Dominican Today Forum » Living in the DR » General Info » Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens
#51 - Posted 7 October 2009, 11:29 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, Cabarete
Join date: October 2009
Member #: 3725
Posts: 1039
Send Message
RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens
Quote:
ElTorodeCibao previously said:

You seem to enjoy this circle jerk as you keep posting.

As for beauty, while individuals often have a say society ultimately dictates a general idea and the individual chooses within that. Thus why a Westerner would most likely not find a Aboriginal attractive.

Define them, I'm sure you have Dictionary.com with that nifty thesaurus tab open.



Indeed such a point in red above you have stated is or has already been made and is of no new statement no matter how we rephrase or structure our wordings in our posts on this thread...

People, there is such a thing called basic critical thinking evaluative standardizing. Much of anything can be debatable and arguable whether or not our premises carry with them good forms or pass and do not pass actual True premise tests. There are even sub-arguments that can be drawn from air and water, but then again we have fire and wind (lol). As far as validity, what is deductive and what is inductive is essential.

Does it means it is worth much energy to go back and forth in further conveying or persuade our points deeper, and for what really...?

P.S: What are our goals and agenda for an argument or starting a thread is purely subjective as most of are already mind made up for our stances. What are our overall intents for change no change would relatively be satisfactory that we would be content with in debating our arguments?
Edited on 10/7/2009 11:55 PM by TanBellaMami.
Post IP/Country: 70.221.128.14* / US
Advertisement
Sponsored Links
#52 - Posted 7 October 2009, 11:31 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 38
Posts: 4955
Send Message
RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens
As for the thread, I'm not adverse to their becoming citizens here, on one condition: like the french and japanese cases, I like to make emphasis in culture, culture, and more culture. In the sense that the former and the latter require for any inmigrant wanting to become citizen of their countries to burn the ships and cut all ties with their former homelands, culturally speaking. In the french case, this requires the arabs and africans to renounce any allegiance to their respective religious fanaticisms (sharia law et al.), while on the japanese case, this requires for the person in question to drop his/her name and surname for japanese, yamato ones. On our case, our guests and citizens-to-be would have to hispanicize their names, learn the language (and apply thoroughly on their day to day lives, zero backstairs cheating), and christianize or make themselves jewish, I don't care, as long as this religion involves abandoning any kind of tribal manifestations from the far away Guinee. If they can't abide by this, then we can cordially show them the door, but we must not allow our inmigrants (from whatever extraction) to reproduce the conditions which they left by migrating on our own back yard. Culture is not only a medium to express ourselves, but most of all, it has to be understood as a way of life, and if you intend to become a dominican citizen, then you have to be a dominican in body and soul.
Edited on 10/7/2009 11:38 PM by Lautaro.
"A man who strives after goodness in all his acts is sure to come to ruin, since there are so many men who are not good."

Niccolo Macchiavelli - The Prince

Post IP/Country: 190.0.86.2* / DO
#53 - Posted 7 October 2009, 11:36 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, Cabarete
Join date: October 2009
Member #: 3725
Posts: 1039
Send Message
RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens
Quote:
TuPapaupa previously said:
Well, KIDDO, for a guy that sounds smart, you suuuuuuure write alot of nonsense.

It doesn't matter if you separate posts by changing colors, when you delete the writer's name, unless people here are magicians, they can't tell who wrote what.

I don't think I was telling you to "do all the job for posters in helping them keep up", but, for the love of God, don't, you don't have to make it harder..



Precisely (lol).

My job is to allow people to see which contents I am responding to and the actual posters can remain anonymous since it is the content we are debating not directly the poster him or herself. That is our problems, we often want to know the posters so we could engaged on direct personal ranting attacks of disagreement. This is not a scholarly paper where I have to give credit to actual posters, but if I do post or reply directly to their quote I do, but if I do not, it is not as if I am writing my response considering TuPapaupa migh want to know my sources (lol ha hah).

