| #41 - Posted 7 October 2009, 10:38 PM | |
Location: Canada, home safe Join date: January 2008 Member #: 268 Posts: 2673 | RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens Quote: ElTorodeCibao previously said: Quote: antonioj previously said: Quote: TanBellaMami previously said: Quote: MIRABUENO previously said: Quote: USADR previously said: For Dominicans who either live in DR or travel their often, I got this question asked on another forum : -How common is dating between Dominicans and Haitians? -How common is marriage between Dominicans and Haitians? -How common are mixed Dominican/Haitians in DR? -How common are Haitians becoming citizens? -Are Haitians becoming absorbed into the Dominican mainstream society, or is it more similar to the Bahamas in which they make up a distinct ethnic minority? i would't say that thier are no dominican haitian couples it's just that it isn't as common as one would think. any that exist would be more in the border regions of our country. Well, Often when inter marriage happens between a Haitian and Dominican it is not broadcast due to of course the known stigmatized resentments and stereotypes but given that I have lived in DR growing up I have seem it all the time. Or keep in mind that there is always a sense such couple often having to want to relocate to new "barrios o ciudades" soon after they marry so their such harmony would not be scrutinized. By the way, in intermarrying in DR there are much to consider culturally fused with traditionally class dynamics often play a major role. in the elite upper class level, intermarriages between Haitians and Dominicans happens everyday. Especially those Haitian tourists men/women (Diasporas) from the USA whom may have once visited DR and have found themselves wives or husbands. To not also forget that often we have several of those couple who at times are well off and moved back to Haiti while owning properties in DR. Often, Dominican women would later find out of their spouse's ancestral background to have been of Haitian heritage due to mislead pretexts of appearance that some Dominicans often assume if one is light skinned therefore he or she may not be Haitian. For example: As a Dominican-Haitian couple, If we are newlyweds new to a neighborhood and are culturally fluent constant Spanish speakers in our household... Who is going to assume that we are Dominican-Haitian intermarrying couple? I would agree with you afro on this one, USADR your argument is full of hole and rather preposterous and serve to stir up controversies when there are none, your ignorance bliss throughout and your subliminal message well understood. 2 countries that share a common border one have been inter-mingling wronlgy or rightly in the other one affair over 200 years, you are saying relation, marriage or concubinage is rare, please provide us with the statistics, I will gladly recant I will venture to say the inter relation it's probably much higher, if we factor in the border town, if you were to google "border countries" you will see a high inter-relation among the population of the border town unless DR and H are exempted. I personally meet these folks during my stay in Montreal While we're at it provide statistics for it being high. I can not and I am not the one making while imaginative argument on predisposed assertion which one allude to be the thruth. I am making a simple observation of border countries on the premises of global trend. Edited on 10/7/2009 10:38 PM by antonioj. We must accept finite disappointment, but never lose infinite hope. |
Post IP/Country: 216.191.222.6* / CA | |
| Advertisement | |
Sponsored Links | |
| #42 - Posted 7 October 2009, 10:41 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: June 2009 Member #: 2977 Posts: 2199 | RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens Quote: antonioj previously said: Quote: ElTorodeCibao previously said: Quote: antonioj previously said: Quote: TanBellaMami previously said: Quote: MIRABUENO previously said: Quote: USADR previously said: For Dominicans who either live in DR or travel their often, I got this question asked on another forum : -How common is dating between Dominicans and Haitians? -How common is marriage between Dominicans and Haitians? -How common are mixed Dominican/Haitians in DR? -How common are Haitians becoming citizens? -Are Haitians becoming absorbed into the Dominican mainstream society, or is it more similar to the Bahamas in which they make up a distinct ethnic minority? i would't say that thier are no dominican haitian couples it's just that it isn't as common as one would think. any that exist would be more in the border regions of our country. Well, Often when inter marriage happens between a Haitian and Dominican it is not broadcast due to of course the known stigmatized resentments and stereotypes but given that I have lived in DR growing up I have seem it all the time. Or