Dominican Today Forum » Living in the DR » General Info » Agriculture failing in the DR
#1 - Posted 5 November 2011, 10:07 PM
Location: United States
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 4
Posts: 17818
Send Message
Agriculture failing in the DR
this appeared in the news today

Oxfam study urges attention to farming

Reporting on findings in a recent analysis of government spending, international development agency Oxfam says that budget allocations to farming show that the political class gives little importance to the sector. Intermon Oxfam said that the DR-CAFTA free trade agreement has ruined national producers.

"In the 1980s, the government spent 14.1% of all revenues in farming. In the 1990s, spending had declined to 9.6%. But in the past decade, the government spent less than 5%," says the report.

Intermon Oxfam says that food and farming are at risk in the Dominican Republic.

"Decades of negligence in farming has resulted in the situation the country is in with few alternatives for replacing expensive imports with domestic production or making the most of high food prices abroad and stimulating farm exports and rural employment," concludes the report, produced for the Crece campaign. According to Intermon Oxfam, indiscriminate imports are not only affecting producers, but also the final consumer who is hard pressed to pay for the goods.

The report says that for the period 2007-2010 when the DR-CAFTA has been implemented, food imports from the US increased four times more than local production, which means that local products are being displaced. "And that is only the beginning of the markets opening," warned the organization. The report says that former small farmers have migrated to the cities, and the remaining farms only survive today by importing low- cost labor. "It is about the poor hiring the destitute," say the experts.

Intermon Oxfam urges the government to spend on farming to increase and modernize irrigation capacity, adding that the improvement of access roads was urgent, as well as access to credit, which has always been a key obstacle to farm development.

The organization forecast that food prices would continue to rise, projecting increases of 120-180% by 2030.

In the Dominican Republic, for many years farmers in the San Jose de Ocoa agriculture area have been calling for the repair of the key highway to the mountain area. Yesterday, the Ministry of Public Works signed a commitment to repair the 39 critical points after years of delays.

See http://intermonoxfam.org/es/campanas/proyectos/crece

www.oxfam.org/sites/www.oxfam.org/files/growing-a-better-future-010611-en.pdf

www.acento.com.do/index.php/news/8790/56/Oxfam-Gobierno-dominicano-descuida-el-campo-y-DR-CAFTA-arruina-productores.html

i stated, several times, that DRCAFTA is going to be the ruin of local production. asymetric trade agreements, by their very nature, will have this result. i am sure that Atabey will take a strong look at this article, especially since i am not the author
Post IP/Country: 190.167.163.16* / DO
Advertisement
Sponsored Links
#2 - Posted 5 November 2011, 10:20 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 38
Posts: 5742
Send Message
RE: Agriculture failing in the DR
Quote:
dreadlocks previously said:

this appeared in the news today

Oxfam study urges attention to farming

Reporting on findings in a recent analysis of government spending, international development agency Oxfam says that budget allocations to farming show that the political class gives little importance to the sector. Intermon Oxfam said that the DR-CAFTA free trade agreement has ruined national producers.

"In the 1980s, the government spent 14.1% of all revenues in farming. In the 1990s, spending had declined to 9.6%. But in the past decade, the government spent less than 5%," says the report.

Intermon Oxfam says that food and farming are at risk in the Dominican Republic.

"Decades of negligence in farming has resulted in the situation the country is in with few alternatives for replacing expensive imports with domestic production or making the most of high food prices abroad and stimulating farm exports and rural employment," concludes the report, produced for the Crece campaign. According to Intermon Oxfam, indiscriminate imports are not only affecting producers, but also the final consumer who is hard pressed to pay for the goods.

The report says that for the period 2007-2010 when the DR-CAFTA has been implemented, food imports from the US increased four times more than local production, which means that local products are being displaced. "And that is only the beginning of the markets opening," warned the organization. The report says that former small farmers have migrated to the cities, and the remaining farms only survive today by importing low- cost labor. "It is about the poor hiring the destitute," say the experts.