I will try to post you name next to you quotes "Oh great one: (lol)!
Post IP/Country: 70.221.128.14* / US
#54 - Posted 7 October 2009, 11:44 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, Cabarete
Join date: October 2009
Member #: 3725
Posts: 1039
Send Message
RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens
Quote:
Lautaro previously said:

As for the thread, I'm not adverse to their becoming citizens here, on one condition: like the french and japanese cases, I like to make emphasis in culture, culture, and more culture. In the sense that the former and the latter require for any inmigrant wanting to become citizen of their countries to burn the ships and cut all ties with their former homelands, culturally speaking. In the french case, this requires the arabs and africans to renounce any allegiance to their respective religious fanaticisms (sharia law et al.), while on the japanese case, this requires for the person in question to drop his/her name and surname for japanese, yamato ones. On our case, our guests and citizens-to-be would have to hispanicize their names, learn the language (and apply thoroughly on their day to day lives, zero backstairs cheating), and christianize or make themselves jewish, I don't care, as long as this religion involves abandoning any kind of tribal manifestations from the far away Guinee. If they can't abide by this, then we can cordially show them the door, but we must not allow our inmigrants (from whatever extraction) to reproduce the conditions which they left by migrating on our own back yard.



Duh Laut,

One way or the other by governing law of the process of naturalization anywhere denouncing previous nationality is the required requirements basically (lol).

However, ideally most when becoming citizen do just that, but in reality one never actually stop being who they are ethnically "culturally" no matter which society they live in and become a citizen on. Yeah they say they do so to speak, but in America do naturalized American Dominicans still not feel culturally connected to DR or at least claim to be? Thus that goes for any other creed, I simply use Dominican as a example here.

I am a Naturalized American and furthermore an American Soldier Officer, does that mean I do not feel culturally attached. drawn and connected to both Dominican Republic and Haiti (Hispaniola) no matter how Americanized I may seem or am perceived to be?

P.S: Believe me, I am not as Americanized as my cousins here in America. They listen to mostly R&B, Rap and all that perhaps are American before they listen to Bachata, Compa or anything Antilles or Caribbean. Whereas for me, the case is reversed and guess what... I have been here longer than they have apart from the ones who born herein the USA yet they still considerably might tell you they are Haitian-Dominicans (Thus Latinos) when they are face off with actual naturally native born and raised North (United States) Americans.
Edited on 10/7/2009 11:57 PM by TanBellaMami.
Post IP/Country: 70.221.128.14* / US
#55 - Posted 8 October 2009, 7:34 AM
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 38
Posts: 4955
Send Message
RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens
Quote:
TanBellaMami previously said:

Quote:
Lautaro previously said:

As for the thread, I'm not adverse to their becoming citizens here, on one condition: like the french and japanese cases, I like to make emphasis in culture, culture, and more culture. In the sense that the former and the latter require for any inmigrant wanting to become citizen of their countries to burn the ships and cut all ties with their former homelands, culturally speaking. In the french case, this requires the arabs and africans to renounce any allegiance to their respective religious fanaticisms (sharia law et al.), while on the japanese case, this requires for the person in question to drop his/her name and surname for japanese, yamato ones. On our case, our guests and citizens-to-be would have to hispanicize their names, learn the language (and apply thoroughly on their day to day lives, zero backstairs cheating), and christianize or make themselves jewish, I don't care, as long as this religion involves abandoning any kind of tribal manifestations from the far away Guinee. If they can't abide by this, then we can cordially show them the door, but we must not allow our inmigrants (from whatever extraction) to reproduce the conditions which they left by migrating on our own back yard.



Duh Laut,

One way or the other by governing law of the process of naturalization anywhere denouncing previous nationality is the required requirements basically (lol).

However, ideally most when becoming citizen do just that, but in reality one never actually stop being who they are ethnically "culturally" no matter which society they live in and become a citizen on. Yeah they say they do so to speak, but in America do naturalized American Dominicans still not feel culturally connected to DR or at least claim to be? Thus that goes for any other creed, I simply use Dominican as a example here.

I am a Naturalized American and furthermore an American Soldier Officer, does that mean I do not feel culturally attached. drawn and connected to both Dominican Republic and Haiti (Hispaniola) no matter how Americanized I may seem or am perceived to be?

P.S: Believe me, I am not as Americanized as my cousins here in America. They listen to mostly R&B, Rap and all that perhaps are American before they listen to Bachata, Compa or anything Antilles or Caribbean. Whereas for me, the case is reversed and guess what... I have been here longer than they have apart from the ones who born herein the USA yet they still considerably might tell you they are Haitian-Dominicans (Thus Latinos) when they are face off with actual naturally native born and raised North (United States) Americans.


