Dominican Today Forum » Living in the DR » General Info » Dominican-Americans..or...American-Dominicans
#111 - Posted 7 August 2009, 11:09 AM
Location: United States
Join date: June 2009
Member #: 2977
Posts: 1513
Send Message
RE: Dominican-Americans..or...American-Dominicans
Quote:
Lautaro previously said:

Quote:
ElTorodeCibao previously said:

Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:

Quote:
Montesquieu previously said:

Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:

Quote:
Montesquieu previously said:

I have mixed feelings about the whole hyphenated American thing. God forbid, we should turn like many Italians today, waving the Italian flag hard yet know nothing about Italy, Italian language, etc. Or just become annoying like some Puerto Ricans, jamming that flag down everyone throat. I'd rather see us become completely assimilated before anything of that sort happens.

As far as DR, they don't even consider us Dominican. Which is hilarious because everyone here wants to be considered Dominican, not American.



The dynamics for our group are different then what they were for the Italians when they were immigrating in large numbers. Most of them never got to go to Italy once they arrived on these shores, we go back often. There was a strong pressure on that group in the time and era they came to assimilate into white American culture, not so among our people. The Puerto Ricans never really bacame a hyphenated group. I mean, you never here anyone say Puerto Rican-American. They're just Puerto Ricans. The dynamics of their migration (and not immigration) is also distinct from ours though there are parallels. Dominicans born stateside are going to prove to be a distant beast all together. Only time will tell, though.

I always thought Puerto Ricans never got hypenated because they're all Americans. Whether it's a Puerto Rican from the Island or from New York, they both have the same passport; an American bald eagle on the front. That, and the fact that it'll be annoying to hyphen it



Yea but that just goes to the hear of the matter: Their situation is different then what ours is and as a result the end result won't be the same.


The end result for every group not considered "White" at one time or another has been the same save one American ethnic group.



Let me guess, the African Americans.


Bingo. Them becoming "White" (see:mainstream) has been predicted time and time again. I doubt that will ever happen for whatever reason (there are many). They've always been the springboard to Whitehood for others, you just got to ensue mob violence on them (Irish, Italians, Germans) or the modern way of distancing yourself socially and economically (Chinese and Jews) and you'll be "White" within a few generations. You know, and drop all the ethnic-y crap but keep a mainstream acceptable quaint version to be marketed.
http://englishquisqueya.ning.com
Post IP: 98.15.242.11*
Advertisement
Sponsored Links
#112 - Posted 7 August 2009, 11:11 AM
Location: Dominican Republic, Parque Colon statue of Anacaona
Join date: April 2009
Member #: 2573
Posts: 3334
Send Message
RE: Dominican-Americans..or...American-Dominicans
Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:

Quote:
FredCDobbs previously said:

You guys forget I am not a provincial hick like you guys and have actually resided in 6 different countries my favorite for living life is Viva Franco Viva Espana but my heart lies in the USA the Dr is also nice especially after spending way to much time on a bunch of West Indian sand bars



I grew up and still reside in the capital of the world. You'll have to live in 6 more countries to be saturated with the cosmpolitanism that has surrounded me all my life and which I take advantage of daily. If they're not from New York they're farmers, bottom line.

I still have been to more great restaurants in New York than you will probably ever be able to afford and can still get a good table at " The Four Seasons " and I dont mean the hotel Yes I know NYC better than Madrid or Rome but then I get around a lot or at least I used to ciby Brooklyn and Staten Island are not Midtown nor the Bronx nor Queens etc.... ..I seldom explored
Edited on 8/7/2009 11:15 AM by FredCDobbs.
My daughter Yaina aka ". Chucky la Nina Diabolica "
Post IP: 66.98.33.8*
#113 - Posted 7 August 2009, 11:14 AM
Location: United States, New York City
Join date: February 2008
Member #: 411
Posts: 3638
Send Message
RE: Dominican-Americans..or...American-Dominicans
Quote:
ElTorodeCibao previously said:

Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:

Quote:
FredCDobbs previously said:

You guys forget I am not a provincial hick like you guys and have actually resided in 6 different countries my favorite for living life is Viva Franco Viva Espana but my heart lies in the USA the Dr is also nice especially after spending way to much time on a bunch of West Indian sand bars



I grew up and still reside in the capital of the world. You'll have to live in 6 more countries to be saturated with the cosmpolitanism that has surrounded me all my life and which I take advantage of daily. If they're not from New York they're farmers, bottom line.




Boy, you should come up north some time, it's quite a lot of farm country off that little island and the few counties north of it.


Oh, of course. I go upstate often. Might go up there this weekend. The whole eastern seaboard is my playground Sometimes I even venture out west Yo concosco este pais bien...
'The past is never dead. In fact, it's not even past.' - William Faulkner
Post IP: 161.185.150.18*
#114 - Posted 7 August 2009, 12:02 PM
Location: United States, Chicago
Join date: March 2009
Member #: 2300
Posts: 3116
Send Message
RE: Dominican-Americans..or...American-Dominicans
You can never forget you roots, I love both countries. The big stereo type is that 99% of women in USA say the all Dominican men are "perros" They think that you are cheating all the time just because you are Dominican. lol
Post IP: 12.96.27.7*
#115 - Posted 7 August 2009, 12:11 PM
Location: United States
Join date: June 2009
Member #: 2977
Posts: 1513
Send Message
RE: Dominican-Americans..or...American-Dominicans
[QUOTE=cibaeño75]
[QUOTE=ElTorodeCibao]
[QUOTE=cibaeño75]
[QUOTE=FredCDobbs]
You guys forget I am not a provincial hick like you guys and have actually resided in 6 different countries my favorite for living life is Viva Franco Viva Espana but my heart lies in the USA the Dr is also nice especially after spending way to much time on a bunch of West Indian sand bars
[/QUOTE]


