Dominican Today Forum » Living in the DR » General Info » Jean Jacques Dessalines: Slaughter of whites & Toussaint Louverture
#141 - Posted 16 April 2009, 12:02 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo
Join date: December 2007
Member #: 38
Posts: 5613
Send Message
RE: Jean Jacques Dessalines: Slaughter of whites
Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:

Quote:
Manhattanite previously said:

Poverty under your countrymen is not worse than slavery under racial supremacists. Also Haiti's condition today is not a direct result of events 200 years ago. You do not have to go too far back into the 20th C. to find a saner, more orderly Haiti, even if it was still poor. Once again I ask that we not let the provocations of the Dessalines fan club force us into condemning brutalized slaves taking care of business on their own turf. I don't think our beef should be with their revolution but with the destructive decision to interfere in our side in such a bloody manner.

Caonabo I had said you face an uphill battle, but honestly you are digging yourself deeper into a trench. If there is any historian in the universe who can convince Dominicans to respect this Dessalines you must accept that it isn't you on this forum. Right now all you are inspiring is more dislike of your nation's revolutionary history by arguing we should admire this guy who to us represents the dark side of that history.


Manny, I thoroughly respect the Haitian Revolution and hold some of the figures it produced in reverance. Contrary to many Dominicans I revere the figure of Touissant for I respect what the man accomplished and his goals. With that said I know damn well who Dessalines was and as such I will continue, until the end of my days, refer to his person as a butcher and murderer for those are fitting epitaphs for the likes of him. And you are quite correct about early 20th century Haiti, As a matter of fact US controlled Puerto Rico had a higher poverty rate in the early 30s, after nearly four decades of American tutlegae, than that of Haiti in the same era.


It just goes to show that it's true what some people say about the victors being the ones which write history. Had Toussaint prevailed, they'd be singing a whole different tune, I'm sure.
"A man who strives after goodness in all his acts is sure to come to ruin, since there are so many men who are not good."

Niccolo Macchiavelli - The Prince

Post IP: 200.88.48.3*
Advertisement
Sponsored Links
#142 - Posted 16 April 2009, 12:13 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, La Union
Join date: July 2008
Member #: 1028
Posts: 1284
Send Message
RE: Jean Jacques Dessalines: Slaughter of whites
Quote:
generoso previously said:

Lautaro:
The sad thing about their contaminated black supremacists thoughts trying to justify the genocide on the eastern part of Saint Domingue, is now beside claiming our "ignorance of the real motives", and we "do not understand the dangers that the Haitian revolution was facing", so that in their minds justifies........
'THE SLAUGHTERING OF THOUSANDS OF RESIDENTS OF THE EASTERN SIDE OF THE ISLAND
EVEN THOUGH THEY WERE WOMEN AND CHILDREN "JUST IN CASE" was justified because after
all they could have bred more men that could have become soldiers and hurt their "glorious" revolution.
Incredible, just incredible, the warped mindset. We even have a failed boring half Haitian poet posting similar garbage.



All European conquerers (invaders such as Spain, France, Great Britain, Italy and Portugal) killed and committed more worse atrocities and were doing it just because with no cause, yet I have not once seen any Dominicans in here demonize them for their epics of killings around the world. Those same Europeans who anahilate ethnic races to extinctions and more...
Post IP: 55.209.28.17*
#143 - Posted 16 April 2009, 1:19 PM
Location: United States
Join date: February 2008
Member #: 336
Posts: 1984
Send Message
RE: Jean Jacques Dessalines: Slaughter of whites
Quote:
AfroLatino previously said:


All European conquerers (invaders such as Spain, France, Great Britain, Italy and Portugal) killed and committed more worse atrocities and were doing it just because with no cause, yet I have not once seen any Dominicans in here demonize them for their epics of killings around the world. Those same Europeans who anahilate ethnic races to extinctions and more...


You have not seen it because as I told you, you do not read our posts. Not once? Nobody? This is a lie.
I'm sorry, I can't hear you over the sound of how awesome I am.

http://twitter.com/ergface
Post IP: 206.252.74.4*
#144 - Posted 16 April 2009, 1:21 PM
Location: United States, New York City
Join date: February 2008
Member #: 411
Posts: 5683
Send Message
RE: Jean Jacques Dessalines: Slaughter of whites
Quote:
Manhattanite previously said:

Quote:
AfroLatino previously said:


All European conquerers (invaders such as Spain, France, Great Britain, Italy and Portugal) killed and committed more worse atrocities and were doing it just because with no cause, yet I have not once seen any Dominicans in here demonize them for their epics of killings around the world. Those same Europeans who anahilate ethnic races to extinctions and more...