keep in mind that there is always a sense such couple often having to want to relocate to new "barrios o ciudades" soon after they marry so their such harmony would not be scrutinized. By the way, in intermarrying in DR there are much to consider culturally fused with traditionally class dynamics often play a major role. in the elite upper class level, intermarriages between Haitians and Dominicans happens everyday. Especially those Haitian tourists men/women (Diasporas) from the USA whom may have once visited DR and have found themselves wives or husbands. To not also forget that often we have several of those couple who at times are well off and moved back to Haiti while owning properties in DR. Often, Dominican women would later find out of their spouse's ancestral background to have been of Haitian heritage due to mislead pretexts of appearance that some Dominicans often assume if one is light skinned therefore he or she may not be Haitian. For example: As a Dominican-Haitian couple, If we are newlyweds new to a neighborhood and are culturally fluent constant Spanish speakers in our household... Who is going to assume that we are Dominican-Haitian intermarrying couple? I would agree with you afro on this one, USADR your argument is full of hole and rather preposterous and serve to stir up controversies when there are none, your ignorance bliss throughout and your subliminal message well understood. 2 countries that share a common border one have been inter-mingling wronlgy or rightly in the other one affair over 200 years, you are saying relation, marriage or concubinage is rare, please provide us with the statistics, I will gladly recant I will venture to say the inter relation it's probably much higher, if we factor in the border town, if you were to google "border countries" you will see a high inter-relation among the population of the border town unless DR and H are exempted. I personally meet these folks during my stay in Montreal While we're at it provide statistics for it being high. I can not and I am not the one making while imaginative argument on predisposed assertion which one allude to be the thruth. I am making a simple observation of border countries on the premises of global trend. Which global trend study are you referring to? Also a lot of other "border countries" don't have our history. I believe if this happened so often why would there be any stigma by this time after so many years? Attitudes change within generations. |
Post IP/Country: 204.210.155.3* / US | |
| #43 - Posted 7 October 2009, 10:41 PM | |
Location: Dominican Republic, Cabarete Join date: October 2009 Member #: 3725 Posts: 1035 | RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens Quote: Lautaro: And I'm doing this analysis without taking into account the physical beauty part of the equation. ElTorodeCibao: And that's a big one. Beauty, as always, is subjective to the solemn eyes of beholders and their conditional circumstances of all the named above premises we have so much "Circularly Verbally Masturbated Exacerbated" about on here in this thread indeed which has exhausted validity and productivity. Now let us define "Fundamental" and "Moot" (lol)! Edited on 10/7/2009 10:44 PM by TanBellaMami. |
Post IP/Country: 70.221.128.14* / US | |
| #44 - Posted 7 October 2009, 10:43 PM | |
Location: Canada, home safe Join date: January 2008 Member #: 268 Posts: 2673 | RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens Quote: Micaela previously said: Quote: TanBellaMami previously said: Often when inter marriage happens between a Haitian and Dominican it is not broadcast due to of course the known stigmatized resentments and stereotypes but given that I have lived in DR growing up and travel there often as my mother and father's marriage is of evidence, I have seen, still seeing it all the time. I didn't get it. The Haitian/Dominican couples hide from their families and friends and move some place else? They fear rejection from their acquaintance, but are welcome by the strangers? Quote: TanBellaMami previously said: For example: As a Dominican-Haitian couple, If we are newlyweds new to a neighborhood and are culturally fluent constant Spanish speakers in our household... Who is going to assume that we are Dominican-Haitian intermarrying couple? Who is going to assume that they are a Dominican-Haitian intermarrying couple? Anybody that hears the Haitian speaking, even if is a first generation of Haitian born in DR. That thick accent takes a lot of effort to disguise, speaking Spanish or English. It's quite ludicrous... what you wrote above. Micaela I wonder what make you a linguistic expert all the sudden and perhaps you can share some of the details to validate your conclusions of facts. Edited on 10/7/2009 10:45 PM by antonioj. We must accept finite disappointment, but never lose infinite hope. |
Post IP/Country: 216.191.222.6* / CA | |
