Dominican Today Forum » Dominicans Abroad » Latin America » Dominicans and Haitians, what is the problem?
#621 - Posted 13 February 2009, 11:22 PM
Location: United States, NYC
Join date: January 2008
Member #: 283
Posts: 500
Send Message
RE: Dominicans and Haitians, what is the problem?
Gizmo wants to single out Dominican leaders of Haitian extraction as bad. What excuses does he make for Mejia and countless others?

What does he have to say about Duverge? Luperon? Pena-Gomez?

One thing that my interaction on this board has enforced in me is the need to get more involved in my country. I hope that a lot of Dominicans and Haitians with open-minds will eventually find ways to change the fashion that our countries are governed.

If WE had real patriotic leaders, this mess would be a moot issue. We really have to prepare ourselves to take over the realms of the governing of our countries when the opportunity presents itself. Those corrupt f*ckers can't last forever.
Edited on 2/13/2009 11:27 PM by kmnupe.

Post IP: 24.188.14.20*
Advertisement
Sponsored Links
#622 - Posted 14 February 2009, 12:02 PM
Location: United States
Join date: January 2009
Member #: 1994
Posts: 1150
Send Message
RE: Dominicans and Haitians, what is the problem?
*NationBuilder
Listen folks, I'm not denying there are national/cultural differences between both nations. What I am suggesting, however, is that they are more similar than not. Perhaps I am oversimplifying it, but from where I sit, that island is occuppied by descendants of Africans from various ethnic groups on the continent of Africa, as well as the creolized African descendants from neighboring Caribbean islands AND mainland America; Europeans - mostly French and Spanish, but American and Jewish et al as well; and the Amerindians - Arawaks, Caribs, Ciboney etc. It's one huge melting pot.

While the respective colonies held allegiance to differing European powers at one time or another, the crux of the matter is that BOTH looked to Europe. In both colonies, the European, his physical characteristics, culture, mores and values occuppied the top of the totem pole. He was planter, businessman, clergy, whatever. He was followed by the mullato, who, for the most part, emulated him and jealously guarded his totemic position in the society. Notwithstanding the other levels of the totem pole, the visibly African Blackman was at the bottom of the totem pole in both countries, and he continues to occuppy that rung of the social ladder.

Europeans hailing from various nations lived in BOTH colonies, as is the case today. After all, business is business. In reading your history, I see that some of your leaders hailed from (of their parents) what is today Haiti. I see a continual cross cultural pollenation occurring on that island from early times until today.

I know this is oversimpliflying, but this is how I see it. I've witnessed the stark anti-Blackism by many Dominicans. And have been the object of it from my friend's Haitian mother that hails from that molatto class. She instantly disliked all of his "Black" friends that were not "high yellow" like them.
I meet Dominicans that will tell me that they are Spanish, and Haitians that will tell me that they are French. It appears that in both countries the 'light, bright, and damn near white' elite rule BOTH countries and are ideological twins. BUT the rhetoric is more vocally played out by the wannabes and those of the lower social classes seeking some 'status symbol' to elevate themselves above those society deems undesireable. Unless they open up their mouths, one could not readily differentiate between a Haitian elite and a Dominican one.

Guys, I'm really learning a lot by reading the various posts on this site. And I will continue to seek to learn and try to keep an open mind. But, right now, many of these posts bring me back to my same conclusion.

OK. Let her rip! (lol)



*Gizmo, Are you serious! Dominicans and Haitians are two distinct groups of people. Haitians are mostly pure africans with a 2% mulatto population. There's only been one president of Haitian extraction in the D.R.'s history, a bad one at that Ulises Hereaux. He put the country in debt, the main reason why the U.S. invaded D.R., most Dominican leaders hailed from Santiago. The province that fought more against the Haitian military and defeated them, in fact the assassin that killed Hereaux hailed from Santiago. And the president that took power in that great period was from Santiago also Good riddance..... Try a little harder Nation Builder.

*Cibaeño75
There were several other Dominican heads of state who were of Haitian extraction. Woss y Gil is one, Trujillo another, and balaguer another still (as a matter of fact Lilis and Balaguer were actually related by blood).

Gizmo, EVIDENCE PLEASE!
Edited on 2/14/2009 12:14 PM by Gizmo.
READ A BOOK FOR REAL! BECOME A BOOKWORM MISTER BEFORE YOU GET SERVED!!!!!
Post IP: 24.215.163.1*
#623 - Posted 14 February 2009, 7:51 PM
Location: United States
Join date: February 2009
Member #: 2118
Posts: 37
Send Message
RE: DOMINICANS AND HAITIANS, WHAT IS THE PROBLEM?
you seemed confused and you talk alot of crap. i really feel you are faking it .
Post IP: 71.249.62.8*
#624 - Posted 14 February 2009, 8:13 PM
Location: United States
Join date: February 2009
Member #: 2118
Posts: 37
Send Message
RE: Dominicans and Haitians, what is the problem?
what is the problem? i feel the haitian nation is the problem.haiti is a failed nation. anarchy is what rules in haiti.hatians want to entegrate the dominican republic and hati into one nation-that would be a disaster for the dominican people.the haitian nation cannot manage their own affairs-imagine el cuco trying to run things in the d.r.you people smell terribly and borrow each others children to beg in santiago.please go home!
Post IP: 71.249.62.8*
#625 - Posted 17 February 2009, 3:12 PM
Location: United States, New York City
Join date: February 2008
Member #: 411
Posts: 5683
Send Message
RE: Dominicans and Haitians, what is the problem?
Quote:
Gizmo previously said:

