children with them, in their family, so that they can go to school (and) have a normal life with their families."

Jean-Robert Cadet said he sang along with his host family at the birthdays of their children, but never knew how old he was and believed that restaveks did not have birthdays.

"It's like a restavek child is not really a person. It's almost like you are disposable cloth," he said. "They use you and they throw you away."

(Editing by Tom Brown and Doina Chiacu)
"People who don't like their beliefs being laughed at shouldn't have such funny beliefs"
Post IP/Country: 75.53.152.9* / US
Advertisement
Sponsored Links
#2 - Posted 29 August 2010, 5:18 PM
Location: United Kingdom, Dominican Republic
Join date: August 2008
Member #: 1307
Posts: 10348
Send Message
RE: Haiti "restavek" tradition called child slavery
Quote:
Belly previously said:



By Jim Loney
PORT-AU-PRINCE | Thu Feb 18, 2010 9:17am EST

(Reuters) - Living in a tent after an earthquake left a million Haitians in the streets, Melila Thelusma says she cannot support her two daughters and is ready to give them away to foreigners if she can find a good home for them.

Despite her desperation, Thelusma said she would never turn 11-year-old Gaelle and 6-year-old Christelle over to a Haitian family, as tens of thousands of other poor parents have done.

"Not a Haitian family. Haitians will make them suffer," Thelusma, 39, said. "They ... force the child to work like a animal. They don't really take care of them."

Deeply ingrained in the culture of the impoverished former slave colony, the practice of poor families giving away children to wealthier acquaintances or relatives is known in the native Creole as "restavek," from the French words rester avec, or "to stay with."

Critics call it slavery.

The children, they said, are taken in as servants, forced to work without pay, isolated from other children in the household and seldom sent to school.

"A restavek is a child placed in domestic slavery," said Jean-Robert Cadet, a former restavek who now runs a foundation to improve the lives of restavek children (www.restavekfreedom.org).

After the January 12 earthquake, the Haitian government warned that child traffickers could take advantage of the ensuing chaos to prey on vulnerable children. The well-publicized drama surrounding 10 U.S. missionaries caught trying to spirit 33 children over the border seemed to reinforce the threat.

But critics say tens of thousands of Haitian children have been freely given by their own parents to a life of slavery within Haiti.

300,000 RESTAVEKS?

A 2002 study for UNICEF and other organizations by Norway's Fafo Institute for Applied Social Science said there were 173,000 restavek children, more than 8 percent of the population between 5 and 17. Cadet believes there are more than 300,000.

"When I was a child, the family basically owned me," said Cadet, whose mother died young. He was given away to a wealthy family when he was four.

"I grew up sleeping under the kitchen table. I got up early, swept the yard, washed the car, fetched water, emptied the chamber pot. I went to the market, bathed the children, walked the children to school and I couldn't come to school," he said. "I never ate with the family. I was abused physically. I was abused emotionally with bad words."

The restavek tradition may date to the time when Haiti was a French slave colony, when the children of slaves worked as domestics in the home of the master. Cadet said a relic of that era, a twisted cowhide whip known in Creole as a rigwaz, is still used to beat restaveks.

"It's the same whip that the French used during colonial times to beat slaves," he said. "You can buy them in the markets (in Port-au-Prince) today."

The restavek tradition lives on in part because it is accepted, or at least tolerated, in Haitian culture. Some families school and feed their restavek children, and some argue the children would die if they remained with their poor parents.

A family that has taken in a restavek child, Cadet said, will never admit to mistreating that child, and the government is reluctant to interfere in domestic affairs.

'LIKE A MOTHER'

Marie Regine Joseph Pierre calls her 16-year-old charge, Rosaline, her cousin, and says she took in the girl when she was eight.

Rosaline lives "like brothers and sisters" with Pierre's own children, she says, and goes to school.

"My behavior with them, it's like a mother," she said.