Intermon Oxfam urges the government to spend on farming to increase and modernize irrigation capacity, adding that the improvement of access roads was urgent, as well as access to credit, which has always been a key obstacle to farm development.

The organization forecast that food prices would continue to rise, projecting increases of 120-180% by 2030.

In the Dominican Republic, for many years farmers in the San Jose de Ocoa agriculture area have been calling for the repair of the key highway to the mountain area. Yesterday, the Ministry of Public Works signed a commitment to repair the 39 critical points after years of delays.

See http://intermonoxfam.org/es/campanas/proyectos/crece

www.oxfam.org/sites/www.oxfam.org/files/growing-a-better-future-010611-en.pdf

www.acento.com.do/index.php/news/8790/56/Oxfam-Gobierno-dominicano-descuida-el-campo-y-DR-CAFTA-arruina-productores.html

i stated, several times, that DRCAFTA is going to be the ruin of local production. asymetric trade agreements, by their very nature, will have this result. i am sure that Atabey will take a strong look at this article, especially since i am not the author


The really bad news is that almost everyone and their mother on leading posts and the society at large here actually supports the blasted treaty. It's like seeing a car crash unfolding.
Edited on 11/5/2011 10:21 PM by Lautaro.
"A man who strives after goodness in all his acts is sure to come to ruin, since there are so many men who are not good."

Niccolo Macchiavelli - The Prince

Post IP/Country: 190.166.130.17* / DO
#3 - Posted 6 November 2011, 1:23 AM
Location: United States
Join date: June 2008
Member #: 933
Posts: 7988
Send Message
RE: Agriculture failing in the DR
Quote:
dreadlocks previously said:



"In the 1980s, the government spent 14.1% of all revenues in farming. In the 1990s, spending had declined to 9.6%. But in the past decade, the government spent less than 5%," says the report.




How come they don't question the wisdom of government subsidizing an industry in order to garner more control?
Proof of dreadlocks Bigotry.
"....... what did Cubans do to deserve preferential treatment?......and treat Black people in the most racist of ways.......... the Cubans are just a bunch of uberracist savages."
: I WILL NOT ANSWER ANY POSTS BY THE BIGOT KNOWN AS DREADLOCKS.
Post IP/Country: 98.254.152.12* / US
#4 - Posted 6 November 2011, 9:57 AM
Location: United Kingdom, Dominican Republic
Join date: August 2008
Member #: 1307
Posts: 10356
Send Message
RE: Agriculture failing in the DR
Quote:
anthonyC previously said:

Quote:
dreadlocks previously said:



"In the 1980s, the government spent 14.1% of all revenues in farming. In the 1990s, spending had declined to 9.6%. But in the past decade, the government spent less than 5%," says the report.




How come they don't question the wisdom of government subsidizing an industry in order to garner more control?

Since ancient times it has been the responsibilty of governments to ensure good food supplies for their populations. Had present governmens taken their responsibilites more seriously the health and welfare of many nation's peoples would be better.

Because of an excess of beef now obesity is a desease as people chomp through the mountains of hamburgers.

S.
Post IP/Country: 190.167.179.20* / DO
#5 - Posted 6 November 2011, 12:11 PM
Location: United States
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 4
Posts: 17818
Send Message
RE: Agriculture failing in the DR
Dr anthonyc waxes quizzical


How come they don't question the wisdom of government subsidizing an industry in order to garner more control?