*NationBuilder
Listen folks, I'm not denying there are national/cultural differences between both nations. What I am suggesting, however, is that they are more similar than not. Perhaps I am oversimplifying it, but from where I sit, that island is occuppied by descendants of Africans from various ethnic groups on the continent of Africa, as well as the creolized African descendants from neighboring Caribbean islands AND mainland America; Europeans - mostly French and Spanish, but American and Jewish et al as well; and the Amerindians - Arawaks, Caribs, Ciboney etc. It's one huge melting pot.

While the respective colonies held allegiance to differing European powers at one time or another, the crux of the matter is that BOTH looked to Europe. In both colonies, the European, his physical characteristics, culture, mores and values occuppied the top of the totem pole. He was planter, businessman, clergy, whatever. He was followed by the mullato, who, for the most part, emulated him and jealously guarded his totemic position in the society. Notwithstanding the other levels of the totem pole, the visibly African Blackman was at the bottom of the totem pole in both countries, and he continues to occuppy that rung of the social ladder.

Europeans hailing from various nations lived in BOTH colonies, as is the case today. After all, business is business. In reading your history, I see that some of your leaders hailed from (of their parents) what is today Haiti. I see a continual cross cultural pollenation occurring on that island from early times until today.

I know this is oversimpliflying, but this is how I see it. I've witnessed the stark anti-Blackism by many Dominicans. And have been the object of it from my friend's Haitian mother that hails from that molatto class. She instantly disliked all of his "Black" friends that were not "high yellow" like them.
I meet Dominicans that will tell me that they are Spanish, and Haitians that will tell me that they are French. It appears that in both countries the 'light, bright, and damn near white' elite rule BOTH countries and are ideological twins. BUT the rhetoric is more vocally played out by the wannabes and those of the lower social classes seeking some 'status symbol' to elevate themselves above those society deems undesireable. Unless they open up their mouths, one could not readily differentiate between a Haitian elite and a Dominican one.

Guys, I'm really learning a lot by reading the various posts on this site. And I will continue to seek to learn and try to keep an open mind. But, right now, many of these posts bring me back to my same conclusion.

OK. Let her rip! (lol)



*Gizmo, Are you serious! Dominicans and Haitians are two distinct groups of people. Haitians are mostly pure africans with a 2% mulatto population. There's only been one president of Haitian extraction in the D.R.'s history, a bad one at that Ulises Hereaux. He put the country in debt, the main reason why the U.S. invaded D.R., most Dominican leaders hailed from Santiago. The province that fought more against the Haitian military and defeated them, in fact the assassin that killed Hereaux hailed from Santiago. And the president that took power in that great period was from Santiago also Good riddance..... Try a little harder Nation Builder.

*Cibaeño75
There were several other Dominican heads of state who were of Haitian extraction. Woss y Gil is one, Trujillo another, and balaguer another still (as a matter of fact Lilis and Balaguer were actually related by blood).

Gizmo, EVIDENCE PLEASE!


Fine, I will provide you with proof but I didn't care for that book cover that you posted as a reposnse to my post. The links are from the DOMINICAN INSTITUTE OF GENEAOLGY:
On Trujillo's haitian ancestry:
http://www.idg.org.do/capsulas/abril2008/abril200812.htm
On Balaguer's Haitian ancestry and his sanguinal links to Heureeaux:
http://www.idg.org.do/capsulas/noviembre2005/noviembre20055.htm
For Woss Y Gil I'll have to refer you to a book I have at home but I'm positive that he is also part haitian.
Oh, let's not forget Luperon who is also the son of a haitian.
Edited on 2/17/2009 3:17 PM by cibaeño75.
"If you're going through hell, keep going." - Winston Churchill
Post IP: 161.185.150.17*
#626 - Posted 17 February 2009, 5:04 PM
Location: United States
Join date: October 2008
Member #: 1579
Posts: 11
Send Message
RE: Dominicans and Haitians, what is the problem?
Oh Ohhhh! I'd better pull out my spanish-english dictionary. Gotta wait until I get home, though.
Post IP: 206.128.211.16*
#627 - Posted 21 February 2009, 7:55 PM
Location: United States
Join date: January 2009
Member #: 1994
Posts: 1150
Send Message
RE: Dominicans and Haitians, what is the problem?
*Gizmo Are you serious! Dominicans and Haitians are two distinct groups of people. Haitians are mostly pure africans with a 2% mulatto population. There's only been one president of Haitian extraction in the D.R.'s history, a bad one at that Ulises Hereaux. He put the country in debt, the main reason why the U.S. invaded D.R., most Dominican leaders hailed from Santiago. The province that fought more against the Haitian military and defeated them, in fact the assassin that killed Hereaux hailed from Santiago. And the president that took power in that great period was from Santiago also Good riddance..... Try a little harder Nation Builder.