| #45 - Posted 7 October 2009, 10:46 PM | |
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo Join date: December 2007 Member #: 38 Posts: 4935 | RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens Quote: TanBellaMami previously said: Quote: Lautaro previously said: I will answer you as honestly and no-holds barred as a brazilian would answer you: My philosophy in dating is "brancas for marriage, mulattas for sex, and pretas to take care of the kids". Given that Jessica Alba is a "branca" (white, as we understand it in Latin America), I would ideally take her for marriage. Halle Berry, being the hot mulatta that she is, would be seen by me as a perfect candidate for sex, sex, and more sex. Sorry for offending the politically correct sensitivities of some people over here, but I have the nasty and antisocial habit of saying things as I see or believe them to be. No strings attached. Exactly, Thus your ideal preferences are what you have developed and accepted to be the norms for "you" perhaps through a learned cultural aspect conditioning that were made or is believed to be traditional to "you"... Whereas it is not generally so with every specific human circumstances to expect to be the norms. What tickles my fancy may urks the hell out of someone else. So regardless of this "Brazilian" graphic entailed description you have just given us (lol)... Those who like Apples will like apples and those that do oranges will do oranges. However, what if we have Apploanges (lol); would a different group of people not like them as well? One's choice, would be entirely based on their knowledge of the combination in taste as to separately what an orange and apple taste like and the willingness to try something new if there were not stigmatized preconceived biases and historical notions as to why there were certain resentments toward both apples and oranges why one was liked over the other verse, versa. BASICALLY: I rest my case on that alone that this above analysis you gave is a judgmentally based philosophy principle you have come to establish as your premise values when choosing a mate of the opposite sex you engagingly form relations with that perhaps is possibly shared or perhaps not shared with some of your peers around you but who knows right... You still don't get it. The only thing that my example does is to strike home the fact that the dominican reality doesn't respond to the idealized image that you have of it in your mind, namely, that the marriages between haitian men and dominican women (the very example of your maternal grandparents) are not as prevalent as you make them to be, for the simple fact that the haitian peasants (the Dieudonnés risking everything for the chance of getting inside this country as we speak) are at the bottom of the ladder of the dominican socioeconomic food chain, and as such, they don't represent the ideal marriage partner for the Yuladis from el barrio living over here that are looking to climb and maintain themselves on top, a lifestyle that is not cheap in the least. Believe me, I don't like this reality as much as you do, but I'll be deceiving myself if I shut my eyes in the face of this. Edited on 10/7/2009 11:18 PM by Lautaro. "A man who strives after goodness in all his acts is sure to come to ruin, since there are so many men who are not good." Niccolo Macchiavelli - The Prince |
Post IP/Country: 190.0.86.2* / DO | |
| #46 - Posted 7 October 2009, 10:54 PM | |
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo Join date: December 2007 Member #: 38 Posts: 4935 | RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens Quote: TanBellaMami previously said: Quote: Lautaro: And I'm doing this analysis without taking into account the physical beauty part of the equation. ElTorodeCibao: And that's a big one. Beauty, as always, is subjective to the solemn eyes of beholders and their conditional circumstances of all the named above premises we have so much "Circularly Verbally Masturbated Exacerbated" about on here in this thread indeed which has exhausted validity and productivity. Now let us define "Fundamental" and "Moot" (lol)! In the first place, sir, the term beauty that we're using here is the same that is used on the rest of the western world, that is, white people (be them nordic looking or mediterranean looking) are at the pinnacle of all things beauty, while the rest can shove themselves down the trash bin. And as beauty comes and goes, our unintended guests living here are as far away from these parameters as Pluto is far away from the Sun. Edited on 10/7/2009 11:16 PM by Lautaro. "A man who strives after goodness in all his acts is sure to come to ruin, since there are so many men who are not good." Niccolo Macchiavelli - The Prince |
Post IP/Country: 190.0.86.2* / DO | |
| #47 - Posted 7 October 2009, 10:57 PM | |