I grew up and still reside in the capital of the world. You'll have to live in 6 more countries to be saturated with the cosmpolitanism that has surrounded me all my life and which I take advantage of daily. [B]If they're not from New York they're farmers, bottom line.[/B]
[/QUOTE]



Boy, you should come up north some time, it's quite a lot of farm country off that little island and the few counties north of it.
[/QUOTE]

Oh, of course. I go upstate often. Might go up there this weekend. The whole eastern seaboard is my playground Sometimes I even venture out west Yo concosco este pais bien...
[/QUOTE]

I'm the same way, though I seldom venture into The City these days. I usually keep to the mid-Atlantic/north east for the eastern sea board (not a big fan of the southern United States [not for any "the south sucks" reasons just not a fan]), then hop over to many spots of the western seaboard.

I'm much more of a open country fresh air tall mountains type of guy. That's why I fell in love with western Austria (Vorarlberg).
http://englishquisqueya.ning.com
Post IP: 98.15.242.11*
#116 - Posted 7 August 2009, 2:41 PM
Location: United States, New York City
Join date: February 2008
Member #: 411
Posts: 3638
Send Message
RE: Dominican-Americans..or...American-Dominicans
[QUOTE=ElTorodeCibao]
[QUOTE=cibaeño75]
[QUOTE=ElTorodeCibao]
[QUOTE=cibaeño75]
[QUOTE=FredCDobbs]
You guys forget I am not a provincial hick like you guys and have actually resided in 6 different countries my favorite for living life is Viva Franco Viva Espana but my heart lies in the USA the Dr is also nice especially after spending way to much time on a bunch of West Indian sand bars
[/QUOTE]


I grew up and still reside in the capital of the world. You'll have to live in 6 more countries to be saturated with the cosmpolitanism that has surrounded me all my life and which I take advantage of daily. [B]If they're not from New York they're farmers, bottom line.[/B]
[/QUOTE]



Boy, you should come up north some time, it's quite a lot of farm country off that little island and the few counties north of it.
[/QUOTE]

Oh, of course. I go upstate often. Might go up there this weekend. The whole eastern seaboard is my playground Sometimes I even venture out west Yo concosco este pais bien...
[/QUOTE]

I'm the same way, though I seldom venture into The City these days. I usually keep to the mid-Atlantic/north east for the eastern sea board (not a big fan of the southern United States [not for any "the south sucks" reasons just not a fan]), then hop over to many spots of the western seaboard.

I'm much more of a open country fresh air tall mountains type of guy. That's why I fell in love with western Austria (Vorarlberg).
[/QUOTE]

I gotta tell you I LOVE the south. I visit Virginia and the Carolinas often. I have good freinds down there.
'The past is never dead. In fact, it's not even past.' - William Faulkner
Post IP: 161.185.150.18*
#117 - Posted 7 August 2009, 4:27 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, America
Join date: June 2009
Member #: 2891
Posts: 830
Send Message
RE: Dominican-Americans..or...American-Dominicans
Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:

Quote:
Montesquieu previously said:

I have mixed feelings about the whole hyphenated American thing. God forbid, we should turn like many Italians today, waving the Italian flag hard yet know nothing about Italy, Italian language, etc. Or just become annoying like some Puerto Ricans, jamming that flag down everyone throat. I'd rather see us become completely assimilated before anything of that sort happens.

As far as DR, they don't even consider us Dominican. Which is hilarious because everyone here wants to be considered Dominican, not American.



The dynamics for our group are different then what they were for the Italians when they were immigrating in large numbers. Most of them never got to go to Italy once they arrived on these shores, we go back often. There was a strong pressure on that group in the time and era they came to assimilate into white American culture, not so among our people. The Puerto Ricans never really bacame a hyphenated group. I mean, you never here anyone say Puerto Rican-American. They're just Puerto Ricans. The dynamics of their migration (and not immigration) is also distinct from ours though there are parallels. Dominicans born stateside are going to prove to be a distant beast all together. Only time will tell, though.



The thing is as little as some of those Italian-Americans may have to do with Italy, or as little as they know about true Italian culture, what they do have is a shared experience and shared history in the USA. To me it is actually commendable that well into 3rd and 4th generations, and after substantial mixing and assimilation, some of them still retain some notion of a group identity . SO even if a guy knows nil about Italy today, speaks no Italian, and has never been there ... he can still see certain other Americans and identify with the fact their families and his had very similar stories. And, truth be told, if you peak into their families you may be surprised to see some behaviors still remain shared in this loosely knit ethnicity. SO though I understand on the surface it seems odd given how distant they've become from the old country, on the other hand what is wrong with waving a lil' foreign flag to commemorate shared struggles of your grandparents?

as Cib says our dynamics are much different. Our migrations are occurring in an age of cheap travel, easy communications, and far less pressure to assimilate to some vague notion of 'mainstream'. also all around us are arriving other groups that happen to share our language and similar folkways. the context of our diaspora is very different, so we'll see what emerges in 20 years time.
http://englishquisqueya.ning.com
Post IP: 206.252.74.4*
#118 - Posted 7 August 2009, 6:11 PM
Location: United States, NYC
Join date: January 2008
Member #: 283
Posts: 390
Send Message
RE: Dominican-Americans..or...American-Dominicans
.
Edited on 8/8/2009 7:13 AM by kmnupe.

Post IP: 24.188.15.12*