Dominican Today Forum » Living in the DR » General Info » Que pasa with the USA and the DR relations?
#61 - Posted 8 April 2009, 12:57 PM
Location: United States, DR
Join date: August 2008
Member #: 1291
Posts: 8401
Send Message
RE: Que pasa with the USA and the DR relations?
Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:

Quote:
generoso previously said:

So that explains a lot of things.
The Haitians exported and exiled the best human capital in a thirst to confiscate their properties and keep them for high rankings Haitian military that were turned over as a war price.
These colonists later founded the most successful Cuban sugar emporiums that coincidently had
French roots, like the Gomez-Mena, the Fanjuls (that claim Spanish descent) and others.
Regarding the Puerto Rico French influence that does explain a lot about their particular pronunciation.
Thanks ciby, what about the 800 soldiers that fought under Lafayette? Did they return to Haiti or stayed in he USA? My theory is that they returned to Haiti and capitalized on the experience gained in real war
to start the Haitian revolution in 1791. (The most useful soldiers are veterans of real wars).


I read somewhere that the Fanjuls are descended from Dominicans that left to Cuba during the era we're discussing and that they and the Dominican Franjul family have a common root. How much of this is true I cannot say with any certainty. As for the french/white haitian immigration to cuba take a gander at this:

http://www.latinamericanstudies.org/cuba/French-in-Cuba.pdf



No relation whatsoever between the Franjuls and the Fanjuls., I asked the same question.
Interesting article I read it all.

"Speak softly, and carry a big stick, you will go far".
Post IP: 201.229.209.22*
Advertisement
Sponsored Links
#62 - Posted 8 April 2009, 1:09 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 38
Posts: 5613
Send Message
RE: Que pasa with the USA and the DR relations?
Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:


That is correct, sith lord. But the agricultural technology they introduced to said island had revertebrations for the rest of the century. Several franco families, though, obviously managed to stay in Spanish territory. The Duverges are one such family that comes to mind.



Their impact would be mostly felt on the coffee industry, where they would revitalize the almost extinct cuban production, specially on the Santiago de Cuba area, which would become the most important producer of this article on the island, while the northwest would become the sugar stronghold of the country, with a few tobacco producers in between (most of them concentrated on the Pinar del Rio area). The french would also teach the cuban oligarchs how to control large numbers of slaves, although the cubans would not be complacent on this score, cuz' they feared a reenactment of the haitian disaster on their soil. That would explain why they would put an emphasis in copying their american counterparts in creating a large white middle class to serve as a buffer against the black/coloured masses, this being the reason explaining why in Cuba the demographical imbalance of Saint Domingue and Jamaica would be almost absent, cuz' the cubans (and the spaniards in general) put more emphasis to their personal security than on the fast generation of wealth. Another idea that would be wildly popular among the cuban property class would be to accomplish an annexation of the island by the USA, which they perceived as a power that would be more effective than the feeble Spain in securing their property and lives were a massive slave uprising to occur.
Edited on 4/8/2009 1:12 PM by Lautaro.
"A man who strives after goodness in all his acts is sure to come to ruin, since there are so many men who are not good."

Niccolo Macchiavelli - The Prince

Post IP: 200.88.48.3*
#63 - Posted 8 April 2009, 1:12 PM
Location: United States, DR
Join date: August 2008
Member #: 1291
Posts: 8401
Send Message
RE: Que pasa with the USA and the DR relations?
So again the same point and historical mistake happens time and time again.
The French brought their chemist experience and agricultural know how from Haiti to Cuba.
Then to Louisiana, then back to Cuba. Then back to Louisiana. But they were the pillars of progress and when the affranchis and military took over in Haiti they didn't have the brains and they failed miserably.
Happened again in the 20 th century with Fidel, the Cubans with money and human capital fled the island, leaving misery behind, and a great shortage of competent management and human capital.
Happened in Haiti recently (1990's I believe) when many Haitian teachers were hired by the UN and sent to French speaking Africa, depleting Haiti of a valuable resource.
Happened in Germany after the Nazi persecution of the Jewish scientists that emigrated to the USA, and many of those scientists
later contributed to build the atomic bomb that would have been used on Germany if they had succeeded in the war in Europe.
So then going back to the Haitian question they were then four classes of residents in Haiti, not three:

1. The grand blancs or plantation owners mostly born in France
2. The petit blancs, or workmen, tailors, chemists, foremen and so forth.
3. The affranchis or mulattoes sons of grand blancs and slaves, or petit blancs and slaves.
4. The African slaves or their descendants.