Location: United States, "El Amanza GUAPOS, BIGOTS, TROLLS, LLORONAS y SELF-PROCLAIMED DOMINICAN "PATRIOTS" De Villa Duarte" Join date: August 2008 Member #: 1255 Posts: 5320 | RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens Quote: TanBellaMami previously said: Well, KIDDO, for a guy that sounds smart, you suuuuuuure write alot of nonsense.Quote: TuPapaupa previously said: Any chance you can write who wrote what?....... The above post (s) you quoted was (were) made by 2 different posters. I mean, you' ve been here long enough to know that members WILL think that post was made by one member, when in fact was made by 2. Well, There is a reason why I re-post it and did so with having them being in two different shades of colors so that people can see that they are two statements perhaps from two different people. I am sure whomever said them and reading them would k now that the reply is addressed to them. I can not do all the job for posters in helping them to keep up, bro... Come on, kiddo, play catch up (lol)!!! It doesn't matter if you separate posts by changing colors, when you delete the writer's name, unless people here are magicians, they can't tell who wrote what. I don't think I was telling you to "do all the job for posters in helping them keep up", but, for the love of God, don't, you don't have to make it harder.. Edited on 10/7/2009 11:07 PM by TuPapaupa. ![]() I am The BOOO!!GEYMAN...Hide The Kids And Stop The VELORIO, The Dancing, The Singing, The Whining, The Nagging, The Complaining and LLORADERA....El LEONAAAAAAAAZO De Villa Duarte is Here!. |
Post IP/Country: 209.204.76.20* / US | |
| #48 - Posted 7 October 2009, 11:04 PM | |
Location: United States Join date: June 2009 Member #: 2977 Posts: 2199 | RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens Quote: TanBellaMami previously said: Quote: Lautaro: And I'm doing this analysis without taking into account the physical beauty part of the equation. ElTorodeCibao: And that's a big one. Beauty, as always, is subjective to the solemn eyes of beholders and their conditional circumstances of all the named above premises we have so much "Circularly Verbally Masturbated Exacerbated" about on here in this thread indeed which has exhausted validity and productivity. Now let us define "Fundamental" and "Moot" (lol)! You seem to enjoy this circle jerk as you keep posting. As for beauty, while individuals often have a say society ultimately dictates a general idea and the individual chooses within that. Thus why a Westerner would most likely not find a Aboriginal attractive. Define them, I'm sure you have Dictionary.com with that nifty thesaurus tab open. |
Post IP/Country: 204.210.155.3* / US | |
| #49 - Posted 7 October 2009, 11:09 PM | |
Location: Canada, home safe Join date: January 2008 Member #: 268 Posts: 2673 | RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens Quote: ElTorodeCibao previously said: Quote: antonioj previously said: Quote: ElTorodeCibao previously said: Quote: antonioj previously said: Quote: TanBellaMami previously said: Quote: MIRABUENO previously said: Quote: USADR previously said: For Dominicans who either live in DR or travel their often, I got this question asked on another forum : -How common is dating between Dominicans and Haitians? -How common is marriage between Dominicans and Haitians? -How common are mixed Dominican/Haitians in DR? -How common are Haitians becoming citizens? -Are Haitians becoming absorbed into the Dominican mainstream society, or is it more similar to the Bahamas in which they make up a distinct ethnic minority? i would't say that thier are no dominican haitian couples it's just that it isn't as common as one would think. any that exist would be more in the border regions of our country. Well, Often when inter marriage happens between a Haitian and Dominican it is not broadcast due to of course the known stigmatized resentments and stereotypes but given that I have lived in DR growing up I have seem it all the time. Or keep in mind that there is always a sense such couple often having to want to relocate to new "barrios o ciudades" soon after they marry so their such harmony would not be scrutinized. By the way, in intermarrying in DR there are much to consider culturally fused with traditionally class dynamics often play a major role. in the elite upper class level, intermarriages between Haitians and Dominicans happens everyday. Especially those Haitian tourists men/women (Diasporas) from the USA whom may have once visited DR and have found themselves wives or husbands. To not also forget that often we have several of those couple who at times are well off and moved back to Haiti while owning properties in DR. Often, Dominican women would later find out of their spouse's ancestral background to have been of Haitian heritage due to mislead pretexts of appearance that some Dominicans often assume if one is light skinned therefore he or she may not be Haitian. For example: As a Dominican-Haitian couple, If we are newlyweds new to a neighborhood and are culturally fluent constant Spanish speakers in our household... Who is going to assume that we are Dominican-Haitian intermarrying couple? I would agree with you afro on this one, USADR your argument is full of hole and rather preposterous and serve to stir up controversies when there are none, your ignorance bliss throughout and your subliminal message well understood. 