Dominican Today Forum » Living in the DR » General Info » What It Says For Race On DR's ID Card?
#21 - Posted 10 April 2009, 10:13 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 38
Posts: 5103
Send Message
RE: What It Says For Race On DR's ID Card?
Quote:
AfroLatino previously said:

Quote:
Lautaro previously said:

My cedula declares me as "indio". But generally speaking, I consider myself to be a mixed race person. That's why you'll find me on the frontlines battling the one drop rule, cuz' I refuse to identify myself with only one of the ethnic groups conforming my line.


Okay so is being "Indio" means one is white? No, being "Indio" still put you as a man of color. You know the various races named by geography right. The White race, the Black race, the Yellow race and the Red race. So given you say you are Indio and quite pssibly I am sure May I assume) you might have African Leneage that puts you even more as a colored man. So do you identify with the red race or the black race more (lol)? The world's majority of race is colored... Does a white man would waste his time trying to tellyou all of those mixes that you are? I do not think so.


See, you're operating under the one-drop rule mindset when you mock my attempt to honor ALL the races on my lineage EQUALLY. Just because you have x% of a race on your bloodline, it doesn't mean that you have to be forced to adhere to a determined culture. Can we simply just agree to disagree? Maybe these essays will make you understand what I'm fighting up against:

http://backintyme.com/essays/?p=15

http://backintyme.com/essays/?p=16

http://backintyme.com/essays/?p=6
Edited on 4/10/2009 10:40 PM by Lautaro.
"A man who strives after goodness in all his acts is sure to come to ruin, since there are so many men who are not good."

Niccolo Macchiavelli - The Prince

Post IP: 190.0.86.2*
Advertisement
Sponsored Links
#22 - Posted 10 April 2009, 10:40 PM
Location: Dominican Republic
Join date: March 2009
Member #: 2266
Posts: 1533
Send Message
RE: What It Says For Race On DR's ID Card?
Quote:
AfroLatino previously said:

Quote:
Manhattanite previously said:

Well I'm not answering as I clearly have no cedula Who knows what silly thing a government bureaucrat would have put down ... I was a baby, and lighter than I am now. Even if I had one I don't think once I was an I would have paid much mind to gov. categories based on appearance as judged by a low paid functinary. My own interest in history would have brought me to identify as an original Dominican, of heritage so thoroughly blended it is dishonest to try and break it down. That is how most in my fam identfy as well, even those with no interest in history.

If I find my parent's old ones I'll let you know what they say.



Yeah, but what do you identify yourself with or as? Just saying you are a mixture is not a fact of race-Identity. That is simply and merely a compusure of breed... Point of the question is, what does it says on your ID card as race? There is not much way to go around this question. I mean, surely you cannot claim yourself white; we all know that. So waht is your race on that ID card or even what do you yourself consider your race is?

P.S: By the way, saying you are DOMINICAN means you are telling someone of your NATIONALITY and that is not a meaning term for race. Race is race, Ethnicity is ethicity and Nationality is nationality.

For example. I am a mix of Dominican-Haitian-Jewish because my mother is Dominican, my father Jewish and I was born in Haiti. Regardless of the fact that I have lived in DR for a long time, I am most identifyied with my nationality being Haitian at least I was until I became a US Citizen by the time I was 16 years of age. My Ethnicity is Latino but I call myself "AfroLatino" given that Haiti and/or my mix is consisting of these particular backgrounds I have listed above. It would be a long stretch for me to say or add "Medditerreanian" in there even though I am part that as well because of my father; but I identify with being part of the "Black" race or as I prefered "Colored."

On my mother's cedula they have her listed as "Negra" even though her, her mother and father are the whitest of light skin hues of Dominicans. However guess what, I did not take the color of neither my father or mother. I am a fair brown light skinned guy. darker than both my mother and most definitelly darker than my father who appears whites witha tan (lol).