Edited on 4/8/2009 1:16 PM by generoso.
"Speak softly, and carry a big stick, you will go far".
Post IP: 201.229.209.22*
#64 - Posted 8 April 2009, 1:16 PM
Location: United States, New York City
Join date: February 2008
Member #: 411
Posts: 5683
Send Message
RE: Que pasa with the USA and the DR relations?
Quote:
generoso previously said:

So again the same point and historical mistake happens time and time again.
The French brought their chemist experience and agricultural know how from Haiti to Cuba.
Then to Louisiana, then back to Cuba. Then back to Louisiana. But they were the pillars of progress and when the affranchis and military took over in Haiti they didn't have the brains and they failed miserably.
Happened again in the 20 th century with Fidel, the Cubans with money and human capital fled the island, leaving misery behind, and a great shortage of competent management and human capital.
Happened in Haiti recently (1990's I believe) when many Haitian teachers were hired by the UN and sent to French speaking Africa, depleting Haiti of a valuable resource.
Happened in Germany after the Nazi persecution of the Jewish scientists that emigrated to the USA, and many of those scientists
later contributed to build the atomic bomb that would have been used on Germany if they had succeeded in the war in Europe.
So then going back to the Haitian question they were then four classes of citizens in Haiti, not three:

1. The grand blancs or plantation owners mostly born in France
2. The petit blancs, or workmen, tailors, chemists, foremen and so forth.
3. The affranchis or mulattoes sons of grand blancs and slaves, or petit blancs and slaves.
4. The African slaves or their descendants.

You forget to mention free people of color who were not mulatto, people such as Touissant himself.








You forget to mention free people of color who were not mulatto, people such as Touissant himself.
"If you're going through hell, keep going." - Winston Churchill
Post IP: 161.185.150.18*
#65 - Posted 8 April 2009, 1:18 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 38
Posts: 5613
Send Message
RE: Que pasa with the USA and the DR relations?
Quote:
generoso previously said:

So again the same point and historical mistake happens time and time again.
The French brought their chemist experience and agricultural know how from Haiti to Cuba.
Then to Louisiana, then back to Cuba. Then back to Louisiana. But they were the pillars of progress and when the affranchis and military took over in Haiti they didn't have the brains and they failed miserably.
Happened again in the 20 th century with Fidel, the Cubans with money and human capital fled the island, leaving misery behind, and a great shortage of competent management and human capital.
Happened in Haiti recently (1990's I believe) when many Haitian teachers were hired by the UN and sent to French speaking Africa, depleting Haiti of a valuable resource.
Happened in Germany after the Nazi persecution of the Jewish scientists that emigrated to the USA, and many of those scientists
later contributed to build the atomic bomb that would have been used on Germany if they had succeeded in the war in Europe.
So then going back to the Haitian question they were then four classes of citizens in Haiti, not three:

1. The grand blancs or plantation owners mostly born in France
2. The petit blancs, or workmen, tailors, chemists, foremen and so forth.
3. The affranchis or mulattoes sons of grand blancs and slaves, or petit blancs and slaves.
4. The African slaves or their descendants.



One of the things that would explain the astounding success of the rebellion would be the bitter divisions among the first three, which allowed the latter to defeat every single one of them separately. On that score, I tend to divide the time within the rebellion in which every group held the reins as follows:

1. Grand blancs (1789-1791)
2. Petits blancs (1791-1793)
3. The affranchis (1793-1798)
4. The african slaves (1798-1802)
Edited on 4/8/2009 1:28 PM by Lautaro.
"A man who strives after goodness in all his acts is sure to come to ruin, since there are so many men who are not good."