Don't "duh" me, you know as well as I do that this is a dead serious matter, specially when we take into account that on the majority of the polls that have been done sounding the opinion of the haitian inmigrants here, the majority of them have confessed having still more loyalties to their former homeland than to the new one. Granted, part of it has been our fault for not making their transition to the new home any easier, but this is something not to take lightly or make jokes about, cuz' in the case of open, unavowed conflict between both countries (God forbid), they would represent an unlimited source of danger to the dominican country and people.

As a political thinker, I'm more concerned about both the territorial and cultural integrity of my country, so excuse me if I offend your sensitivities and the ones of other haitian posters around here, but like king Louis XIV and Napoleon on their time, I'm a believer of the principle of the state having only one culture and language representing it, and in the dominican case, this is represented by the spanish language and the hispanic ethos in which the dominican culture is based. I'm a mortal enemy of letting other cultural manifestations have a free hand, cuz' the only thing that they might lead to is the creation of a state within the state. And please, don't bring me the US example, cuz' they're (still) a mighty empire, with resources enough to make them capable of crushing any kind of ethnic rebellion that might appear on their soil with ease. On the dominican case, we can't give ourselves the luxury of granting the free hand to the cultures of inmigrant communities, specially when the one that is the more numerically significant around here (haitians) have superior birth rates than the local population. To ignore this reality is to invite disaster, and it can only end up in tears.

Another measure that the state have to take urgently (something which is being planned right now, but only with the people of the armed forces) is to repopulate the border provinces (Monte Cristi, Dajabon, Elias Piña, Independencia and Pedernales) with ethnic dominican families. I know that you'll come up with the line "How would you know if the dominican families in question don't have an haitian strain down the line", which would be my cue to respond "Duh, Wil", cuz' my main criteria in choosing the ethnic dominican families for the project would be to make sure that the connection of those families with Haiti (if they have any at all) is not that recent.

The objective of this is to prevent the population of the said provinces from developing an haitian majority that could be used as a basis for any further demand for more territories on the part of the haitian state on any future bilateral negotiation. And don't come to me with the line that there are not precedents about states reclaimming neighboring territories on the basis of having a part of their populations living on those territories in dispute, cuz' the international arena is shock full about those examples (France and Germany, about the provinces of Alsace and Lorraine; Belgium and the Netherlands on the brabantine provinces, etc.). For all the talks about brotherhood and good neighborhood, you know as well as I do that at the end of the day the haitian authorities will still look up for number one, that is, to struggle for the defense of their national interests first and foremost, and if the defense of those interests involve making our life impossible on the negotiation table, guess what? that would not make them lose their sleep in any sense, so I don't see the reason why we dominicans should act any differently on principle.
Edited on 10/8/2009 8:21 AM by Lautaro.
"A man who strives after goodness in all his acts is sure to come to ruin, since there are so many men who are not good."

Niccolo Macchiavelli - The Prince

Post IP/Country: 200.88.48.3* / DO
#56 - Posted 8 October 2009, 8:32 AM
Location: United States, El Guapito Jarabacoence,Nariz de Guineo, a troll and lloronas nightmare, right hand of El Boogeyman!
Join date: August 2009
Member #: 3407
Posts: 1929
Send Message
RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens
Quote:
Lautaro previously said:

Quote:
TanBellaMami previously said:

Quote:
Lautaro previously said:

As for the thread, I'm not adverse to their becoming citizens here, on one condition: like the french and japanese cases, I like to make emphasis in culture, culture, and more culture. In the sense that the former and the latter require for any inmigrant wanting to become citizen of their countries to burn the ships and cut all ties with their former homelands, culturally speaking. In the french case, this requires the arabs and africans to renounce any allegiance to their respective religious fanaticisms (sharia law et al.), while on the japanese case, this requires for the person in question to drop his/her name and surname for japanese, yamato ones. On our case, our guests and citizens-to-be would have to hispanicize their names, learn the language (and apply thoroughly on their day to day lives, zero backstairs cheating), and christianize or make themselves jewish, I don't care, as long as this religion involves abandoning any kind of tribal manifestations from the far away Guinee. If they can't abide by this, then we can cordially show them the door, but we must not allow our inmigrants (from whatever extraction) to reproduce the conditions which they left by migrating on our own back yard.



Duh Laut,

One way or the other by governing law of the process of naturalization anywhere denouncing previous nationality is the required requirements basically (lol).

However, ideally most when becoming citizen do just that, but in reality one never actually stop being who they are ethnically "culturally" no matter which society they live in and become a citizen on. Yeah they say they do so to speak, but in America do naturalized American Dominicans still not feel culturally connected to DR or at least claim to be? Thus that goes for any other creed, I simply use Dominican as a example here.

