SANTO DOMINGO.- The deputy Pelegrín Castillo and the French journalist Jean Michel Caroit agreed yesterday in affirming that Dominican Republic has not assumed a correct defense against the groups of human rights who "unjustly" accuse it of practicing xenophobia and racism against the Haitians resident here.
Both agreed, in addition, that in the same measure that those types of accusations against the country have increased internationally, the common border is increasingly vulnerable to the traffic of undocumented Haitians.
They criticized that the country has not implemented a new Immigration Law and the absence of a repatriations policy with the international agreements that it has signed in that regard, with which it could confront the organisms and the international community with a greater weight.
However, they marked his differences as to the reasons behind the information such as the one by Amnesty International, because while Caroit states that it doesn’t obey to a campaign of disrepute against the country, Castillo said that they are based on a perspective of “reductionism, false and superficial which in objective terms lends itself to the machinations and manipulations of other interests, other agendas."
Castillo said that the country’s defensive attitude is unacceptable because “if there is a country which is being victimized from an international crisis it’s Dominican Republic."
Caroit, Caribbean correspondent of the French newspaper Le Monde, interviewed by Manuel Jiménez on Channel 27, feels that that report in fact doesn’t involve an accusation against the Dominican Republic, instead a focus on the situation of the Haitians in the country, regarding repatriations and the problem of the children of Haitians born in the country who don’t have legal existence.
"I believe that the Dominican Republic doesn’t know how to defend itself and I also believe that those human rights organizations unjustly accuse this country of racial discrimination. How he can have racial discrimination in this country that is probably the world’s most mulatto," the French journalist said.
Castillo again criticized the fact that great powers like United States, France and Canada have been irresponsible with Haiti and that instead of contributing to rebuild the neighboring country they try to use the Dominican Republic as a "pivot State" for a solution to those problems.
The official warned that Haiti has become an "insolvent State" and suffers from the entire hemisphere’s most serious problems ranging from an ecological disaster to being controlled by the international underworld.
He added that the Haitian case isn’t merely humanitarian problem, "but an international crisis.”
From: Santo Domingo
"I believe that the Dominican Republic doesn’t know how to defend itself and I also believe that those human rights organizations unjustly accuse this country of racial discrimination. How he can have racial discrimination in this country that is probably the world’s most mulatto," the French journalist said.
Spoken like a true foreigner with little knowledge of Dominican culture. His characterization of Dominican demographics is accurate but he doesn't realize that few Dominicans agree.
From: Bronx, New York
Every Dominican should defend the country's reputation. We must tell the truth about our society. To those who speak of slavery and apartheid in our country, they are telling you that they do not know what those two aberration of human history was as an inhumane political system. There is class discrimination in DR. There is also, racial discrimination in DR. What you do not have is a government policy of racial and class discrimination. Guess what? That is also what you have in the U.S.
Written by: nico, 26 Mar 2007 7:11 PM
From: .
The Dominican Republic's defence of its national interests in general is weak. No real nation should let a foreign force or organization dictate them. The DR needs leadership. I hope that Pelegrin Castillo becomes president one day, he has what it takes.
From: Plantation, Florida
Be it known that the Dominican Republic granted almost 70,000 visas to haitian national last year. How many visas were granted to haitians by France ? Italy ? England ? Germany ? Japan ? China ? United States ? Need I say anymore ?
MAY GOD BLESS OUR DOMINICAN REPUBLIC.
Written by: Dag, 26 Mar 2007 10:24 PM
From: NYC
The DR can not defend itself against such accusations because it does not have the means to do and because it knows that in the process of self defense and investigations the truth would come out. As a Black Dominican and successfull migrant in the US, I tend to agree that there is an under the rug racial sentiment in the US. On the other hand that sentiment does not deny you a good education, student aid, right to won property and rise up in the social bracket. In DR blacks don't get chance
From: New York
I can tell that R.L. Trujillo was successful at brainwashing a lot of Dominicans just by reading the openly racist opinions that seem to be so common here. Those who know history will recall that one of Trujillo's dreams was to bring in a majority of whites from Spain and elsewhere to"europeanize" the DR,in other words to turn it white .A lot of Dominicans are refusing to Haitians in the DR the same rights that Dominicans enjoy in the US.Is a child born in the US an American or a Dominican ?
From: Brooklyn
dag, are you sure you're dominican? because if you were you'd realize that black dominicans are prominent in EVERY facet of the country's national life...no one would be able to confuse a group picture of the dominican senate with a group of spaniards, that's for sure.what you've stated is simply not true.
From: Bogota N.J.
To: Dag from NYC
you made it in the USA so did I ,but don't under estimate D.R.
There you have a lots of profesionals at no cost of education
and they are from the poor sector ,black as well as mulattos.
You would have to understand the circumstances and no
comparison to a Capitalist country such as this one . Over here
we have the means and because it is so well organized we could get ahead, Furthermore what you said is not true" as a black person you don't have a chance over there "
From: Bogota N.J.
To Lazaro Hidalgo
from Plantation Fl.
I see you are well informed as to how many visas were granted to Haitian naional . At least some one is doing his h.w.
All this started in San Jose Costa Rica ,but i don't see the "Org-
anization of American States"forcing visas of Haitian origen into their country. If they are so worry about the situation, shouln't they also help a little? instead of false accusation forced on by the big powers...They don't want them in Fl.but
have taken cubans.