2 countries that share a common border one have been inter-mingling wronlgy or rightly in the other one affair over 200 years, you are saying relation, marriage or concubinage is rare, please provide us with the statistics, I will gladly recant I will venture to say the inter relation it's probably much higher, if we factor in the border town, if you were to google "border countries" you will see a high inter-relation among the population of the border town unless DR and H are exempted. I personally meet these folks during my stay in Montreal While we're at it provide statistics for it being high. I can not and I am not the one making while imaginative argument on predisposed assertion which one allude to be the thruth. I am making a simple observation of border countries on the premises of global trend. Which global trend study are you referring to? Also a lot of other "border countries" don't have our history. I believe if this happened so often why would there be any stigma by this time after so many years? Attitudes change within generations. I think the attitude have changed indeed not at the pace, it should have been due to what you mentionned above. However you need to realize there is superiority / inferiority complexe affecting the dynamic of any undertaking relation between DR and H, until the field play is level I am afraid there will be not much progress, and we can go back, ponder and blame the economic situation in which Haiti is in. Edited on 10/7/2009 11:31 PM by antonioj. We must accept finite disappointment, but never lose infinite hope. |
Post IP/Country: 216.191.222.6* / CA | |
| #50 - Posted 7 October 2009, 11:17 PM | |
Location: Dominican Republic, Cabarete Join date: October 2009 Member #: 3725 Posts: 1035 | RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens Quote: Lautaro previously said: You still don't get it. The only thing that my example does is to strike home the fact that the dominican reality doesn't respond to the idealized image that you have of it in your mind, namely, that the marriages between haitian men and dominican women (the very example of your maternal grandparents) are not as prevalent as you make them to be, for the simple fact that the haitian peasant (the Dieudonnés entering this country daily as we speak) are at the bottom of the ladder of the dominican socioeconomic food chain, and as such, they don't represent the ideal marriage partner for the Yuladis from el barrio living over here. Believe me, I don't like this reality as much as you do, but I'll be deceiving myself if I shut my eyes in the face of this reality. Oh I did understand you, but we are now just having , what I call, a conversation and no longer debating. So as we dialogue through this in term of one's preferences, any one of us regardless we are or may be Haitian or Dominican may not chose to find "Dieudonne or Marianne" suitably attractive as imagery idealist for or as a mate aside the known stigmas that are attached with them already for just being lowly Haitian peasants to even a Haitian might deem unfavorable. That is the case almost generally every where in most societies. However, that is still a matter of class caste range preference given we often have a preconceived notion that a peasant is less or not as civilized as urban city folks than it is anything else, but all possible aspects are and can also be inclusive as to why that is as you stated in your excerpt. Example: I was in DR and I met this Haitian girl named Sonia before I met my now Dominicans girlfriend (which her picture you see here). Sonia, she was born in La Romana and raised in Montellano and Sosua Abajo, DR. Anyway, you would or could kill her if you have and must, she will not go out with the certain peasant looking Haitian or Dominican or generally the local men (Dominican, Haitian or not) which lived in her barrio. Why? Simple and simply to her, they do not fit nor meet her lifestyle of what she deems fashionable... which is close to American her being a Dominican Haitian she can get. She dates only Diasporas Dominican and Haitian men. She dated me, and believe she did not date me for money as she rather used to actually give me money. Point is, granted as we can agree and I did never totally disagree with your points you have made that there is indeed image association that do not suit us as people and our preferences (Dominican, Haitian or not) which goes beyond the barriers we have much exacerbate here today. |
Post IP/Country: 70.221.128.14* / US | |