No es asi de simple, Afrolatino. I view racial purity as something very sacred, that only happens once, when the bloodline got mixed, it's mixed and there is nothing that can be done about it but dilluting it to the point where your descendant is 99%+ percent that race. You don't belong to the black race because the genuine black race(Negroid)is something like Mugabe and Mandela with the shiny face and yellow sclera rather than Will Smith and Tyra Banks looking mofos. Many Ethiopians, Egyptians and Sudanese are of mixed Moorish/Negrid lineage, which explains the rather normal-looking noses they now posess and suggests that they are mutts. In conclusion, Johnny Ventura, David Ortiz and Pena gomez are technically black. Milly Quezada, Hector Acosta and Manny Ramirez aren't more than Eurafrican mutts.
Post IP: 76.24.128.20*
#23 - Posted 11 April 2009, 12:38 PM
Location: United States
Join date: February 2008
Member #: 340
Posts: 1192
Send Message
RE: What It Says For Race On DR's ID Card?
Based on these and other posts AfroLatino seems to be either obsessed with race/ethnicity and/or having self-identification issues in general and as it applies to DR in particular.

Here are a couple of facts that may or may not help you:

1. Dominican Republic is a LatinAmerican country.
2. Dominican Republic is a Spanish speaking country.
3. The other Spanish Caribbean Islands (Puerto Rico, Cuba) share the most similarity to DR.
4. Dominican is a nationality, it's not a single 'race' or color.
5. Dominicans fall under the Latino/Hispanic ethnic label.
6. Majority of Dominicans are of mixed heritage, this is backed up by genetic studies, ethnohistory, and anyone's eyeballs.

The 'indio' descriptor is very similar to the way Brazilians use the pardo descriptor. In Brazil, pardo is frequently used for people of any one of the following combiniations-mulattos/mestizos/zambos/tri-racials. etc. It's a very broad descriptor and it's usually people who aren't white or black.

I don't know if it's technically correct or not, but Haitians are not considered Latinos/Hispanics and neither do they self-identify as such here in the USA. If speaking French makes them Latinos/Hispanics, then that would mean French Guiana, Guadaloupe, Martinique, St. Martin, Quebec are Latinos too.
By the way, blame the French for the Latino term, it was they who came up with it ironically.
Post IP: 68.197.226.22*
#24 - Posted 11 April 2009, 5:14 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, La Union
Join date: July 2008
Member #: 1028
Posts: 1284
Send Message
RE: What It Says For Race On DR's ID Card?
Quote:
USADR previously said:

Based on these and other posts AfroLatino seems to be either obsessed with race/ethnicity and/or having self-identification issues in general and as it applies to DR in particular.

Here are a couple of facts that may or may not help you:

1. Dominican Republic is a LatinAmerican country.
2. Dominican Republic is a Spanish speaking country.
3. The other Spanish Caribbean Islands (Puerto Rico, Cuba) share the most similarity to DR.
4. Dominican is a nationality, it's not a single 'race' or color.
5. Dominicans fall under the Latino/Hispanic ethnic label.
6. Majority of Dominicans are of mixed heritage, this is backed up by genetic studies, ethnohistory, and anyone's eyeballs.

The 'indio' descriptor is very similar to the way Brazilians use the pardo descriptor. In Brazil, pardo is frequently used for people of any one of the following combiniations-mulattos/mestizos/zambos/tri-racials. etc. It's a very broad descriptor and it's usually people who aren't white or black.

I don't know if it's technically correct or not, but Haitians are not considered Latinos/Hispanics and neither do they self-identify as such here in the USA. If speaking French makes them Latinos/Hispanics, then that would mean French Guiana, Guadaloupe, Martinique, St. Martin, Quebec are Latinos too.
By the way, blame the French for the Latino term, it was they who came up with it ironically.



Duh, if you have not been paying attention and not doing your own selective reading you will see that I said that Nationality does not mean race or ethnicity. Dominicans falls under "latino" and the race is still "colored" or "Negros" no matter how much many Dominicans try to deviate from the facts or flatter other ethnic self labeled categories such as Indio. If that was this simple then the whole world would come up possibly not really having specific races, and ethnics.

Indeed, Haitians areconsidered latinos because being latino does nopt belong to those who speak spanish alone, but all the Romance languages or any dielects that derrived from any particular Romance languages such as French, Spanish, Italian and Portugues. Go read about it. It is not up to those who speak only Spanish to decide who is part of that category or not. Plain and simple, because muchlike you havein Brazil the "AfroLatinos" that is what Haitians are if they were to not want to simply refer to themselves as only latinos thus to give recognition to their African roots. So once again you have contradicting yourself by this last statement upon which justified and where my case rests "ironically" (indeed lol).

