Dominican Today Forum » Dominicans Abroad » Latin America » The Chilean Model: Good or Bad?
#21 - Posted 10 September 2010, 12:05 PM
Location: United States, NYC
Join date: October 2009
Member #: 3761
Posts: 16353
Send Message
RE: The Chilean Model: Good or Bad?
Quote:
abc200 previously said:

Quote:
dreadlocks previously said:

you are free to believe what you will..if you think it was pinochet, than that is what it was


Friedman was a crook!


IMF and others induce shock so they can impose capitalism for markets and
profit.

When will the next crisis hit us!

Coup of Chile was a shock to impose market capitalism.

Disaster Capitalism!



S.


ABC,

You hit my weak joint with that video: I couldn't stop looking at her lips
And there in lies my weakness, good looking babes who can talk a good story.

But getting back to Chile for a minute, the issue at hand is what role if any did Milton Friedman play in guiding or helping Chileans out of the stagnant economic grip of the socialistic economic scheme of the Allende years? I say he was in the main a positive force. He helped bring into being an association with high end academic research that has made Chile one of the most sort after developing nation in this area. This all got started in earnest back in the sixties and has bloomed into a solid research tradition. Hundreds if not thousands of advanced students have made their way from Chile into many of the leading American and European institutions of higher learning. The number of PhDs and other advance degree students is not to be easily disputed; and these have had a positive impact on Chilean economic development. One of the interesting aspects of this development in Chile was that under the dictatorship many leftists were forced into going into these institutions to remove themselves from the harsh anti-democratic conditions in Chile. This proved to have a positive result because many of these aforementioned leftist leaning intellectuals got first hand training in the elite colleges and institutions of the West. They learned the inner meanings of the economic lingo and studied hard economic subjects that greatly broadened their understanding of the profession. Then they applied these more nuanced understandings when they returned to Chile. That is why many of these former leftist turned centralist have misgivings about any attempt to bring back the leftist economic schemes of the past. They understand that in our globalized world framework, many of these proscriptions would prove suicidal to the small economies like Chile. Hopefully, a similar process is at work with respects to the DR today. Of course, the blood shed and the overall brutality of the Dictatorship is one few people would endorse as a solution to economic mismanagement. I for one do not believe it to be a necessary condition.



"If you want to sleep well at night, it's best to avoid watching the making of sausages or politics." Otto Von Bismarck

William Arthur Ward - "The pessimist complains about the wind; the optimist expects it to change; the realist adjusts the sails.
Post IP/Country: 74.68.159.19* / US
Advertisement
Sponsored Links
#22 - Posted 10 September 2010, 7:35 PM
Location: United States
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 4
Posts: 22496
Send Message
RE: The Chilean Model: Good or Bad?
sometimes my initial reaction is not to bother to reply to you at all. then, i simply must. are you aware that under the urgings of the Chicago Boys, all economic theories besides monetarism, Friedman style, were forbidden in Chilean universities? so much for your democratic trends
Post IP/Country: 190.80.162.18* / DO
#23 - Posted 10 September 2010, 9:47 PM
Location: United States, NYC
Join date: October 2009
Member #: 3761
Posts: 16353
Send Message
RE: The Chilean Model: Good or Bad?
dread, are you saying that Chileans were prevented from studying the history of economic thought? And what does that have to do with their exposure here in the USA? Or were they also required only to read the monetarist texts? Check out Chile's International Competitive position, I believe 30th and tops in Latin America. How do you like 'em apples Dread? Not a bad showing, Dread.

"If you want to sleep well at night, it's best to avoid watching the making of sausages or politics." Otto Von Bismarck

William Arthur Ward - "The pessimist complains about the wind; the optimist expects it to change; the realist adjusts the sails.
Post IP/Country: 74.68.159.19* / US
#24 - Posted 10 September 2010, 9:48 PM
Location: United States, NYC
Join date: October 2009
Member #: 3761
Posts: 16353
Send Message
RE: The Chilean Model: Good or Bad?
.
Edited on 9/10/2010 9:48 PM by Atabey.

"If you want to sleep well at night, it's best to avoid watching the making of sausages or politics." Otto Von Bismarck

William Arthur Ward - "The pessimist complains about the wind; the optimist expects it to change; the realist adjusts the sails.
Post IP/Country: 74.68.159.19* / US
#25 - Posted 11 September 2010, 10:09 AM
Location: United States
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 4
Posts: 22496
Send Message
RE: The Chilean Model: Good or Bad?
this is exactly why i cannot bother to waste my time and energy debating with you. you simply shift the focus of the inquiry around, muddy the waters, and think you have made a point. i asked you, quite simply, to tell me the recommendations of Milton Friedman that would be "welcome" here in the DR. nothing more, nothing less. just give me a list. do not tell me about how Chile did this year, since it is not operating strictly under monetarist economic dictates.. if you would just focus, maybe we could talk.
Post IP/Country: 190.80.161.14* / DO
#26 - Posted 11 September 2010, 5:10 PM
Location: United States, NYC
Join date: October 2009
Member #: 3761
Posts: 16353
Send Message
RE: The Chilean Model: Good or Bad?
Quote:
dreadlocks previously said:

this is exactly why i cannot bother to waste my time and energy debating with you. you simply shift the focus of the inquiry around, muddy the waters, and think you have made a point. i asked you, quite simply, to tell me the recommendations of Milton Friedman that would be "welcome" here in the DR. nothing more, nothing less. just give me a list. do not tell me about how Chile did this year, since it is not operating strictly under monetarist economic dictates.. if you would just focus, maybe we could talk.