Niccolo Macchiavelli - The Prince

Post IP: 200.88.48.3*
#66 - Posted 8 April 2009, 1:19 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 38
Posts: 5613
Send Message
RE: Que pasa with the USA and the DR relations?
Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:

Quote:
generoso previously said:

So again the same point and historical mistake happens time and time again.
The French brought their chemist experience and agricultural know how from Haiti to Cuba.
Then to Louisiana, then back to Cuba. Then back to Louisiana. But they were the pillars of progress and when the affranchis and military took over in Haiti they didn't have the brains and they failed miserably.
Happened again in the 20 th century with Fidel, the Cubans with money and human capital fled the island, leaving misery behind, and a great shortage of competent management and human capital.
Happened in Haiti recently (1990's I believe) when many Haitian teachers were hired by the UN and sent to French speaking Africa, depleting Haiti of a valuable resource.
Happened in Germany after the Nazi persecution of the Jewish scientists that emigrated to the USA, and many of those scientists
later contributed to build the atomic bomb that would have been used on Germany if they had succeeded in the war in Europe.
So then going back to the Haitian question they were then four classes of citizens in Haiti, not three:

1. The grand blancs or plantation owners mostly born in France
2. The petit blancs, or workmen, tailors, chemists, foremen and so forth.
3. The affranchis or mulattoes sons of grand blancs and slaves, or petit blancs and slaves.
4. The African slaves or their descendants.

You forget to mention free people of color who were not mulatto, people such as Touissant himself.



You forget to mention free people of color who were not mulatto, people such as Touissant himself.



That might be so, but the fact at the end of the day is that the majority of that class was composed by those mixed people. Only a handful of them (like Toussaint and the mulatto Lamartiniere) would go out their way in supporting the brigand faction. It would not be until Leclerc exiled Rigaud when the mixed people would adhere themselves to the brigand faction almost to a man.
Edited on 4/8/2009 1:21 PM by Lautaro.
"A man who strives after goodness in all his acts is sure to come to ruin, since there are so many men who are not good."

Niccolo Macchiavelli - The Prince

Post IP: 200.88.48.3*
#67 - Posted 8 April 2009, 1:26 PM
Location: United States, New York City
Join date: February 2008
Member #: 411
Posts: 5683
Send Message
RE: Que pasa with the USA and the DR relations?
Quote:
Lautaro previously said:

Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:

Quote:
generoso previously said:

So again the same point and historical mistake happens time and time again.
The French brought their chemist experience and agricultural know how from Haiti to Cuba.
Then to Louisiana, then back to Cuba. Then back to Louisiana. But they were the pillars of progress and when the affranchis and military took over in Haiti they didn't have the brains and they failed miserably.
Happened again in the 20 th century with Fidel, the Cubans with money and human capital fled the island, leaving misery behind, and a great shortage of competent management and human capital.
Happened in Haiti recently (1990's I believe) when many Haitian teachers were hired by the UN and sent to French speaking Africa, depleting Haiti of a valuable resource.
Happened in Germany after the Nazi persecution of the Jewish scientists that emigrated to the USA, and many of those scientists
later contributed to build the atomic bomb that would have been used on Germany if they had succeeded in the war in Europe.
So then going back to the Haitian question they were then four classes of citizens in Haiti, not three:

1. The grand blancs or plantation owners mostly born in France
2. The petit blancs, or workmen, tailors, chemists, foremen and so forth.
3. The affranchis or mulattoes sons of grand blancs and slaves, or petit blancs and slaves.
4. The African slaves or their descendants.

You forget to mention free people of color who were not mulatto, people such as Touissant himself.



You forget to mention free people of color who were not mulatto, people such as Touissant himself.



That might be so, but the fact at the end of the day is that the majority of that class was composed by those mixed people. Only a handful of them (like Toussaint and the mulatto Lamartiniere) would go out their way in supporting the brigand faction. It would not be until Leclerc exiled Rigaud when the mixed people would adhere themselves to the brigand faction almost to a man.