I am a Naturalized American and furthermore an American Soldier Officer, does that mean I do not feel culturally attached. drawn and connected to both Dominican Republic and Haiti (Hispaniola) no matter how Americanized I may seem or am perceived to be?

P.S: Believe me, I am not as Americanized as my cousins here in America. They listen to mostly R&B, Rap and all that perhaps are American before they listen to Bachata, Compa or anything Antilles or Caribbean. Whereas for me, the case is reversed and guess what... I have been here longer than they have apart from the ones who born herein the USA yet they still considerably might tell you they are Haitian-Dominicans (Thus Latinos) when they are face off with actual naturally native born and raised North (United States) Americans.


Don't "duh" me, you know as well as I do that this is a dead serious matter, specially when we take into account that on the majority of the polls that have been done sounding the opinion of the haitian inmigrants here, the majority of them have confessed having still more loyalties to their former homeland than to the new one. Granted, part of it has been our fault for not making their transition to the new home any easier, but this is something not to take lightly or make jokes about, cuz' in the case of open, unavowed conflict between both countries (God forbid), they would represent an unlimited source of danger to the dominican country and people.

As a political thinker, I'm more concerned about both the territorial and cultural integrity of my country, so excuse me if I offend your sensitivities and the ones of other haitian posters around here, but like king Louis XIV and Napoleon on their time, I'm a believer of the principle of the state having only one culture and language representing it, and in the dominican case, this is represented by the spanish language and the hispanic ethos in which the dominican culture is based. I'm a mortal enemy of letting other cultural manifestations have a free hand, cuz' the only thing that they might lead to is the creation of a state within the state. And please, don't bring me the US example, cuz' they're (still) a mighty empire, with resources enough to make them capable of crushing any kind of ethnic rebellion that might appear on their soil with ease. On the dominican case, we can't give ourselves the luxury of granting the free hand to the cultures of inmigrant communities, specially when the one that is the more numerically significant around here (haitians) have superior birth rates than the local population. To ignore this reality is to invite disaster, and it can only end up in tears.

Another measure that the state have to take urgently (something which is being planned right now, but only with the people of the armed forces) is to repopulate the border provinces (Monte Cristi, Dajabon, Elias Piña, Independencia and Pedernales) with ethnic dominican families. I know that you'll come up with the line "How would you know if the dominican families in question don't have an haitian strain down the line", which would be my cue to respond "Duh, Wil", cuz' my main criteria in choosing the ethnic dominican families for the project would be to make sure that the connection of those families with Haiti (if they have any at all) is not that recent.

The objective of this is to prevent the population of the said provinces from developing an haitian majority that could be used as a basis for any further demand for more territories on the part of the haitian state on any future bilateral negotiation. And don't come to me with the line that there are not precedents about states reclaimming neighboring territories on the basis of having a part of their populations living on those territories in dispute, cuz' the international arena is shock full about those examples (France and Germany, about the provinces of Alsace and Lorraine; Belgium and the Netherlands on the brabantine provinces, etc.). For all the talks about brotherhood and good neighborhood, you know as well as I do that at the end of the day the haitian authorities will still look up for number one, that is, to struggle for the defense of their national interests first and foremost, and if the defense of those interests involve making our life impossible on the negotiation table, guess what? that would not make them lose their sleep in any sense, so I don't see the reason why we dominicans should act any differently on principle.

"Another measure that the state have to take urgently (something which is being planned right now, but only with the people of the armed forces) is to repopulate the border provinces (Monte Cristi, Dajabon, Elias Piña, Independencia and Pedernales) with ethnic dominican families".

not to get too much into the subject that i copied and pasted but i do have a question. do you really take seriously what the government is trying to do by taking this measure in repopulating the border? look how long it has taken them to take such an action that one would think should have happened many moons ago.
by the way excelent post lautaro
Post IP/Country: 170.232.192.1* / US
#57 - Posted 8 October 2009, 8:46 AM
Location: Dominican Republic
Join date: June 2009
Member #: 2945
Posts: 502
Send Message
RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens
Quote:
antonioj previously said:

It's quite ludicrous... what you wrote above. Micaela I wonder what make you a linguistic expert all the sudden and perhaps you can share some of the details to validate your conclusions of facts.