You have not seen it because as I told you, you do not read our posts. Not once? Nobody? This is a lie.


Exactly.
"If you're going through hell, keep going." - Winston Churchill
Post IP: 161.185.150.17*
#145 - Posted 16 April 2009, 1:26 PM
Location: United States
Join date: December 2008
Member #: 1813
Posts: 234
Send Message
RE: Jean Jacques Dessalines: Slaughter of whites
Quote:
AfroLatino previously said:

All European conquerers (invaders such as Spain, France, Great Britain, Italy and Portugal) killed and committed more worse atrocities and were doing it just because with no cause, yet I have not once seen any Dominicans in here demonize them for their epics of killings around the world. Those same Europeans who anahilate ethnic races to extinctions and more...


Those atrocities commited by the European powers are disgusting aren't they? I agree but what I find interesting is that you point to a greater more sinister example as if to down play or justify the actions of Dessalines. You're post is just plain finger pointing as if to try and distract from the main topic at hand.

Murdering innocent people for whatever reason is disgusting, simple as that.
Edited on 4/16/2009 1:28 PM by joblitsky.
Post IP: 69.204.227.11*
#146 - Posted 16 April 2009, 1:31 PM
Location: United States, New York City
Join date: February 2008
Member #: 411
Posts: 5683
Send Message
RE: Jean Jacques Dessalines: Slaughter of whites
Quote:
joblitsky previously said:

Quote:
AfroLatino previously said:

All European conquerers (invaders such as Spain, France, Great Britain, Italy and Portugal) killed and committed more worse atrocities and were doing it just because with no cause, yet I have not once seen any Dominicans in here demonize them for their epics of killings around the world. Those same Europeans who anahilate ethnic races to extinctions and more...


Those atrocities commited by the European powers are disgusting aren't they? I agree but what I find interesting is that you point to a greater more sinister example as if to down play or justify the actions of Dessalines. You're post is just plain finger pointing as if to try and distract from the main topic at hand.

Murdering innocent people for whatever reason is disgusting, simple as that.


Bottom goddamn line.
"If you're going through hell, keep going." - Winston Churchill
Post IP: 161.185.150.17*
#147 - Posted 16 April 2009, 1:46 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, La Union
Join date: July 2008
Member #: 1028
Posts: 1284
Send Message
RE: Jean Jacques Dessalines: Slaughter of whites
Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:


Bottom goddamn line.


So how come with all the defaming threads many of you have started denigrading other nations' forfathers such as principally of those that of Haiti, yet why none/ zero/ ziltch threads have been errected to expose for the evil deeds of Europeans like or such as of Spain, France, Great Britain, Italy and Portugal for their atrocities around the world? Rather instead having thier leneage is adored, glorified and embraced while making a pariah of the African leneage? Or is for most Dominicans guilt, resentment and ethnic loathing of everything thatis African and black also the bottom goddamn line for that as well while making the ways of those Europeans the divine supreme above all, justifiable?
Post IP: 55.209.28.17*
#148 - Posted 16 April 2009, 2:07 PM
Location: United States, New York City
Join date: February 2008
Member #: 411
Posts: 5683
Send Message
RE: Jean Jacques Dessalines: Slaughter of whites
Quote:
AfroLatino previously said:

Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:


Bottom goddamn line.


So how come with all the defaming threads many of you have started denigrading other nations' forfathers such as principally of those that of Haiti, yet why none/ zero/ ziltch threads have been errected to expose for the evil deeds of Europeans like or such as of Spain, France, Great Britain, Italy and Portugal for their atrocities around the world? Rather instead having thier leneage is adored, glorified and embraced while making a pariah of the African leneage? Or is for most Dominicans guilt, resentment and ethnic loathing of everything thatis African and black also the bottom goddamn line for that as well while making the ways of those Europeans the divine supreme above all, justifiable?