Dominicans, much like many people of the world indeed may be mixed; but it does not deter from the fact that you arenot considered white as well as a white person willnot considre you one; and being mixed in fact considers you as a person of color period. Dominicans may indeed be a mixture of White Europeans from Spain or (of anything of mixture a spanish person might be a descendant of), also they are mixed with African more so than Taino Indians because as History and facts willt ell you the Spaniard drove the Indigenous Tainos to extinction (Is that a lie as well?) or something most Dominicans still like to marginalized as the part of their fantasy gene pool just to simply evade from accepting the fact that they are part African in spite of their racial brainwashed hatred for their neighbor period. (Not to say that no Indigenous people may nothave survived to make this areality, but the amount of survivors where enormously slim but never the less granted some may have survived I am sure). However, it is funnyto me how Europeans have managed to make all people of color take and give importance to perception of racial color as to make most of the world glorify being of thier European mix over any other ethnic racial groups. Whether one is French from France, Spanish from Spain, Portugues from Portugal and Italian from Italy; guess what, they are all Europeans and regardless of their ancient past leneage and they have all accepted that, yet the same does not seem to apply for people of color who are indeed mixture of races of people such as the Latin-Americas.

Lastly, different people; different stroke of passionate subjects they like to takle as their endervors. As most on here like to embarked in constant bashing and denigration of one another, I suppose mine is indeed set on the racial aspects of debates which does not proclure to be any lack of identity or issue on my part, but rather indeed much embrace for the multitude of all and much identity there is of my being me. That is where your true color to derogate one's race and ethnicity as bieng lesser human comes to play.
Post IP: 74.63.93.15*
#25 - Posted 11 April 2009, 5:27 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, La Union
Join date: July 2008
Member #: 1028
Posts: 1284
Send Message
RE: What It Says For Race On DR's ID Card?
Quote:
Gizmo previously said:

Cibaeño75
Mi cedula me declara "blanco".

AFROLATINO
Responde a me de verdad por favor mi amigo. Hay todas las cedulas declaran los gentes de Republica Dominicana "Blanco"?

Do all or the general ID of the mass populace declare them as "White" and are you in fact or actually consider yourself "White" for real?
Does a White European descent view you as "White"?

GIZMO
AfroLatino "Does a White European descent view you as "White"? You know AfroLatino Europe doesn't have a racket on whiteness or white as a color. If you're color is white than you're genetic make up has a relation to Europe. Just as if you're pigmentation is dark brown or black and you're traits are those of Africans, then your genetic make up has a relation to Africa. The same question?"Likewise does a Black African descent view you as "Black"? Remember the Dominican Republic is a country with an array of colors and shades and hair textures, trigueños are part of that mix also. So when you talk about Dominicans we are a rich array of colors and races. NOT SIMPLY BLACK AND WHITE.





Indeed, most Black African descent people in the US who sees a person of color more often than not just see them as Black, unless they are outspokenly have something of pure evidence to tell them otherwise. Whereas a White person, no matter how closer light skin you are to them or just half mixed still see one as either simply Black or colored as well and never as white like themselves. Indeed with that premise I rest my case. So, why Dominicans like to claim they are all kinds of flattered races or ethnicities as you put it "rich array of colors and races" (not to say that it is not true) before they can accept or not to ever accept being of African leneage or even as people of color is in fact a mind sickness and an identity issue instilled by Europeans who have made the world to derogate all that is of color darker than the White skin of race. The same goes for someone who will say that just because I talk about racial issues means I have "Identity Issue" could not have been so far from the truth. In fact when one denies bieng of or abstain from a certain racial leneage by accpeting all others before the ones they resent and like to defame is the one exact proof of self-loathing and dientity issue indeed. Not hte other way around.
Post IP: 66.90.104.7*
#26 - Posted 11 April 2009, 5:30 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 38
Posts: 5103
Send Message
RE: What It Says For Race On DR's ID Card?
Quote:
AfroLatino previously said:

Quote:
Gizmo previously said:

Cibaeño75
Mi cedula me declara "blanco".

AFROLATINO
Responde a me de verdad por favor mi amigo. Hay todas las cedulas declaran los gentes de Republica Dominicana "Blanco"?

Do all or the general ID of the mass populace declare them as "White" and are you in fact or actually consider yourself "White" for real?
Does a White European descent view you as "White"?