Antonio, sorry for offending your sensibility. I am not linguist expert, but I thought that everybody could pick the native French and Creole speakers by their heavy accent and especially the way they stress the 'r'. I have a Frech girlfriend that had lived in DR for 25 years, speaks fluent Spanish and still you can hear it.
Post IP/Country: 64.251.32.25* / US
#58 - Posted 8 October 2009, 9:14 AM
Location: United States, El Guapito Jarabacoence,Nariz de Guineo, a troll and lloronas nightmare, right hand of El Boogeyman!
Join date: August 2009
Member #: 3407
Posts: 1929
Send Message
RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens
Quote:
Micaela previously said:

Quote:
antonioj previously said:

It's quite ludicrous... what you wrote above. Micaela I wonder what make you a linguistic expert all the sudden and perhaps you can share some of the details to validate your conclusions of facts.


Antonio, sorry for offending your sensibility. I am not linguist expert, but I thought that everybody could pick the native French and Creole speakers by their heavy accent and especially the way they stress the 'r'. I have a Frech girlfriend that had lived in DR for 25 years, speaks fluent Spanish and still you can hear it.

i thought their r was flat. at least according to trujillo!
Post IP/Country: 170.232.192.1* / US
#59 - Posted 8 October 2009, 9:25 AM
Location: United States, "El Amanza GUAPOS, BIGOTS, TROLLS, LLORONAS y SELF-PROCLAIMED DOMINICAN "PATRIOTS" De Villa Duarte"
Join date: August 2008
Member #: 1255
Posts: 5429
Send Message
RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens
Quote:
TanBellaMami previously said:

Quote:
TuPapaupa previously said:
Well, KIDDO, for a guy that sounds smart, you suuuuuuure write alot of nonsense.

It doesn't matter if you separate posts by changing colors, when you delete the writer's name, unless people here are magicians, they can't tell who wrote what.

I don't think I was telling you to "do all the job for posters in helping them keep up", but, for the love of God, don't, you don't have to make it harder..



Precisely (lol).

My job is to allow people to see which contents I am responding to and the actual posters can remain anonymous since it is the content we are debating not directly the poster him or herself. That is our problems, we often want to know the posters so we could engaged on direct personal ranting attacks of disagreement. This is not a scholarly paper where I have to give credit to actual posters, but if I do post or reply directly to their quote I do, but if I do not, it is not as if I am writing my response considering TuPapaupa migh want to know my sources (lol ha hah).

I will try to post you name next to you quotes "Oh great one: (lol)!

No, your "job" is to not make it difficult for others when you are quoting someone.....deleting the name of the person you quoted is unnecessary, ESPECIALLY when quoting TWO posts from 2 different posters.......

Over a year ago, in one of our many battles I told you that talking to you was like talking to a wall.....

A year later, although not in battle, I feel the same way (at least on this topic).

That said, enjoy "your" thread because I am DONE replying to you about this subject.

ABULLLLLLL!.
Edited on 10/8/2009 10:38 AM by TuPapaupa.

I am The BOOO!!GEYMAN...Hide The Kids And Stop The VELORIO, The Dancing, The Singing, The Whining, The Nagging, The Complaining and LLORADERA....El LEONAAAAAAAAZO De Villa Duarte is Here!.
Post IP/Country: 209.204.65.14* / US
#60 - Posted 8 October 2009, 10:21 AM
Location: Canada, home safe
Join date: January 2008
Member #: 268
Posts: 2673
Send Message
RE: Question to Dominicans about Haitians becoming Dominican citizens
Quote:
MIRABUENO previously said:

Quote:
Micaela previously said:

Quote:
antonioj previously said:

It's quite ludicrous... what you wrote above. Micaela I wonder what make you a linguistic expert all the sudden and perhaps you can share some of the details to validate your conclusions of facts.


Antonio, sorry for offending your sensibility. I am not linguist expert, but I thought that everybody could pick the native French and Creole speakers by their heavy accent and especially the way they stress the 'r'. I have a Frech girlfriend that had lived in DR for 25 years, speaks fluent Spanish and still you can hear it.

i thought their r was flat. at least according to trujillo!

The R is flat, Micael granted no offense, here is just one example only, however chances are you will not pick any accent for me or afro let's not fall into generalization here.
Edited on 10/8/2009 10:27 AM by antonioj.
We must accept finite disappointment, but never lose infinite hope.
Post IP/Country: 74.198.12.* / CA