Expatriates have carried restavek traditions to the United States, Two years ago, a mother and her adult daughter were convicted in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, of keeping a Haitian teenager as their slave for six years.

The girl, Simone Celestin, described in court how she was beaten, forced to sleep on the floor and bathe from a bucket.

Although Haiti is a signatory to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, Caroline Bakker, a child protection adviser for UNICEF, said it has no laws to protect restavek children.

Haiti needs new laws to protect children in domestic servitude from illegal labor practices, as well as social service programs to help parents who might otherwise give their children away.

"It should go hand in hand, protection and criminalization," she said. "Set up programs ... so that those families are able to keep those children with them, in their family, so that they can go to school (and) have a normal life with their families."

Jean-Robert Cadet said he sang along with his host family at the birthdays of their children, but never knew how old he was and believed that restaveks did not have birthdays.

"It's like a restavek child is not really a person. It's almost like you are disposable cloth," he said. "They use you and they throw you away."

(Editing by Tom Brown and Doina Chiacu)

A very difficult problem. Poverty is extreme in Haiti and there is little sign of a big inernational effort to change the situation there.
S.
Post IP/Country: 190.167.83.23* / DO
#3 - Posted 1 September 2010, 12:36 PM
Location: United States, Chicago, IL
Join date: June 2008
Member #: 992
Posts: 80
Send Message
RE: Haiti "restavek" tradition called child slavery
Such an awful tradition.

A couple of things, not to downplay the severity of the restavek situation and the physical abuse that happens but you have to remember that Haiti, and a lot of other countries in the region, have a tradition of physically disciplining their kids by spanking or whipping. Even in the US. How it takes place often varies between individual families.

The reason I bring it up is because I wanted to make a point about the rigwaz mentioned above. My mom grew up in a high society family in PAP during the 60s and she is forever telling stories about how she had to run and get the rigwaz anytime she got trouble (which her big mouth put her in often) to get her ass whooped on the stairs. She also talked about getting it from a martinet, which is a broom handle often with leather on it. And it was a normal thing, she said every kid had them in their house and she only really knew about people from her social class. I'm sure the restaveks can probably get it WAY worse in ways that are more abusive than disciplinary but the rigwaz is not just something that was used to beat slaves and now is only used for child slaves. Any kid can be disciplined with a rigwaz in Haiti. Whether or not they are being abused is another story.

A couple years ago Junot Diaz came to Chicago for a release "party" for the Spanish version of "Oscar Wao" and held a panel discussion/Q&A. Not surprisingly, Haiti came up quite a bit and the issue of restaveks was brought up.

Diaz said there was something similar that existed in the DR. If I remember correctly, Dominican restaveks were called criados or something like that. Can anyone here shed light on that situation in DR, both now and in the past. Do I even have the word right, criado? Thanks.
Edited on 9/1/2010 12:38 PM by eddiearkadian.
Post IP/Country: 216.143.30.* / US
#4 - Posted 1 September 2010, 1:11 PM
Location: United States, Quisqueya
Join date: August 2008
Member #: 1291
Posts: 9125
Send Message
RE: Haiti "restavek" tradition called child slavery
The word criado is correct or hijo de crianza. The tradition does carry on to the Dominican Republic as
poor parents give away their children to be "criados".
Hijos de crianza and the way they are treated depends on the persons they are sent to live with, some form part of the family immediately, some are exploited and used, some get beaten, and so on. Depends on their luck, but most go to school and only do house chores after they return home.
José Francisco Peña Gomez was a "hijo de crianza" of the Bogaert family, and grew up to be a prominent politician.
Ignorance is temporary, stupidity lasts forever.
Post IP/Country: 201.229.209.5* / DO
#5 - Posted 1 September 2010, 1:34 PM
Location: United States, NYC
Join date: October 2009
Member #: 3761
Posts: 12043
Send Message
RE: Haiti "restavek" tradition called child slavery
This tradition is as old as mankind. Modernization has dealt it a mortal blow, but it still carries weight in those places, like Haiti and parts of the DR, where modernity has not reached a sufficient level of penetration. A few years ago I was visiting some rather wealthy friends in the North coast of DR and was somewhat surprised that they apparently had some Haitian children "staying with them." I kinda looked at my wife and said, "Sure." So even in wealthy households you find this set-up because it provides the owner with a ready supply of cheap labor, a calling to their humanistic side, and it also satisfies the needs of a population otherwise abandoned and in need of basic shelter and food. In the old times, families often passed on to the better halves of the family tree their children, often sending a son to a certain aunt or uncle to care for. Nothing new. What is significant is the extent to which this practice has gained almost commonality in Haiti today. It speaks to the systematic breakdown of the society, and defines the Failed State moniker to the tee.