From: California
We live in a society which is very racist and sometimes even inhumane towards people of a darker skinned color and lower socio-economic status. People are no better than they were hundreds of years ago. The simple thing is that public policy has changed. The DR is raicst and prejudiced just like the American society, and just like the French society. The only way to truly overcome this prejudice is to respect and treat people similarly because in the end, we are naught but the same.
From: Santiago, Santiago
Amnesty International's accusations are couched in what is called "Emotional Appeal".
They are totally disregarding the stipulations of the Dominican Constitution with regard to the basis underwhich Citizenship is awarded to residents.
Their logic is one of "Fallacious Reasoning" and "Comparative Law and Mores of Society". How they can accuse this or any other government of "descrimination" is untenable in light of the Constitutional Law of theland.
It's "International Politics", plainly.
From: NY
This is great dialogue. Few points: Criticism of public policy should not be taken as criticism of a nation. It should be taken as input or impetus to start an evaluation of sub-optimal policies. Being defensive is the worst situation. Second, the fact that the DR grants visas to Hatians, doesn't mean that there are no human rights violations. Third, in the DR there have not been obvert racial policies, but racism is embedded in the society, despite having the myth of social mobility throuh--
From: NY
--through miscegination. The fact that you have a few blacks and mulattoes in the upper-echelons does not deny the millions who remain excluded, and the disproportinate benefits derived by whites. Racism is in the language (cabello bueno y malo, etc.), it is part of media, it is part and parcel of the Dominican society. However, the myth of mobilization, of "mejorar la raza", has promoted acceptance of racist practices. The lack of official discriminatory policies, like in the US & S. Africa--
From: NY
-- S. Africa has impaired race to become a source of identity and political mobilization: how can you combat something that is invisible? Foucault says that invisible power mechanisms are the most effective.
Anthony Marx's "Race and Nation" is an excellent book that discusses these issues. I recommend it highly.
We need to recognize the racialization of oppression & poverty, and mobilize to address such inhumane practices against ALL human beings.
From: Santo Domingo
The real crisis is that children of Haitians who were born here do not even have citizenship rights in Haiti. They are officially stateless. The assumption that all nations grant citizenship to children born on their soil is in error. Many simply give an option. There are routes to citizenship here but many of the workers who come here are illiterate. Interested in working on the issue? Contact me at lizieames@yahoo.com
Written by: Kate, 4 Apr 2007 3:35 PM
From: NH
Just because some Dominicans enter the U.S. illegally and are allowed to stay here illegally, doesn't mean that Dominican Republic should do the same with Haitians. If the U.S. doesn't exercise their laws of exporting illegals, that's their problem. Dominican Republic is a very poor country and too many of its citizens live in poverty for it to allow almost 1million Haitians and still coming, to live there illegally. Dominican Republic cannot and should not have to absorb the poverty ot Haiti
From: New York
I am afraid you got it wrong,Kate .If that was up to me there would not be one Haitian citizen in the DR,there would be no trade and no interaction between our nations.We Haitians,although the so-called poorest in the Americas,are proud nation with a rich culture enjoyed by those able to apreciate it.Because of Dominican anti-Haitianism I see no need for our people to even keep diplomatic relations.Your view that Haitians have no rights shows how wide the gap is between reason and passion.
From: Atlanta
The logical soluton in my opinion and one that is eventual is the disolvement of the Dominican Republic, it's flag and it's racist identity. The creation of a new nation, free of the foundation of bigotry cemented in place by Juan Pablo Duarte up until today is the problem. The word "Dominican" from St. Dominic's Order of Preachers has been representative of bigotry and hate since the invention of the word. Until the nation of the Dominican Republic is elminiated; racism and hate will continu
Spoken like a true foreigner with little knowledge of Dominican culture. His characterization of Dominican demographics is accurate but he doesn't realize that few Dominicans agree.
MAY GOD BLESS OUR DOMINICAN REPUBLIC.
you made it in the USA so did I ,but don't under estimate D.R.
There you have a lots of profesionals at no cost of education
and they are from the poor sector ,black as well as mulattos.
You would have to understand the circumstances and no
comparison to a Capitalist country such as this one . Over here
we have the means and because it is so well organized we could get ahead, Furthermore what you said is not true" as a black person you don't have a chance over there "
from Plantation Fl.
I see you are well informed as to how many visas were granted to Haitian naional . At least some one is doing his h.w.
All this started in San Jose Costa Rica ,but i don't see the "Org-
anization of American States"forcing visas of Haitian origen into their country. If they are so worry about the situation, shouln't they also help a little? instead of false accusation forced on by the big powers...They don't want them in Fl.but
have taken cubans.
They are totally disregarding the stipulations of the Dominican Constitution with regard to the basis underwhich Citizenship is awarded to residents.
Their logic is one of "Fallacious Reasoning" and "Comparative Law and Mores of Society". How they can accuse this or any other government of "descrimination" is untenable in light of the Constitutional Law of theland.
It's "International Politics", plainly.
Anthony Marx's "Race and Nation" is an excellent book that discusses these issues. I recommend it highly.
We need to recognize the racialization of oppression & poverty, and mobilize to address such inhumane practices against ALL human beings.