The haitian mulatto class before the revolution is of much interest to me. They developed a specific ethos that was very peculiar. Very interesting group. Too bad that their decimated numbers rose to be the new oppressors of the Haitian masses.
"If you're going through hell, keep going." - Winston Churchill
Post IP: 161.185.150.18*
#68 - Posted 8 April 2009, 1:36 PM
Location: United States, DR
Join date: August 2008
Member #: 1291
Posts: 8401
Send Message
RE: Que pasa with the USA and the DR relations?
That is correct, five classes then, because they were some although not many blacks that were free blacks.
"Papa Touissant" as he was called later, was a free slave at 33 and did own slaves after that I read.
He did not trust mulattoes after the retreat of the officers in the battle of St. Marc.
Even though he was a francophile the French took advantage of his peaceful retirement in the country and put him in chains, and sent him to France where he later died.
The best ally of the freedom fighters in Haiti was the poor resistance to disease of the European soldiers, so that many French soldiers were being decimated by yellow fever epidemic.
He also understood the concept of welcoming back the white French colonists that were indispensable
for the progress of the island.
Edited on 4/8/2009 1:42 PM by generoso.
"Speak softly, and carry a big stick, you will go far".
Post IP: 201.229.209.22*
#69 - Posted 8 April 2009, 1:38 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 38
Posts: 5613
Send Message
RE: Que pasa with the USA and the DR relations?
Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:

Quote:
Lautaro previously said:

Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:

Quote:
generoso previously said:

So again the same point and historical mistake happens time and time again.
The French brought their chemist experience and agricultural know how from Haiti to Cuba.
Then to Louisiana, then back to Cuba. Then back to Louisiana. But they were the pillars of progress and when the affranchis and military took over in Haiti they didn't have the brains and they failed miserably.
Happened again in the 20 th century with Fidel, the Cubans with money and human capital fled the island, leaving misery behind, and a great shortage of competent management and human capital.
Happened in Haiti recently (1990's I believe) when many Haitian teachers were hired by the UN and sent to French speaking Africa, depleting Haiti of a valuable resource.
Happened in Germany after the Nazi persecution of the Jewish scientists that emigrated to the USA, and many of those scientists
later contributed to build the atomic bomb that would have been used on Germany if they had succeeded in the war in Europe.
So then going back to the Haitian question they were then four classes of citizens in Haiti, not three:

1. The grand blancs or plantation owners mostly born in France
2. The petit blancs, or workmen, tailors, chemists, foremen and so forth.
3. The affranchis or mulattoes sons of grand blancs and slaves, or petit blancs and slaves.
4. The African slaves or their descendants.

You forget to mention free people of color who were not mulatto, people such as Touissant himself.



You forget to mention free people of color who were not mulatto, people such as Touissant himself.



That might be so, but the fact at the end of the day is that the majority of that class was composed by those mixed people. Only a handful of them (like Toussaint and the mulatto Lamartiniere) would go out their way in supporting the brigand faction. It would not be until Leclerc exiled Rigaud when the mixed people would adhere themselves to the brigand faction almost to a man.



The haitian mulatto class before the revolution is of much interest to me. They developed a specific ethos that was very peculiar. Very interesting group. Too bad that their decimated numbers rose to be the new oppressors of the Haitian masses.


As incredible as it sounds, that class was almost as plagued with internal divisions as the "blancs" themselves. Some of them supporting the grand blancs, which were royalists in their majority, others supporting the republican side (represented by the commissioners sent routinely by the revolutionary gov. in Paris in their attempt to keep the colony under control) and others, a scant minority, supporting the black brigands. It seems that their only interest was to support the group which they perceived as the one with the upper hand at the moment.
"A man who strives after goodness in all his acts is sure to come to ruin, since there are so many men who are not good."

Niccolo Macchiavelli - The Prince

Post IP: 200.88.48.3*
#70 - Posted 8 April 2009, 1:38 PM
Location: United States, DR
Join date: August 2008
Member #: 1291
Posts: 8401
Send Message
RE: Que pasa with the USA and the DR relations?
Duplication
Edited on 4/8/2009 1:39 PM by generoso.
"Speak softly, and carry a big stick, you will go far".
Post IP: 201.229.209.22*