Again, you only read what you want. If you were to follow my posts you would see that I'm no freind of Spain and that I have denounced her atrocities time and again.
"If you're going through hell, keep going." - Winston Churchill
Post IP: 161.185.150.17*
#149 - Posted 16 April 2009, 2:16 PM
Location: Dominican Republic, La Union
Join date: July 2008
Member #: 1028
Posts: 1284
Send Message
RE: Jean Jacques Dessalines: Slaughter of whites
Quote:
cibaeño75 previously said:


Again, you only read what you want. If you were to follow my posts you would see that I'm no freind of Spain and that I have denounced her atrocities time and again.



Well, I would not be the only person to be accused of "selective reading" on here since many of us seem to be doing a lot of that in here quite so often so eager to try to disclaim one another on many issues placing blames. However, I would say you are the one and the first to have ever done so denouncing Euro-Spania' evil deeds as one of the Europrean packs of whores that she is.
Edited on 4/16/2009 2:17 PM by AfroLatino.
Post IP: 55.209.28.17*
#150 - Posted 16 April 2009, 2:31 PM
Location: United States
Join date: July 2008
Member #: 1126
Posts: 975
Send Message
RE: Jean Jacques Dessalines: Slaughter of whites
Quote:
Manhattanite previously said:

Poverty under your countrymen is not worse than slavery under racial supremacists. Also Haiti's condition today is not a direct result of events 200 years ago. You do not have to go too far back into the 20th C. to find a saner, more orderly Haiti, even if it was still poor. Once again I ask that we not let the provocations of the Dessalines fan club force us into condemning brutalized slaves taking care of business on their own turf. I don't think our beef should be with their revolution but with the destructive decision to interfere in our side in such a bloody manner.

Caonabo I had said you face an uphill battle, but honestly you are digging yourself deeper into a trench. If there is any historian in the universe who can convince Dominicans to respect this Dessalines you must accept that it isn't you on this forum. Right now all you are inspiring is more dislike of your nation's revolutionary history by arguing we should admire this guy who to us represents the dark side of that history.

Manny,
I am not a historian and not pretending to be either. I am looking at the past events from the standpoint of the masses for Liberation and Independence at a basic common sense level. I am not trying to convince Dominicans to respect Dessalines but speak out about what he stood firmly for in terms of Liberation, Independence and Freedom for the masses. Some of the posters here are exclusively concerned about what happened to their white ancestors, a very narrow-minded and selfish view of extraordinary events at the time. I do not condone oppression, repression or killing of masses, or hurting children and women, at any time, past, present or future, never. The question is Was our REAL FEAR of a resurgent campaign to take back Haiti by France or Spain justified? Dessalines's campaign put an end to slavery there and also weakened the pro-Spain royalists in the eastern part. This was a class war. Could there have been collateral damage whereby unintended casualties occurred? Very likely. I would differenciate those from how the pro-Spain royalists -here we are talking about the big wigs- were dealt with.
The problem is the way some pseudo-historians with the Dominican elite have packaged the whole thing in a very biased way and have disseminated a very narrow-minded and racist view, They have served that to the Dominican masses from generation to generation till today creating hatred, hostilities, negative attitudes not simply toward Dessalines, the Father of the Haitian Nation, but to all poor Haitians including the Haitian Immigrant Workers in the DR. How hypocritical! While they are doing that, they have organized the most elaborate network of smugglers/brokers to recruit hundreds of thousands of Haitians in Haiti to be smuggled to the DR to replenish the cheap labor supply/pool to create their wealth through the most vicious form of exploitation.
The tactics used have been to frame the whole issue as a Dominicans against Haitians thing. You are either pro-Dominican or pro-Haitian, just like that. That's basically scientifically false. We cannot look at Dominicans in general as we cannot look at Haitians in general. There are classes in the DR as much as there are in Haiti. The poor Dominican and Haitian workers and peasants have way much more in common with each other than with their respective oppressors and exploiters, the Dominican and Haitian elite. They are as we say in Haiti, "milk and lemon" . You may already know what happens when you mix the two alone. It is to their own detriment for the oppressed to look at history with the same narrow minded, selfish and racist lens as their oppressors and exploiters. Once the Dominican masses are able to differenciate and liberate themselves from the stranglehold of the Dominican elite in their view of events, they will be in a much better position to identify who the real enemies are.
Post IP: 64.12.116.6*