| #31 - Posted 31 August 2009, 12:04 PM | |
Location: United States, Brooklyn Join date: December 2007 Member #: 40 Posts: 2707 | RE: "The real Dominican" video. Quote: cyberdragon previously said: Looks like the same family, over and over again... Still, I'll agree that most domincans are phenotypically like the video shows, though my family, who are from COTUI and LA VEGA are by a wide majority on the lighter side.... |
Post IP: 96.224.179.22* | |
| Advertisement | |
Sponsored Links | |
| #32 - Posted 31 August 2009, 12:17 PM | |
Location: United States, Bronx, NY Join date: August 2009 Member #: 3394 Posts: 101 | RE: "The real Dominican" video. I remember a lot of Dominican people when I was younger and I would tell them my family was from Puerto Plata, they would say oh that's where all the rich white people were from and that there weren't any real Dominicans over there. This of course was ridiculous and far from the truth. But my point is many Dominicans aren't the best informed on their own country!!! I think there are a lot of generalizations on this board. You will find people from all over the color spectrum throughout the country. Edited on 8/31/2009 12:19 PM by Chico81. |
Post IP: 67.87.128.8* | |
| #33 - Posted 31 August 2009, 12:29 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: July 2009 Member #: 3276 Posts: 422 | RE: "The real Dominican" video. i have no idea why so much darma about the color of the skin of the people in the video i seen alot of dominicans that look like that i have cousins who are fully dominicans who like like that too |
Post IP: 67.83.60.16* | |
| #34 - Posted 31 August 2009, 1:30 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: June 2009 Member #: 2977 Posts: 2597 | RE: "The real Dominican" video. Quote: USADR previously said: Quote: guillermone previously said: Quote: Lautaro previously said: Quote: ElTorodeCibao previously said: Quote: Eriliza previously said: I personally do not see any problem with posting this video as part of being a "real" Dominican in terms of phenotypes. I myself have family members from both parents who look like this, and I indeed consider myself a real Dominican. The race topic should have not been brought up in the first place because this is how most of us look like. Exactly. I feel this highly reflects my experience as a Dominican, even the music picked. Someone felt slighted, I can not relate. So much the worse for them. The morons still don't get it, the Cibao is still the most populated area of the Republic, so it's a given that it will have the most representative sample of the dominican phenotype, duélale a quien le duela. And this is a capitaleño born person the one that is telling you this. Because of regional isolation the Cibao is the most indigenous (autóctono) to the DR and representative of authentic Dominican culture. The rest of the other regions have had a lot of foreign influences that you can't truely call Dominican. Particularly, the Guloyas culture that came with the migrants from the nearby English speaking islands that settled in the San Pedro and La Romana area, the excaped slaves of Samana, the Jews of Sosua, the Japanese from Constanza and strong Haitian influence near all the border towns. And to a lesser extent we can also include, many of the other coastal cities such as Puerto Plata, Barahona and San Cristobal and Monte Cristi just to name a few as having a strong taste of imported culture. Allow me to expand on your post: -The Cibao is the most populous region. -The South is the second highest source of indigenous DNA, not to mention the strong Taino influenced campesino culture, in particular the area around San Juan/Azua (this has been posted on Dominican researchers Jorge Estevez's website and also in the Taino thread here on DT) -I cannot personally comment on every single border town, but due to the negative stigma attached to Haitians, intermarriage with them was frowned upon and/or discouraged. So it did surprise me upon meeting Dominicans from Banica, and looking at videos/pics of that border area, the start difference in phenotype. In my opinion, many of those in that border town look downright like East Indians. I asked about this, but I'll refrain from posting their actual comments to avoid starting an internet flame war. Remmember, their answers are from a campesinos point of view, so it's not sugar coated with PCness. -Agreed on the Guloya culture centered in San Pedro de Macoris. -Agreed on the African Americans descendants of Samana, but they were always a very tiny element of that region. Just to avoid anyone from misundertanding this post (purposely or otherwise), I'm talking about culture/phenotype not 'color'. We have our own Afroinfluenced heritage and ancestry that is seperate and apart from later arrivals like the Cocolos and African Americans. If you could, PM me said comments as I'm no stranger to the straight forward words of los campesinos nor am I a fan of "PCness". |
Post IP: 98.15.242.11* | |
| #35 - Posted 31 August 2009, 1:32 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: June 2009 Member #: 2977 Posts: 2597 | RE: "The real Dominican" video. Quote: Chico81 previously said: I remember a lot of Dominican people when I was younger and I would tell them my family was from Puerto Plata, they would say oh that's where all the rich white people were from and that there weren't any real Dominicans over there. This of course was ridiculous and far from the truth. But my point is many Dominicans aren't the best informed on their own country!!! I think there are a lot of generalizations on this board. You will find people from all over the color spectrum throughout the country. Of course and I don't think any of us this but generalizations like rumors and stereotypes have truth to them. |
Post IP: 98.15.242.11* | |
| #36 - Posted 31 August 2009, 1:36 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: June 2009 Member #: 2977 Posts: 2597 | RE: "The real Dominican" video. Quote: divinedominicana previously said: i have no idea why so much darma about the color of the skin of the people in the video i seen alot of dominicans that look like that i have cousins who are fully dominicans who like like that too There wasn't any drama really. My comment was the first to predict it, but it was mostly a prediction of non-Cibaeños complaining of this video depicting only culture from El Cibao. That proved to be false and instead a comment was made about feeling left out due to lack of supposed moreno and black Dominicans who are supposedly the majority. The second half of my comment was on phenotypes in MY family, not any region or the country as a whole. |
Post IP: 98.15.242.11* | |
| #37 - Posted 31 August 2009, 2:26 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: March 2008 Member #: 522 Posts: 5223 | RE: "The real Dominican" video. Quote: cyberdragon previously said: Can you or anybody manually type the address for the "The Real Dominican Video." My system does not show or pick-up the link. Thanks |
Post IP: 168.221.159.3* | |
| #38 - Posted 31 August 2009, 3:23 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: June 2009 Member #: 2977 Posts: 2597 | RE: "The real Dominican" video. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RsVUAqRzy90&eurl=http%3A%2F%2F |
Post IP: 98.15.242.11* | |
| #39 - Posted 31 August 2009, 4:00 PM | |
Location: Dominican Republic Join date: March 2009 Member #: 2266 Posts: 1533 | RE: "The real Dominican" video. Quote: Chico81 previously said: I remember a lot of Dominican people when I was younger and I would tell them my family was from Puerto Plata, they would say oh that's where all the rich white people were from and that there weren't any real Dominicans over there. Believe it or not, the "Real Dominican" (perception) of 1930's was pretty different from the "Real Dominican" of today. |
Post IP: 76.24.128.20* | |
| #40 - Posted 31 August 2009, 4:59 PM | |
Location: United States, Brooklyn, NY Join date: August 2009 Member #: 3511 Posts: 244 | RE: "The real Dominican" video. I'm glad that everything that I wrote was deleted. But that doesn't change anything. Edited on 8/31/2009 5:00 PM by HiHater. Formerly Estrella. |
Post IP: 130.199.3.13* | |