Close Gallery
Haitian carnaval girls, Photo minustah.org
Zoom Picture

The very ones sent to preserve and protect in times of desperation are sometimes seen as the oppressor

Haiti stands out as one of the poorest and most underdeveloped countries in the western hemisphere suffering from unheard of poverty which at times grapples the mind and makes it hard to comprehend. Still on top of all of the disparity that the poor suffer, sexual assault of women and young girls persist as a ramped crime initiated against the defenseless that continues to go unpunished and unrestrained both from a domestic perspective and internationally.

As reported by the BBC in Dec 2006, accusations in 2004, later unfounded were brought against a Minustah UN force soldier by a 16 year old Haitian girl who said she was raped by the Brazilian soldier.

The very ones sent to preserve and protect in times of desperation are sometimes seen as the oppressor and participant in the continued exploitation of the poor, contributing to more controversy and confusion in the wave of violence that has engulfed the region.

From Port Au Prince to City Soleil gangs of armed young men roam the dark unlit streets at night attacking women indiscriminately and contributing to the fear and terror. The government remains to be caught in an odd position as members of the Haitian police force have also been accused and convicted of committing violent acts of rape, making it easy to understand why rape often goes unreported. The question remains why no response to the call for help by the persecuted and what can be done to put an end to these violent attacks?

The shame and stigma is a heavy burden to bear for the victims and the reality of imminent death is felt as a real possibility by those who may want to persecute their attackers as well as seek help. Why is violence perpetrated against women in such an inhumane manner and what can be done to stop violent sexual attacks in a country ravaged by a history of coup d’etat overthrows where rape was used as a tactic of terror for those in authority, to subdue the civilian populations into submission.

All of this sounds very reminiscent of the Congo and the ongoing conflict that has also used rape, collective violence and sexual attacks and mutilations to strike fear in the hearts of the voiceless. In the case of Haiti policy initiated since 2005 made rape a crime but then why is it that attackers still run free?

The disparaging statistics show that though over a hundred rapes may be reported a year, only 12 may actually go to trial. Part of the problem seems to be a lack of political will on behalf of the judiciary. In a country such as Haiti where there is no safety net to catch the poor and civil society possess few resources for redress, help is needed from outsiders such as those within the international community to speak out against such violent attacks against women and to give a voice to the voiceless.

Amnesty international can continue to do its part to advocate on behalf of human rights abuses but those in power internationally who feel a moral obligation to put an end to apathetic approaches of the past whereby Haitian suffering is seen and felt as almost surreal and intangible, must step up and speak out. The violence in Haiti can also almost assuredly be viewed as a desperate call for help by both perpetrator and victim, both of which suffer in extreme conditions of poverty and both who view little hope for the future.

Perhaps extraordinary evil is committed by ordinary human beings who happen in this case to live in inhumane conditions and thus result to animalistic behavior. Perhaps they are ordinary men, who have fallen to the lowest level of inhumanity, who run in packs and seek refuge in collectives attacking their prey simply because they can and times are hard. Even in the west the economic down surge is seeing an increase in crime and violence against women is on the rise. Whatever the reason violence against women and children must end and just maybe, the UN’s Ambassador to the Mission.