GIZMO
AfroLatino "Does a White European descent view you as "White"? You know AfroLatino Europe doesn't have a racket on whiteness or white as a color. If you're color is white than you're genetic make up has a relation to Europe. Just as if you're pigmentation is dark brown or black and you're traits are those of Africans, then your genetic make up has a relation to Africa. The same question?"Likewise does a Black African descent view you as "Black"? Remember the Dominican Republic is a country with an array of colors and shades and hair textures, trigueños are part of that mix also. So when you talk about Dominicans we are a rich array of colors and races. NOT SIMPLY BLACK AND WHITE.





Indeed, most Black African descent people in the US who sees a person of color more often than not just see them as Black, unless they are outspokenly have something of pure evidence to tell them otherwise. Whereas a White person, no matter how closer light skin you are to them or just half mixed still see one as either simply Black or colored as well and never as white like themselves. Indeed with that premise I rest my case. So, why Dominicans like to claim they are all kinds of flattered races or ethnicities as you put it "rich array of colors and races" (not to say that it is not true) before they can accept or not to ever accept being of African leneage or even as people of color is in fact a mind sickness and an identity issue instilled by Europeans who have made the world to derogate all that is of color darker than the White skin of race. The same goes for someone who will say that just because I talk about racial issues means I have "Identity Issue" could not have been so far from the truth. In fact when one denies bieng of or abstain from a certain racial leneage by accpeting all others before the ones they resent and like to defame is the one exact proof of self-loathing and dientity issue indeed. Not hte other way around.


As I see things, you're experiencing, like many african americans that come to our shores, a cultural shock, because you're unable to comprehend our reasons for NOT accepting the cursed one drop rule. Worse, you're seeing our refusal to accept it as an insult to african americans or any other african community in general, asking yourself: How dare they?. Can't you just accept the fact that this cursed pseudoscientific crap will never take hold in the dominican psyche?
Edited on 4/11/2009 5:37 PM by Lautaro.
"A man who strives after goodness in all his acts is sure to come to ruin, since there are so many men who are not good."

Niccolo Macchiavelli - The Prince

Post IP: 190.0.86.2*
#27 - Posted 11 April 2009, 5:59 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, La Union
Join date: July 2008
Member #: 1028
Posts: 1284
Send Message
RE: What It Says For Race On DR's ID Card?
Quote:
Lautaro previously said:

Quote:
AfroLatino previously said:

Quote:
Gizmo previously said:

Cibaeño75
Mi cedula me declara "blanco".

AFROLATINO
Responde a me de verdad por favor mi amigo. Hay todas las cedulas declaran los gentes de Republica Dominicana "Blanco"?

Do all or the general ID of the mass populace declare them as "White" and are you in fact or actually consider yourself "White" for real?
Does a White European descent view you as "White"?

GIZMO
AfroLatino "Does a White European descent view you as "White"? You know AfroLatino Europe doesn't have a racket on whiteness or white as a color. If you're color is white than you're genetic make up has a relation to Europe. Just as if you're pigmentation is dark brown or black and you're traits are those of Africans, then your genetic make up has a relation to Africa. The same question?"Likewise does a Black African descent view you as "Black"? Remember the Dominican Republic is a country with an array of colors and shades and hair textures, trigueños are part of that mix also. So when you talk about Dominicans we are a rich array of colors and races. NOT SIMPLY BLACK AND WHITE.





Indeed, most Black African descent people in the US who sees a person of color more often than not just see them as Black, unless they are outspokenly have something of pure evidence to tell them otherwise. Whereas a White person, no matter how closer light skin you are to them or just half mixed still see one as either simply Black or colored as well and never as white like themselves. Indeed with that premise I rest my case. So, why Dominicans like to claim they are all kinds of flattered races or ethnicities as you put it "rich array of colors and races" (not to say that it is not true) before they can accept or not to ever accept being of African leneage or even as people of color is in fact a mind sickness and an identity issue instilled by Europeans who have made the world to derogate all that is of color darker than the White skin of race. The same goes for someone who will say that just because I talk about racial issues means I have "Identity Issue" could not have been so far from the truth. In fact when one denies bieng of or abstain from a certain racial leneage by accpeting all others before the ones they resent and like to defame is the one exact proof of self-loathing and dientity issue indeed. Not hte other way around.


As I see things, you're experiencing, like many african americans that come to our shores, a cultural shock, because you're unable to comprehend our reasons for NOT accepting the cursed one drop rule. Worse, you're seeing our refusal to accept it as an insult to african americans or any other african community in general, asking yourself: How dare they?. Can't you just accept the fact that this cursed pseudoscientific crap will never take hold in the dominican psyche?