*Cibaeño75
There were several other Dominican heads of state who were of Haitian extraction. Woss y Gil is one, Trujillo another, and balaguer another still (as a matter of fact Lilis and Balaguer were actually related by blood).
http://www.doyletics.com/arj/onbullsh
Gizmo, EVIDENCE PLEASE!


Fine, I will provide you with proof but I didn't care for that book cover that you posted as a reposnse to my post. The links are from the DOMINICAN INSTITUTE OF GENEAOLGY:
On Trujillo's haitian ancestry:
http://www.idg.org.do/capsulas/abril2008/abril200812.htm
On Balaguer's Haitian ancestry and his sanguinal links to Heureeaux:
http://www.idg.org.do/capsulas/noviembre2005/noviembre20055.htm
For Woss Y Gil I'll have to refer you to a book I have at home but I'm positive that he is also part haitian.
Oh, let's not forget Luperon who is also the son of a haitian.
STILL B.S.
Gizmo, Don't believe in such source I believe that many French whites escaped the massacres of 1791 from rebellious former slaves and further by Dessalines and his troops in 1803. Perhaps? the link to Balaguer is to French whites not the common Black Haitian. The only people on you're list that are proven by fact to have Haitian ancestry are Ulisses Hereaux and Duverge everyone else is highly questionable??????????
Edited on 2/21/2009 8:51 PM by Gizmo.
READ A BOOK FOR REAL! BECOME A BOOKWORM MISTER BEFORE YOU GET SERVED!!!!!
Post IP: 24.215.163.1*
#628 - Posted 23 February 2009, 12:02 PM
Location: United States, New York City
Join date: February 2008
Member #: 411
Posts: 5683
Send Message
RE: Dominicans and Haitians, what is the problem?
"Gizmo, Don't believe in such source I believe that many French whites escaped the massacres of 1791 from rebellious former slaves and further by Dessalines and his troops in 1803. Perhaps? the link to Balaguer is to French whites not the common Black Haitian. The only people on you're list that are proven by fact to have Haitian ancestry are Ulisses Hereaux and Duverge everyone else is highly questionable?????????? "

Well if the Dominican Institute of Genealogy is not a good enough source for you than may I suggest the fairy tail land of wikipedia? I doubt very much that you are in a better position to ascertain the geneaology of Dominican heads of state than individuals who dedicate their lives to such work. As for for Dominican heads of state of white haitian descent indeed there is such an individual, Nouel, but I did not mention him as I already knew that you were alluding to persons of african descent. Trujillo's black haitian background is common knowledge among anyone who knows at least a little something about Dominican history. The Cambridge History of Latin America states that Trujillo "came from a lower class family of mixed Spanish, Creole, and HAITIAN BLOOD"(emphasis added). Chirot's Modern Tyrants:The Power and Prevalance of Evil in Our Age states about Trujillo that his "grandmother was the illegitmate daughter of a Haitian officer and a Haitian woman who had lived in the Dominican Republic during the Haitian occupation. There was nothing unusual or disgraceful about this heritage, but it bothered Trujillo, particularly the fact that he was PART BLACK AND HAITIAN"(emphasis added). The fact that you are unaware of said fact speaks volumes as to your lack of information concerning Dominican history and the individuals in said history. That Balaguer is descended from black Haitians from his mother's side and is related to Heureaux is an indisputable fact. His mother was the daughter of one Rosa Amelia Heureaux, who's father happens to be the brother of Lilis' father, making Balaguer's grandmother and Lilis first cousins. We all know that Heureaux's father was a black Haitian emigre, that's also common knowledge and any portrait of Lilis will bare witness to the fact that very little, if any, white blood flowed through his veins, but according to your hypothesis his brother was a "french white". Yea right. There's plenty of documentation of this fact if you choose to look for it even if Mr. Balaguer was careful to conceal it (not once did he mention his mother's maternal surname in his Memorias de Un Cortesano, which is indeed Heureaux, even though it is typical in DR for most individuals to go by their paternal and maternal surnames). Unless you can provide documentation that disproves what I have just stated then you have nothing.
Edited on 2/23/2009 12:57 PM by cibaeño75.
"If you're going through hell, keep going." - Winston Churchill
Post IP: 161.185.150.18*
#629 - Posted 23 February 2009, 12:31 PM
Location: United States, Washington D C
Join date: February 2009
Member #: 2133
Posts: 77
Send Message
RE: DOMINICANS AND HAITIANS, WHAT IS THE PROBLEM?
Very well said.
Post IP: 74.0.190.15*
#630 - Posted 23 February 2009, 12:34 PM
Location: United States, Washington D C
Join date: February 2009
Member #: 2133
Posts: 77
Send Message
RE: DOMINICANS AND HAITIANS, WHAT IS THE PROBLEM?
Then why would you rush and get that child a Japanese passport?
Post IP: 74.0.190.15*