Written by: Sonya Shannon
Share / Recommend this article: FacebookFacebook Digg thisDigg this del.icio.usdel.icio.us TechnoratiTechnorati YahooYahoo Facebook
COMMENTS
14 comment(s)
Written by: iCare, 5 Jul 2009 3:25 PM
From: Dominican Republic, Altamonte Springs FL, USA
Well. At least you have a crystaline example of what america could potentially fall to when the money disappears(as we are all, after all, no less or more "human" than the next. ) what do even americans say deperate times call for... that concept is practically a proverb in the US. Don't worry. I bring you a mutual hope. On the other side of that island is a body of people experiencing somewhat similar elements while refusing to resort to those lows as a majority. So what we have is your two most effective options when coping with a depressed state of being; you can acknoledge your desperation as a try of faith, and use your belief system to guide the reenforcement of the common morals set forth; or you can use the depression as a direct form of inspiration, thus developing a system of motivation. Being feuled by negative energy. I like to think of the faith of a peoples like the dominicans as if it was a type of filter for elements like depression and desperation. Grow.
Written by: dagtan, 30 Jul 2009 1:38 PM
From: United States
Well you must first look at the conditions on the ground in Haiti. The country is really going trhought a phse that it is hard to define or put into plain language. However, paper takes what ever you put on it without any regrets of warnings, so it is simple to wrtie about the issue without addressing the possible origins of such behaviors. The Haitian situation is not acceptable and the behaviors of people could be attribute to a whole series of resons and feelings. I believe that it is time for the intenational community concentrate on the haitian issue and put their money where it is worth. The first country that needs to step up to the plate is France, since they have a direct link to Haiti's history and past. Moreover, the United States must intervene in the dowward spirral in which Haiti finds itself today. This country can still be developed and normalized and hoepfully it would become stable under a stables rule. I believe that France or the US should take over temp.
Written by: Pepe32, 6 Aug 2009 2:32 PM
From: Dominican Republic
Temp for maybe 100 years...
Written by: dagtan, 8 Aug 2009 9:58 PM
From: United States
pepe32, I was recently back in the DR for 20 days total, visiting my relatives in Santiago and enjoying a nice long vacation at one of the resorts in POP. One thing that I was able to notice is how successful the government has been in displaying the Haitian problem as self created and that Haiti is all negative and bad. Even my family which has always being fairly liberal and understanding of the Haitian issues has been shifting to a more militant stage towards Haitians. When I asked, why the shift? they all cited government and news reports as to how infectious Haitians are to the DR. This is some dangerous game the DR and its government is playing. it seems to me that you would love for Haiti to be taken over for long period of time and hopefully it will be off your plate. However, even if there is a temp takeover, it will not limit the dominican responsibility on create a fair and square migration policy toward these people. I guess that if one day the Americans decide,
Written by: dagtan, 8 Aug 2009 10:03 PM
From: United States
not to recognize any child born from of the 400k plus illegal Dominicans in NYC alone, I will have no right to cry out foul. Or if the Americans one day decide to drive their police trucks through the Washington heights area and pick up the illegal Dominicans, put them in plane and send them back to DR without telling their families or without affording them their due process, then I can not cry out foul. One message for you guys who support such injustices against the Haitians, we are watching here and the American people is watching as well. As things get worse here the more and more they will love to Dominicans what Dominicans do to Haitians, it is just cheaper and more effective. So one day it might be your illegal friend, or uncle or brother or sister. I think that most Dominicans either know or have an illegal relative in the U.S. or some other country.
Written by: Pepe32, 9 Aug 2009 11:44 PM
From: Dominican Republic
Dagtan,I feel that the US government has every right as a sovereign nation to do EXACTLY as you say although I don't have any relatives in that situation since my family left long ago I believe firmly that every nation has the right to protect it's borders from UNINVITED people who enter without any documentation or investigation whatsoever.

Also every comparison between immigration to the USA (The most powerful nation on earth and our impoverished nation is without basis and their is also the obvious historical context of the multiple Haitian invasions of DR and their constitution speaking of on nation (meaning a claim on our territory) and the obvious demographic avalanche which overwhelms our already fragile infratructure and support system.