So let me get this right: I ask you a question and this is "shifting" in your words. Milton Friedman played an important role in the economic debate that surfaced in Chile and his monetarist changed the foundations of the Chilean economic system. Yes, this model did have to be rescue by the US in the early 1980s, but it also laid the foundations for the current highly competitive underpinnings that Chile has today. And yes, Chile is as all other nations are, a product of their past; so the period 1973-1990s was instrumental in establishing her current highly competitive economy. Just the facts, Dread.

"If you want to sleep well at night, it's best to avoid watching the making of sausages or politics." Otto Von Bismarck

William Arthur Ward - "The pessimist complains about the wind; the optimist expects it to change; the realist adjusts the sails.
Post IP/Country: 74.68.159.19* / US
#27 - Posted 12 September 2010, 10:28 AM
Location: United States
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 4
Posts: 22496
Send Message
RE: The Chilean Model: Good or Bad?
to say that his economic teachings changed the economic history of Chile cannot be in debate. of course it would have. the question is " how did it change Chile?" YOU say that his recommendations would have been " welcome here". i deduce from that that you mean that their effects were positive. so, Atabey, building on that, let us revisit the question which you, in your accustomed role as the artful dodger, seem to be avoiding...GIVE ME A LIST OF THE PRESCRIPTIONS WHICH WOULD BE "WELCOME" HERE. that is alll i asked for, not some circuitous game of ring around the roses. JUST THE FACTS, ATABEY!
Edited on 9/12/2010 10:29 AM by dreadlocks.
Post IP/Country: 190.80.161.20* / DO
#28 - Posted 12 September 2010, 6:33 PM
Location: United Kingdom, Dominican Republic
Join date: August 2008
Member #: 1307
Posts: 10609
Send Message
RE: The Chilean Model: Good or Bad?
Quote:
Atabey previously said:

Quote:
dreadlocks previously said:

this is exactly why i cannot bother to waste my time and energy debating with you. you simply shift the focus of the inquiry around, muddy the waters, and think you have made a point. i asked you, quite simply, to tell me the recommendations of Milton Friedman that would be "welcome" here in the DR. nothing more, nothing less. just give me a list. do not tell me about how Chile did this year, since it is not operating strictly under monetarist economic dictates.. if you would just focus, maybe we could talk.



So let me get this right: I ask you a question and this is "shifting" in your words. Milton Friedman played an important role in the economic debate that surfaced in Chile and his monetarist changed the foundations of the Chilean economic system. Yes, this model did have to be rescue by the US in the early 1980s, but it also laid the foundations for the current highly competitive underpinnings that Chile has today. And yes, Chile is as all other nations are, a product of their past; so the period 1973-1990s was instrumental in establishing her current highly competitive economy. Just the facts, Dread.

Total craziness idiocy - Chile suffered terribibly for years for nothing!

S.
Post IP/Country: 190.167.69.5* / DO
#29 - Posted 14 September 2010, 11:02 PM
Location: United States
Join date: August 2010
Member #: 5624
Posts: 147
Send Message
RE: The Chilean Model: Good or Bad?
Quote:
abc200 previously said:

Quote:
Atabey previously said:

Quote:
dreadlocks previously said:

this is exactly why i cannot bother to waste my time and energy debating with you. you simply shift the focus of the inquiry around, muddy the waters, and think you have made a point. i asked you, quite simply, to tell me the recommendations of Milton Friedman that would be "welcome" here in the DR. nothing more, nothing less. just give me a list. do not tell me about how Chile did this year, since it is not operating strictly under monetarist economic dictates.. if you would just focus, maybe we could talk.



So let me get this right: I ask you a question and this is "shifting" in your words. Milton Friedman played an important role in the economic debate that surfaced in Chile and his monetarist changed the foundations of the Chilean economic system. Yes, this model did have to be rescue by the US in the early 1980s, but it also laid the foundations for the current highly competitive underpinnings that Chile has today. And yes, Chile is as all other nations are, a product of their past; so the period 1973-1990s was instrumental in establishing her current highly competitive economy. Just the facts, Dread.

Total craziness idiocy - Chile suffered terribibly for years for nothing!

S.

Post IP/Country: 64.131.136.23* / US
#30 - Posted 14 September 2010, 11:07 PM
Location: United States
Join date: August 2010
Member #: 5624
Posts: 147
Send Message
RE: The Chilean Model: Good or Bad?
Quote:
mrchivo previously said:

Quote:
abc200 previously said:

Quote:
Atabey previously said:

Quote:
dreadlocks previously said:

this is exactly why i cannot bother to waste my time and energy debating with you. you simply shift the focus of the inquiry around, muddy the waters, and think you have made a point. i asked you, quite simply, to tell me the recommendations of Milton Friedman that would be "welcome" here in the DR. nothing more, nothing less. just give me a list. do not tell me about how Chile did this year, since it is not operating strictly under monetarist economic dictates.. if you would just focus, maybe we could talk.



So let me get this right: I ask you a question and this is "shifting" in your words. Milton Friedman played an important role in the economic debate that surfaced in Chile and his monetarist changed the foundations of the Chilean economic system. Yes, this model did have to be rescue by the US in the early 1980s, but it also laid the foundations for the current highly competitive underpinnings that Chile has today. And yes, Chile is as all other nations are, a product of their past; so the period 1973-1990s was instrumental in establishing her current highly competitive economy. Just the facts, Dread.

Total craziness idiocy - Chile suffered terribibly for years for nothing!

S.



Post IP/Country: 64.131.136.23* / US