who said anything about subsidies? since when is government spending on agriculture necessarily a subsidy? what if government established an agricultural college, or research institution? i know you are dense, but think before you make idiotic remarks, if that is at all possible.
Post IP/Country: 190.167.163.16* / DO
#6 - Posted 6 November 2011, 12:13 PM
Location: United States
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 4
Posts: 17818
Send Message
RE: Agriculture failing in the DR
Mr Lautaro, i hate to say ¨i told you so¨, but i will. ever since this treaty came along, i have been saying that it would ruin the DR farmer. well, there you have it. one of my good buddies seems to be eerily silent about this....come in, Ata.
Post IP/Country: 190.167.163.16* / DO
#7 - Posted 6 November 2011, 2:49 PM
Location: United States
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 4
Posts: 17818
Send Message
RE: Agriculture failing in the DR
Mr Lautaro, this article might interest you. others who are interested, take a look



http://www.oxfam.org/en/news/pressreleases2006/pr060614_song_sirens
Edited on 11/6/2011 2:51 PM by dreadlocks.
Post IP/Country: 190.167.163.16* / DO
#8 - Posted 6 November 2011, 2:59 PM
Location: United States
Join date: June 2008
Member #: 933
Posts: 7988
Send Message
RE: Agriculture failing in the DR
Quote:
dreadlocks previously said:

Dr anthonyc waxes quizzical


How come they don't question the wisdom of government subsidizing an industry in order to garner more control?

who said anything about subsidies? since when is government spending on agriculture necessarily a subsidy? what if government established an agricultural college, or research institution? i know you are dense, but think before you make idiotic remarks, if that is at all possible.



Wow.......If the government gives money, land, tax breaks to farmers or institute price controls or tariffs on imports it is a subsidy. UNDERSTAND?
Proof of dreadlocks Bigotry.
"....... what did Cubans do to deserve preferential treatment?......and treat Black people in the most racist of ways.......... the Cubans are just a bunch of uberracist savages."
: I WILL NOT ANSWER ANY POSTS BY THE BIGOT KNOWN AS DREADLOCKS.
Post IP/Country: 98.254.152.12* / US
#9 - Posted 6 November 2011, 3:02 PM
Location: United States
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 4
Posts: 17818
Send Message
RE: Agriculture failing in the DR
here is no such thing as "free trade"
Yep - we're back on this old chestnut again.

If it wasn't for the fact that the consequences of this fixation with "free trade" was so damaging for Britain as a nation there would be some sort of delicious irony in the fact that "free trade" conservatives will be the authors of their own destruction. However, their destruction will also mean the destruction of this nation and its people.

Free trade does not exist. It is questionable whether it is even possible (or desirable) to attain free trade within a national economy, but it most certainly is not possible beyond national borders.

For free trade to exist you have to have identical conditions for trade between the two trading parties - not mostly similar or relatively close conditions - they have to be identical. If they are not then one or other party will have a "penalty" and the trade can not be free.

As I said, this is pretty hard to achieve even within the national context. There are still regional discrepancies and so trade is never really free within national borders - but at least you can have a single government that can make those conditions as similar as it is possible to be.

But when you are talking about two different nations with two different governments with widely differing approaches to trade then "free trade" is nothing of the sort - and if those conditions of trade offer one of those nations such a massive advantage that you can not compete with it then it is in your national interest to impose conditions on trade with that nation.

If you don't then you are effectively giving up on your national economy. Other nations will take advantage of that and plunder your nation for what they can get. They'll sell you whatever they can and buy up whatever they want - until you've got nothing left to offer them at which point they'll leave you and go elsewhere

you are free to agree with, or disagree with, these truisms.
Post IP/Country: 190.167.163.16* / DO
#10 - Posted 6 November 2011, 3:05 PM
Location: United States
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 4
Posts: 17818
Send Message
RE: Agriculture failing in the DR
Dr anthonyc informs us

Wow.......If the government gives money, land, tax breaks to farmers or institute price controls or tariffs on imports it is a subsidy. UNDERSTAND?

i have implored you, many a time and oft, to go to school. my exhortations have, apparently, fallen upon deaf ears. ergo, you make nonsensical statements that price controls are subsidies. are your parents aware that you are making an internationsl spectacle of yourself with your ignorance?
Post IP/Country: 190.167.163.16* / DO