Also Haitian are mainly a net negative for our nation given that every Haitian entering DR ,moves our nation back culturally,socially and economically and only the rich landowners and powerful businessmen benefit from the exploitation of H
Written by: Pepe32, 9 Aug 2009 11:45 PM
From: Dominican Republic
Haiti
Written by: dagtan, 11 Aug 2009 8:56 AM
From: United States
pepe32, so you are saying that due to the messy history between the DR and Haiti, the DR has a natural right to treat the haitians with distrust and to a lesser human status. If I take this point, then should we in the U.S. treat Canadians, British, French just as we treat Haitians back in the DR, becuase as you know these three particular nations had conflicts and even invaded the U.S. either directly or indirectly at one point. Second, the mexican, who still claim california, new mexico, arizona, nevada, colorado and so on as part of their country, should we simply do to them what we do to Haitians in the DR. pepe32, wehre I totally believe what you are saying is in the net negative, you see this the negative propaganda that Dominincans are falling for. How can you say that Haitians are a negative when it comes to the DR progress culturally, socially and economically. So you believe that our culture and social behaviors are superior to those of the Haitians? cont,
Written by: dagtan, 11 Aug 2009 9:01 AM
From: United States
The Nazis believe the same thing about other people, the hatred and racists groups in America today believe the same thing about us, the immigrants, including your folks. I only hope that you are not spreading such venon among the future popualtion, eventhough I feel that it has already happened. I am really down on the DR as a Dominican born person, becuase here in the U.S. we are alwys fighting for equality and respect. While back in our homeland were a bunch of bigots and racists against a weaker people. I wonder how your folks felt if they were one day discriminated or made feel of lower cultural or social leve as Americans here in the U.S. Why don't you ask them? Finally, the Haitians do the jobs that Domincans would not do in a million years, so who do you want the business community to hire to complete projects? Yet, you see many Dominicans here doing far lower jobs, but they are to proud to do it in their own homeland. pepe32, you sound racist and ignorant on this.
Written by: Pepe32, 14 Aug 2009 12:08 PM
From: Dominican Republic
Dagtan your whole post is based on misconceptions ,twisting statements and blindness to facts finished with a small dose of personal attack.I don't have the time to respond properly to your diatribe at this moment but will do so later.


Written by: Juciosa, 17 Sep 2009 12:06 PM
From: United States
dagtan, do you have a link to some of the propaganda material coming into DR? I saw a video on Youtube re: the plight of the Dominican born people of Haitian ancestry trying to apply for benefits in DR being denied.
Written by: dagtan, 17 Sep 2009 10:37 PM
From: United States
Juciosa, youtube has a lot of good materials if you look carefully. I often get my information from the United Nation's UNICEF page and resources. Moreover, I am doctoral student at Fordham University at Lincoln Center and have access to a whole lot of materials. Moreover, you also try and search the national newspapers such as the NYT,WP,LAP and many others. For starters try to get a hand on the documentary "big sugar", it gives you a rare look at the lives of Haitians in the bateyes and how the Dominican CAPATAS treats them. Finally, Juciosa, the best source is to travel to the Dominican Republic and forget about going to the beach and the river for a while and walk the streets and go to fleet markets, parks, supermarkets and observe, simply observe the dynamics of the treatment of hatians. Finally, juciosa, talk to people about the haitian issues and talk to university students about. One thing is, Dominicans tell all and have no shame in telling you what they feel about,cont
Written by: dagtan, 17 Sep 2009 10:44 PM
From: United States
about the haitians walking in the streets of taking jobs at lower wages. Due to the fact that racism toward haitians in the DR is systemic and promoted by the government, then there is little of no fear in discriminating haitians openly. Simply read as much as possible about the decisions that have been instituted in the DR to prevent haitian born from getting dominican citizenship. I have posted before on other topics about the last constitutional law signed by president Fernandez, in which it makes it legal to deny dominican citizenship to any person of mix haitian, all haitian or any other containing any haitian ancestry living in the DR.
Written by: iCare, 18 Sep 2009 11:05 AM
From: Dominican Republic, Altamonte Springs FL, USA
Woah.
Post Your Comment | Not a member? Create your account | Lost your password?
Write your opinion here. Please keep your comment relevant to this article. Please note that any comments which contain offensive language or discriminatory expressions may be edited/removed.
You must log in to post a comment:
Username Password