Indeed it may never take hold, but it does not constitute to be justifiably right regardless of whom would like to view it from any standing point. Again may the words you have used in this small excerp be of self judging matter.
Post IP: 66.90.104.7*
#28 - Posted 11 April 2009, 7:15 PM
Location: United States, new england mass.
Join date: March 2009
Member #: 2358
Posts: 71
Send Message
RE: What It Says For Race On DR's ID Card?
"""""No es asi de simple, Afrolatino. I view racial purity as something very sacred, that only happens once, when the bloodline got mixed, it's mixed and there is nothing that can be done about it but dilluting it to the point where your descendant is 99%+ percent that race. You don't belong to the black race because the genuine black race(Negroid)is something like Mugabe and Mandela with the shiny face and yellow sclera rather than Will Smith and Tyra Banks looking mofos. Many Ethiopians, Egyptians and Sudanese are of mixed Moorish/Negrid lineage, which explains the rather normal-looking noses they now posess and suggests that they are mutts. In conclusion, Johnny Ventura, David Ortiz and Pena gomez are technically black. Milly Quezada, Hector Acosta and Manny Ramirez aren't more than Eurafrican mutts""""""




true. thats right gangsta. im a proud eurafrican mutt LoL

Edited on 4/11/2009 7:19 PM by delgadoMASS.
Post IP: 75.67.13.17*
#29 - Posted 11 April 2009, 7:18 PM
Location: United States, new england mass.
Join date: March 2009
Member #: 2358
Posts: 71
Send Message
RE: What It Says For Race On DR's ID Card?
"""""No es asi de simple, Afrolatino. I view racial purity as something very sacred, that only happens once, when the bloodline got mixed, it's mixed and there is nothing that can be done about it but dilluting it to the point where your descendant is 99%+ percent that race. You don't belong to the black race because the genuine black race(Negroid)is something like Mugabe and Mandela with the shiny face and yellow sclera rather than Will Smith and Tyra Banks looking mofos. Many Ethiopians, Egyptians and Sudanese are of mixed Moorish/Negrid lineage, which explains the rather normal-looking noses they now posess and suggests that they are mutts. In conclusion, Johnny Ventura, David Ortiz and Pena gomez are technically black. Milly Quezada, Hector Acosta and Manny Ramirez aren't more than Eurafrican mutts""""""




true. thats right gangsta. im a proud eurafrican mutt LoL



Post IP: 75.67.13.17*
#30 - Posted 14 April 2009, 1:03 PM
Location: United States
Join date: February 2008
Member #: 340
Posts: 1192
Send Message
RE: What It Says For Race On DR's ID Card?
Quote:
AfroLatino previously said:

Duh, if you have not been paying attention and not doing your own selective reading you will see that I said that Nationality does not mean race or ethnicity. Dominicans falls under "latino" and the race is still "colored" or "Negros" no matter how much many Dominicans try to deviate from the facts or flatter other ethnic self labeled categories such as Indio. If that was this simple then the whole world would come up possibly not really having specific races, and ethnics.

Duh yourself, I went much further than that. I just laid out all pertinent facts and I see you've managed to apply your own biased Afrocentric viewpoint with a dash of your self-identification confusion/complexes.
What LatinAmerican country uses the 'colored' label? Why are you using foreign ethnoracial labels (USA & S. Africa?) on DR? It is you who did selective reading, did you skip over the fact that Dominicans do not=a single race/color, so why are you:
a) Generalizing the entire population of a nation by calling them 'colored or Negros'
b) Mocking their self-identification because they don't fit into your distorted definition.
Quote:
Indeed, Haitians areconsidered latinos because being latino does nopt belong to those who speak spanish alone, but all the Romance languages or any dielects that derrived from any particular Romance languages such as French, Spanish, Italian and Portugues. Go read about it. It is not up to those who speak only Spanish to decide who is part of that category or not. Plain and simple, because muchlike you havein Brazil the "AfroLatinos" that is what Haitians are if they were to not want to simply refer to themselves as only latinos thus to give recognition to their African roots. So once again you have contradicting yourself by this last statement upon which justified and where my case rests "ironically" (indeed lol).

I'd like to hear from some Haitians on this forum, I've never heard of a Haitian being considered Latino or even self-identifying as such. I have no idea what you're trying to say in the rest of your post.
Post IP: 68.197.226.22*