"If you want to sleep well at night, it's best to avoid watching the making of sausages or politics." Otto Von Bismarck
Post IP/Country: 74.68.159.19* / US
#6 - Posted 3 September 2010, 12:42 PM
Location: United States, NYC
Join date: September 2010
Member #: 5729
Posts: 191
Send Message
RE: Haiti "restavek" tradition called child slavery
As a 23 year old I have always noticed the demographic changes when I would visit la Isla annually throughout my childhood. The sad case is that we are being out-breeded. Both countries holding about ten million citizens on each side on a island with a limited number of resources. Please take into consideration that does not include the illegal Haitian immigrants that are currently in the Republic.

My brothers and sisters this is not about purifying but perserving.

Some of you can look in the mirror right now and ask yourselves
do you want to live in such land? Where your daughters are no
longer safe? Where law has no order? Everything behind metal
bars? More sexual deviance introduced into our youth culture?

Stand up Dominican brother!
The time has come.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AEGlVs5cGHo
^ your future Dominican MAN
"We must secure the existence of our people and a future for Dominican children"
Post IP/Country: 67.80.187.9* / US
#7 - Posted 3 September 2010, 12:42 PM
Location: United States, NYC
Join date: September 2010
Member #: 5729
Posts: 191
Send Message
RE: Haiti "restavek" tradition called child slavery
As a 23 year old I have always noticed the demographic changes when I would visit la Isla annually throughout my childhood. The sad case is that we are being out-breeded. Both countries holding about ten million citizens on each side on a island with a limited number of resources. Please take into consideration that does not include the illegal Haitian immigrants that are currently in the Republic.

My brothers and sisters this is not about purifying but perserving.

Some of you can look in the mirror right now and ask yourselves
do you want to live in such land? Where your daughters are no
longer safe? Where law has no order? Everything behind metal
bars? More sexual deviance introduced into our youth culture?

Stand up Dominican brother!
The time has come.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AEGlVs5cGHo
^ your future Dominican MAN
"We must secure the existence of our people and a future for Dominican children"
Post IP/Country: 67.80.187.9* / US
#8 - Posted 9 September 2010, 7:27 PM
Location: United States
Join date: June 2010
Member #: 5216
Posts: 665
Send Message
RE: Haiti "restavek" tradition called child slavery
Edited on 9/9/2010 7:28 PM by ElFactor.
Post IP/Country: 64.131.136.23* / US
#9 - Posted 9 September 2010, 7:29 PM
Location: United States
Join date: June 2010
Member #: 5216
Posts: 665
Send Message
RE: Haiti "restavek" tradition called child slavery
Post IP/Country: 64.131.136.23* / US
#10 - Posted 9 September 2010, 9:25 PM
Location: United States
Join date: August 2010
Member #: 5624
Posts: 147
Send Message
RE: Haiti "restavek" tradition called child slavery
Quote:
ElFactor previously said:

<object width="480" height="385"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/1w-QRwJwfwQ?fs=1&amp;hl=en_US"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/1w-QRwJwfwQ?fs=1&amp;hl=en_US" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="480" height="385"></embed></object>

Post IP/Country: 64.131.136.23* / US